4 ms·
> School shooting where 3 people die = national dialogue on gun control because it's outrageous. I'm sorry, what country is this? The one I live in its just "t
by seanmcdirmid 8y ago
> School shooting where 3 people die = national dialogue on gun control because it's outrageous.
I'm sorry, what country is this? The one I live in its just "thoughts and prayers" when that happens.
- bargl 8y agoI do not understand the attack on "thoughts and prayers." There are plenty of people sending "thoughts and prayers" who also support gun control. I get that it calls out the hypocrisy of Christians who don't support gun control, but it also seems like an overly broad attack. What does someone who both believes gun control is necessary and wants to send "thoughts and prayers" do? I think the idea of gun control is a target at a solution while thoughts and prayers are meant to console the individual. Anyway, it's just something I found super annoying. I had someone who I know lost a loved one (not due to guns) and I struggled with what to say. It's a simple thing, but I realized I didn't know how to attempt to console someone anymore.
- lazyasciiart 8y agoThe attack is against high profile politicians who regularly act to block or dismiss gun control measures, but also reliably jump to announce that they are sending "thoughts and prayers" to the victims of gun attacks. I don't think this would be relevant in the case of an individual interaction. https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/20/us/thoughts-and-prayers-florida-school-shooting-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/20/us/thoughts-and-prayers-flori...
- sooper 8y agoMy (non-US) understanding of the outrage is that they feel that the person saying it is not actually going to actually keep the victims in their thoughts and prayers...
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoEven if they did, what good would it do? Unless your a friend or immediate family member there is sweet fuck all you can do to console someone in a time of grief.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIt isn't the "thoughts and prayers" part by itself, it is the "thoughts and prayers" offered by politicians and then absolutely nothing else. Even Christians can find it hypocritical: > "Prayer that doesn't lead to concrete action toward our brothers is a fruitless and incomplete prayer. [...] Prayer and action must always be profoundly united" - Pope Francis. (grabbed from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoughts_and_prayers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thoughts_and_prayers) Otherwise, that to many people the phrase has become synonymous with willful inaction is just collateral damage. It doesn't even call out the hypocrisy of christians that don't support gun control. They can believe in other ways forward, like arming all kids with guns and having them practice lots of active shooter drills, or whatever, but it is the "it is not that bad, let's not worry about it" attitude that makes people angry. The original comment I was replying to talked about a "having a national dialogue on gun control", which simply hasn't happened.
- bargl 8y agoI want to clarify something, I'm not attacking you or your comment. I'm really asking for clarity. I appreciate what you've stated. It's funny, we assume everyone uses the same definition of a phrase or slogan as we do and just by reading through the comments on this I see that's not the case.
- TimTheTinker 8y ago> hypocrisy of Christians who don't support gun control I don't see how the two equate to hypocrisy. A friend of mine (a Christian) is strongly opposed to gun control. He has a concealed carry license and carries everywhere, because he wants to have the means to protect himself and his loved ones from an active shooter, if necessary. He cites "if guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns," and feels personally affronted by gun control legislation. That, and he prays regularly for others. I for one would not accuse him of hypocrisy on that basis.
- free652 8y agoIf there are no guns then outlaws wouldn't have them.
- TimTheTinker 8y agoThat's true, but it's a bit late for that, at least in the US.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoOur gun industry produces more than 11 million guns a year. Sure, many of those wind up in Mexico and Central America via the drug trade, but that's still a lot of supply being sustained through the system. Guns wear out, simply cutting production would do a lot to reduce the number of guns in the system (outlaw or not).
- XaoDaoCaoCao 8y agoEven with our vast gun supply, the US one of the safest nations on Earth. Half of our homicides are committed by a particular minority of the population which, when removed from the picture, makes it really stark how "well behaved" a majority of Americans are in comparison to the number of guns.
- dang 8y ago
- rayiner 8y agoOr what about people who feel bad that these things happen, but believe it’s the cost of living in a free society? Every system has trade offs. You can be sympathetic about the system having downsides while still believing that the system is better than the alternatives. There is absolutely nothing inconsistent about it. To use a less charged example: developers might feel bad for novice users who get computer viruses on Windows or Mac OS. They might even help people out. And that’s entirely consistent with those sample people opposing locking down Windows and MacOS like iOS in the name of security.
- thrower123 8y agoIt really depends on whether said shooters fit a profile that is conducive to the agenda. Most of the time, they don't, and are otherwise problematic villains, because they tick the wrong census boxes or a cursory search of their social media history reveals that they have the wrong political and social opinions. And so after a day or two the story is memory-holed.
- int_19h 8y agoThat would be USA. Nothing much is happening on the federal level, because of the deadlock there. But there's plenty of new legislation on state level.
- rayiner 8y agoDo you live in a blue state? Folks are in a state of apoplexy here in Maryland. If gun ownership wasn’t written into the Constitution the overreaction would have been complete long ago. (Same thing with free speech.)