16 ms·
Twitter’s Plan to Get People to Stop Yelling at Each Other
- josefresco 8y ago> Twitter, predictably, immediately dysregulated in response. This a rant, but I hate this trend of taking what a couple/few people say and calling it "Twitter" or "everyone is saying" or "people are calling for" or "the Internet hates". Reference the actual person who said the comment and don't lump millions of users in with the comments of a few. Whenever I dig into an issue like this, I find maybe a handful of comments when the topic itself is seen by thousands/millions.
- TheTruth1234 8y ago"Trumpian" Blame the US electorate.
- yourduskquibble 8y agoHN'ers all agree ;) that modern day journalism is filled with hyperbole and unsubstantiated information.
- tyfon 8y agoThis started a long time ago, I remember during the Bush/Gore election the media using "some people say" as a intro to a topic, as if those words validated the entire thing and had to be responded to. Might have started earlier as well but I didn't watch much US news before that.
- fredsanford 8y ago1926 would like to introduce you to the National Enquirer. [0] Not the first, but the first that came to my mind... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Enquirer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Enquirer
- asdff 8y agoNot all journalism though
- ve55 8y agoIt lets them constantly drag anything out of proportion. Very often articles are written titled "Xs are Ying", where less than 1% of Xs are even considered to begin with. This is BuzzFeed (not that they're even a worse offender than most others at this point), what does one expect?
- save_ferris 8y agoIt frustrates me how often arguments like these are made without considering the economic conditions which led to publishers adopting this clickbait behavior. When the internet came in and destroyed print subscriptions and tech giants like FB/Google started controlling online advertising, getting clicks became the way to make money. We really only have ourselves to blame for choosing ad-driven media content at the expense of new dark patterns that help to prop the system up. I hate clickbait headlines too, but they work. A/B testing shows publishers that they work. What should a publisher do to create less sensational content without sacrificing revenue?
- 52-6F-62 8y agoI'm with you on this one. Don't forget people rejecting subscriptions and demanding the journalism for free. But it wasn't the internet and Google alone. It was greed, and the elevation of media properties as shareholder golden geese. They saw exponential returns in the late 90's. When revenue slowed, they lost favour with their new corporate owners and were alike choked that way.
- z3t4 8y agoAds and "click" bait predates the Internet. Topics have yet to reach the "quality" of front page headlines.
- less_penguiny 8y agoGoing non-clickbaity is not only about sacrificing revenue: it's also about sacrificing readership. Even if your only goal is readership, living in a world where the competition employs click-bait means your hands are somewhat forced.
- bluetidepro 8y agoTHIS. This is "Twitter Moments" in a nutshell, and it drives me absolutely crazy. It may be the most toxic "news-source", in my opinion, because of this. It takes a handful of tweets (usually not even verified accounts), and tries to make mountains out of molehills. It tries to drive narratives based on trends of a few "loud" users, and it's so deceiving. It rarely paints a full picture, and it tries so hard to manipulate you into believing these 12 or so tweets are the majority. And because it refreshes so quickly, they have no reason to correct things that end up being wrong, or clarify clickbait-esq topics when more info comes around.
- baroffoos 8y agoI once did the research on an article with a title in the format "X group is outraged over Y's comment on twitter" and when I found the original post I found no outrage and at most just a mild dissatisfaction.
- bluetidepro 8y agoExactly. Haha They blow everything WAY out of proportion. It's so silly. Drives me mad. ha
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- minimaxir 8y agoThe following sentence links to many tweets in Biz Stone's Twitter thread, which itself currently has 527 replies and 242 retweets ("ratioed"). It's a valid proxy for sentiment (in the majority of cases).
- Dirlewanger 8y agoExcept it's not. It's like every other Internet platform: it's the vocal minority, the 10% of the 10%. The average monetizeable Twitter user doesn't know/give a shit about this twttr redesign.
- asdff 8y agoThe people who actively tweet are the minority of a minority of Americans. https://www.pewinternet.org/2019/04/24/sizing-up-twitter-users/ https://www.pewinternet.org/2019/04/24/sizing-up-twitter-use...
- bob_doggo 8y agoYes. Or when the opinion: "group x are idiots for having opinion y." is hundreds of times more common than someone actually claiming to be an x with opinion y.
- rootusrootus 8y agoPolitical discussion in a nutshell. It's always possible to find some idiot who happens to belong to group X and holds opinion Y, and then use that to tar the rest of the group.
- derefr 8y agoI can picture a perfect Improv Everywhere scene: a bunch of people get together and practice/research statements that make them sound like they hold awful opinion Y. Then, they sneak into a political debate, or a protest that has a counter-protest... on both sides. And then they all simultaneously try to call the other group out [with the other people they came with as their specific examples] for having opinion Y.
- rootusrootus 8y agoI remember very specifically being taught about those phrases in middle school and/or high school. Weasel Words, they were called.
- dalore 8y agoHackernews is saying that comments that generalise should be specific and attributed to the person who said the comment.
- la_barba 8y agoIts a natural consequence of wanting to inflate your position when you have little to no personal authority on the matter, and essentially stealing 'authority' by supporting what amounts to an angry mob on the internet. "One person thinks this" has never really been a valuable commodity, unless that one person has some kind of name recognition.
- asdff 8y agoIt's used as a proxy for American opinion by journalists, and it's probably the worst possible proxy you could use. Only 22% of Americans use the site, and of those users 10% are responsible for 80% of tweets. Why do we care about the opinions of the loudest 2% of the population? Twitter could be blowing up according to active users, but you step outside and none of that affects you or the world at all. Everything keeps on ticking like nothings happened. https://www.pewinternet.org/2019/04/24/sizing-up-twitter-users/ https://www.pewinternet.org/2019/04/24/sizing-up-twitter-use...
- CPLX 8y agoI didn’t read the article. Does this involve unplugging the twitter servers?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rchaud 8y ago> "....learn about how not having [likes and retweets] could potentially change how people read things,” How does that change the way you interact in a conversation? That’s super interesting.” So basically, a bunch of tiny iterative UX changes that won't move the needle one bit. This is the company where moving from from 140 to 280 chars happened over the course of a decade. I feel for the product people, they are working with one hand tied behind their backs. Twitter is tailor-made for drama and outrage; nobody would be on the platform if it wasn't primarily a promotional channel; otherwise it'd just be you sending your thoughts into the void. The way Twitter currently is is because that's the balance they struck between a microblogging platform and something you can actually make money with/on. Lowest-common-denominator content is the only thing that can generate enough eyeballs to pique the interest of fly-by-night T-shirt companies and diet pill peddlers who buy ads on it.
- gipp 8y agoI'm not super optimistic about the changes, but getting rid of like/rt counts is not even close to a "tiny iterative ux change". Those counts are absolutely central to the way users interact with and understand conversation on the site. Getting rid of them completely is a massive sea change in the conversational dynamics.
- scott_s 8y agoIt was a big change for HN.
- smacktoward 8y agoAnd for Slashdot when it did so as well. Seriously, we have nearly 20 years of evidence at this point showing that, if you associate something with users’ online identities that looks like a score, they will treat it as such and start looking for ways to outscore everyone else.
- rchaud 8y ago> Those counts are absolutely central to the way users interact with and understand conversation on the site. Maybe so, but the numbers won't be hidden to the algorithm, which ultimately decides which retweets and "high-engagement" posts to show you on the timeline. I would think that has a much bigger influence on the conversation. You won't reply to something if it never makes it to your feed in the first place.
- ForHackernews 8y agoThey're declaring bankruptcy and closing up shop? "It's been an incredible journey... thanks to all the Russian hackers, spambots, intractable ideologues and lazy journalists on a deadline who've helped make Twitter such a special place these past 13 years..."
- skybrian 8y agoSimpler: stop showing tweets just because other people liked them. That's not a reshare, so it shouldn't be treated that way. More generally, discourage large conversations and encourage fragmentation.
- ihuman 8y ago> stop showing tweets just because other people liked them There's already a way to do this: use any third-party client. You even get the added bonus of a reverse-chronological timeline!
- skybrian 8y agoThat works for individuals, but the social interactions won't change unless a lot of people do it.
- bobbygoodlatte 8y agoI think this is a very important point. Even when an individual user can opt-out via settings, the societal-level impact is almost entirely determined by the defaults.
- LargeWu 8y agoIt's not just that. Timelines are generally unavoidably toxic. It's not going to stop people from retweeting things and then shouting about it, or writing condescending, smug threads starting with "We need to talk about ...".
- dvtrn 8y agoWe need to talk about people who think the phrase 'we need to talk about...' is a fruitful way to start a conversation when "In my opinion" is probably more welcoming and conducive opening to a discussion that doesn't turn into ideological jousting right from the start.
- izzydata 8y ago
- beepboopbeep 8y agoJust add a damn dislike button. Don't let obnoxious ideas go without punishment.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ihuman 8y agoWhy not just unfollow/block the person if you dislike their tweets?
- beepboopbeep 8y agoAccording to that logic I should follow every single person I agree with as well. Which is silly, and I should not be encouraged to block every person I disagree with. The like button exists for a reason. It's a simple interactive button to register my positive feeling towards a given statement. That exists unto it self. Why should a dislike button not exist as well? With no way of showing disagreement with a statement, people take to words and that's why they're yelling at each other. There's no other outlet. The reason they're not putting in a dislike button is because negativity feeds tweet activity.
- ihuman 8y agoI never said anything about agreeing or disagreeing. I suggested unfollowing/blocking someone if you dislike their tweets. Your timeline only has posts written by or endorsed by people you choose to follow. If you don't like what they are writing or endorsing, you don't have to keep them on your timeline. There's no rule that says you have to listen to "people tak[ing] to words and... yelling at each other"; you have the option to stop listening. You are in control of your timeline. Also, if you want to get rid of posts people you follow liked, most (if not all) 3rd-party apps don't show them. Some apps like Tweetbot and Twitteriffic even allow you to remove tweets with specific words from your timeline, or filter retweets.
- 8y ago
- LargeWu 8y agoTwitter mostly proves that a lot of people are not happy unless they're outraged.
- la_barba 8y agoAgree. Its just a reflection of society. You cannot legislate behavior or morality from top-down.
- vokep 8y agoOr rather a lot of people are unhappy and express this through constant outrage masked by a facade of happiness and "good vibes"
- thinkingemote 8y agoI think the reality on Twitter is that only a very few people are unhappy and outraged and a very many people without the strong emotions empathise and amplify it. This is actively encouraged and labeled in some groups by "being a good ally" for example.
- LargeWu 8y agoBut to what end? The end result of all this for me has been that I simply quit Twitter. And here's the thing: I generally agree with them, but it's so annoying I can't even engage with them anymore. So sure, maybe they're amplifying somebody's message, but I'm no longer there to hear it, no matter how loud it is. They're mostly just shouting at each other at this point.
- thinkingemote 8y agoI'm with you here, I wonder if it encourages people to shout even louder as "these people aren't listening as much any more"?
- derefr 8y agoI feel like there's a mental illness the entire world is seemingly ignoring, whose symptom is constant, floating disgust and contempt and despise. The ability to be offended by anything, because it's not the stimulus that offended you; you were already offended as an equilibrium state. Let me attempt to describe this mentality as a recipe (because I don't have a good name for it, but I'm sure you can recognize it): start by imagining clinical depression. Keep the "everything in the world sucks" part, but remove the part where you consider "everything" to include you. (This isn't narcissism; you don't think you're all that great. You just aren't down on yourself. You think of yourself in a normal, healthy way.) Then, take the parts of depression where you have no energy and don't experience any emotional affect, and replace those with a sliding scale from "neutral" to "panicked shouting." (Which isn't real panic, per se; it's just a very loud simulated fight-or-flight response, without any real fear or traumatic recall behind it.) An increasing number of people are like this. Nobody notices these people as unusual at all. This used to be rare enough to caricature; it was the "I want to speak to your manager" mom. But everyone is like that now. Every age group has these people in equal numbers. What... happened?
- buttholesurfer 8y agoMaybe they can just ban the people they dont agree with...
- forgottenpass 8y ago>The entire episode was a microcosm of Twitter’s larger problems [...] everyone yelling, and no one talking This isn't meant as a dig at Twitter, but humans simply have limits to how many active participants a conversation can have at any one time. If people start talking on twitter instead of yelling, engagement metrics are going to drop through the floor. In your experience, how many people can be in a room and all participate in one conversation before they split into more than one group, or an audience/panel dynamic forms? Twitter's design is such that there are so many silent participants to every interaction, that any conversation is stressed to the breaking point if even a tiny percent of them choose to say anything. I don't understand what jornos think twitter is and/or could be. As far as I can tell, they want themselves and celebrities to post self-promotion and overton-window-approved nonsense care-free, and then have the crowd act as a mass of sycophantic yes-men.
- Funes- 8y agoPersonally, I would let users decide for themselves if they want to see metrics at all, as well as favorites, retweets, and replies from other accounts. That way, they wouldn't be forced to come across content from people they've never intended to see. Just get new users through a quick tour in which all these options are showcased and be transparent in regards to what they do.
- 435rafwweeww 8y agoDorsey (from the article) : “I also don’t feel good about how Twitter tends to incentivize outrage, fast takes, short term thinking, echo chambers, and fragmented conversation and consideration.” But what has he done to fix the problem, besides tiny UX tweaks that go nowhere, and the occasional ban of a highly visible jerk? Twitter is on fire, and he just plods along. Dorsey, in this article, is about as believable as Mark Zuckerberg saying "we have to get serious about privacy." The prototype that the article mentions exemplifies this attitude. Twitter needs to reinvent itself, but the prototype offers tiny fixes - threaded replies and helpful profile cards. These are needed, but does anyone really think they are going to solve outrage on twitter? The outrage problem is the product of twitter's core design. It combines 2-way conversations with a context-free public soapbox and rewards comments that make people nod in agreement. Solving this would mean redefining what twitter is. Dorsey won't do that, and so he's not serious about the problem. Maybe he can't be serious because it would hurt their profits. The best we can do is delete our accounts, disinvest, and hope twitter burns to the ground.
- metalliqaz 8y agoHe doesn't feel good about it, but he also has to watch the bottom line. The only group he really fears are those to whom he owes a profit. It's better if we don't make CEOs responsible for fixing our social problems. We have to do that ourselves. They will follow along ("give the people what they want")
- CharlesColeman 8y ago> It's better if we don't make CEOs responsible for fixing our social problems. We have to do that ourselves. They will follow along ("give the people what they want") CEOs are a subset of "we," and are in positions where their decisions have impact disproportional to their numbers.
- la_barba 8y agoAll companies become 'slow and lumbering' once they pass a certain size. I cant think of any exception off the top of my head. Once you have the welfare of thousands of people in your hand, you tend to not take any risks. Seems like a normal human response to me...
- Itaxpica 8y agoUnfortunately, I don’t think this is really an issue that can be fixed technically. People go to Twitter to yell at each other; that’s basically the point of the platform. A Twitter where people don’t yell at each other is basically Mastodon, which is a lovely network that basically nobody uses.
- Qwertystop 8y agoIt seems to work well enough for the people who are on it -- and that's enough, really. One-place-for-everyone isn't the goal. "Basically nobody" compared to Twitter can still be pretty sizable.
- Uhhrrr 8y agoI think they go on Twitter to react, and post things which get reactions. Yelling is "only" about 40%.
- ergl 8y agoPeople don't yell at each other in Mastodon precisely because so few people use it (besides, I've already seen Twitter-like behavior there, mainly on the mastodon.social instance). If mastodon had the same amount of users it would be the same, if not worse, because there's no centralized moderation to lean on. Mastodon seems fixated on emulating Twitter without questioning if there's anything worth keeping.
- Kye 8y agoThis is why the instance I'm on mutes mastodon.social. Interaction quality spiked after that. It works with small numbers and good communities. I have several small instances on my personal mute list because the admins brought all the worst Twitter behavior over. That sets a negative tone and ensures only negative people get invited in.
- erikpukinskis 8y ago> I don’t think this is really an issue that can be fixed technically. It’s really easy to bet that something is impossible. It sounds smart, because all of history confirms your theory. But history is also chock full of people doing things that didn’t seem possible, so personally I think you’re making a very bad bet. And I wonder why you are even doing it? What’s gained by trying to convince people that there are zero viable interventions in a specific corner of the solution space? Especially such a big corner as “all technical interventions”?
- skymt 8y ago> Over several days this spring, BuzzFeed News met with Twitter’s leadership and watched as twttr’s team worked on its first big push: helping people better understand what’s being said in often chaotic conversations. The team thinks that if people took more time to read entire conversations, that would help improve their comprehension of them. I had assumed that Twitter was aware of the implications of its design for conversation and had decided that the controversy boost to engagement numbers was worth creating a toxic environment. For real, consider these two basic elements of Twitter's design. First, any given post has a low maximum length, so any time you want to say more than a sentence or two it needs to be spread over multiple posts (a "tweetstorm"). Second, Twitter has two separate features that let anyone pull any part of a series of posts out of its original context: retweeting and quote-tweeting.
- carriers 8y agoYeah, I don't get this at all. I think it's even deeper than designing for controversy. I'm "older" (40s), though I work on products used by younger people, so I don't think this is just me being old, but I can't follow a conversation on twitter at all. When there's a link from HackerNews to Twitter, I click on it and sometimes see the thing mentioned in the HN title, and sometimes don't. Then there's a bunch of stuff below it, some of which is definitely replies to the original post, and some of which appears to be part of a completely different conversation. Some threads of conversations get cut off for no apparent reason and you have to click something to see more of them. Nothing is indented, so it's really hard to tell who's replying to whom. I basically can't understand a thread on Twitter, so I've never signed up because who the hell wants to be part of that? I usually also don't go to Twitter to read stuff other people link to because I'm not going to be able to follow it. Forget boosting controversial stuff, I bet a lot of users post the way they do because they also don't understand what they're looking at.
- nineteen999 8y agoI'm a similar age as you. I did create a Twitter account once, but never used it more than once or twice. Unfortunately the Twitter username (handle?) I chose happened to be the same as the name of a somewhat well-known RnB/Hip Hop video producer (who I had no knowledge of before I created the account). I signed in a year or two later and found that I had a couple of hundred follow requests from various aspiring and up-and-coming rap artists. At that point I realised in all honesty that I probably had no real use for Twitter.
- lcnmrn 8y agoTwitter becoming https://sub.cafe https://sub.cafe any day now.
- robdachshund 8y agoMy solution is to completely ignore Twitter and social media overall.
- floatingatoll 8y agoMy takeaway is “Twitter’s plan is to stop showing integer counts to users, no matter what they say they want”. Good.
- Chris_Chambers 8y agoWhy are twitter and instagram both suddenly talking about doing this? Were they instructed to either do this or face new regulations?
- FeloniousHam 8y ago"People don't go to Twitter to feel good about themselves. People go to Twitter to fight."
- alexandercrohde 8y agoI used blame twitter for creating at outrage culture. But then I realized I had it backwards. There have always been people who find it fun to vent outrage, moral indignity, and condescension. They just got it from TV blowhards before.
- kristianc 8y agoYou had it right the first time, I think. There have always been those things, but then Twitter gave them a place to coalesce and then kept adding features like like metrics and quote tweeting that made all of those behaviors easier in the name of 'engagement' and VC metrics.
- fullshark 8y agoAgreed. News junkies aren’t after the truth / meaningful debate. They are after confirmation bias and seeing people they hate get rekt.
- asdff 8y agoHeadline junkies more like. Nearly every linked article reddit thread has a comment along the lines of "No one read the article." Twitter is even worse about this.
- int_19h 8y agoTV was one-way - at most, you could "reshare" what you heard with friends or colleagues, with a very limited bandwidth and a more considerable effort. Today, we have created tech that makes it easy and convenient. If you look at practically all social networks, they're essentially optimized for outrage gossip. The human part of that equation is much more difficult to change - as social primates, we have this moral outrage thing hardwired to some extent. But why do we deliberately encourage it? (For profit, of course.)
- asdff 8y agoSocial media offered everyone the megaphone and now everyone feels obligated to reiterate their own copycat opinion as a result. People can't even read longform anymore. Share an informative NYT article to someone, and they will complain about the wall of text despite it being a 5 min read that gives you much more nuance to an issue than 280 characters ever could. Signal to noise has never been lower on the internet.
- duxup 8y agoTwitter by design encourages trite / curt posts that have to be outlandish to get any attention. Nuance and understanding are not encouraged ... just based on how the whole thing works. The medium is the message.
- 52-6F-62 8y agoSeriously. McLuhan would have a lot to say, I’m sure.
- baud147258 8y agoWell, your comment fits in a tweet...
- duxup 8y agoA tweet can be true, in fact many are, but the medium can still be dumb / encourage dumb things.
- baud147258 8y agoI agree, it was just some sarcasm on the 'trite / curt' part of your comment.
- duxup 8y agoNoted, you weren't wrong.
- lalos 8y agoWhy not add an ability for the author of the parent tweet to censor the tweets they please and other users can tap on 'show tweets hidden by author under this tweet'. End of story, people who are into the crazy discussions can see it, authors can control and censor as they please and Twitter washes it's hands by saying that the censoring is done on the personal level.
- JaimeThompson 8y agoI can't even get someone banned who directly threatened to murder me in direct messages so I say they hVe a long way to go.
- dfischer 8y agoSolution: people pay to use twitter. Kill advertising as the main model. Either Twitter will do this or the future decentralized apps will do this naturally through micropayments of having to pay for compute through the network. I see a distributed p2p database that costs money to interact with and anyone can build a client for it. Go ahead, build a client - maybe it's free, maybe it costs money because it uses the protocol really well and people like it the UX. Hell, maybe even the client has advertisements in it. Either way interacting with the actual content costs money and that will naturally bring in a balance of information. Right now we have information asymmetry exploited by advertising.
- bradleyankrom 8y agoThis gets suggested as the solution to privacy/junk content/etc for every social platform - why have none of them (that I am aware of) adopted this model?
- derefr 8y agoIf you look at it a certain way, this is what email was before ISPs and bigcorps gave away email addresses; everyone who had an email address was paying their sysadmin for the privilege of having one (through their tuition at a university that has email services, or through the cost-center of the company they work for.) In either of those cases, people were more careful with email, because postmasters were easily angered (and this was, in turn, because causing trouble could actually get your system kicked off the network!) In modern times, people pay to use Slack. It'd be interesting to study the sociology of paid Slack groups (as compared to free Slack groups, or as compared to any other free-for-everyone group chat platform.) I've always thought it'd be a cool idea to have a group chat platform where, rather than some admin owning the group and maybe paying, the group has a tip-jar and anyone/everyone in the group can contribute. (Twitch sort of works like this, but you're really donating to the channel owner, not to the group itself. In my hypothetical model, there is no channel owner; the group persists because at least some of the user-base want it to, and so pay for it to.)
- 8y ago
- otakucode 8y agoMegan Phelps-Roper grew up in the Westboro Baptist "Church", that cult that protests with offensive homophobic signs outside soldier funerals and such. She went on Twitter. She got yelled at on Twitter. She started thinking that maybe what she'd been taught was wrong. She grew in understanding of the impact she was having on the world and she left the 'church', taking her sister with her. If Twitter had gotten people to stop yelling at each other earlier, there would be 2 more protestors outside soldier funerals chanting hateful and homophobic mantras. Keep that in mind while supporting an end to the yelling.
- thrower123 8y agoTwitter is one of the last gasps of the anonymous shit-posting that pervaded internet communities before everything got all Web 2.0 and your grandmother got a Facebook page. Now everything is so serious.
- nullc 8y agoThe product has "twit" right in the name. Twitter is where you go to read twits or become one. Why is anyone surprised? From its tiny size limits to its byzantine threading and inability to follow all of one person without creating an account (which they often instantly ban, even if it does nothing but read)... Twitter is a communications medium constructed in a way that maximizes the ability ferment outrage and minimizes the ability to inform. Twitter is a platform for twits to be twits as an amusement to other twits. Fortunately, you don't have to use it and a great majority of people largely don't. For some reason it gets fetishized by the media -- probably because twittishness is good for business -- and spun as if it were important.
- kaffeemitsahne 8y ago> For some reason it gets fetishized by the media -- probably because twittishness is good for business -- and spun as if it were important. I've always assumed this is simply because a lot of journalists happen to be on Twitter.
- s_y_n_t_a_x 8y agoProtip: you can text "follow @username" to 40404 to follow people without having a twitter account. I much prefer getting a text from a select few people when they tweet. And if you're not a fan of twitter there's the bonus of it costing them money without giving ad revenue.
- bubblewrap 8y agoExcept you can follow all sorts of experts and famous people om there. Not all of them are twits. Even Paul Graham drops the occasional tweet: https://twitter.com/paulg https://twitter.com/paulg
- asdff 8y agoThat's dependent on your interests though. In my field people are too busy writing manuscripts to write a tweet.
- 8y ago
- samirillian 8y agoReads like such a puff piece.
- RickJWagner 8y agoHaha, good luck with that. Internet trashtalking is the biggest thing since beer muscles. It's an aggression-enabler.
- slater 8y agoDoes it involve banning nazis?
- toephu2 8y agoWhy do you have nazis in your timeline in the first place? I never understood the people that always complain about nazis on twitter. Like seriously what are you clicking 'Like' on that your twitter is fully of nazis?
- enraged_camel 8y agoIt’s not my Twitter that is full of Nazis. It’s Twitter in general. And their tweets make it into my life because non-Nazis respond to them, and those responses then become popular and are shared.
- thinkingemote 8y agoIt's more accurate to say that Twitter is full of responses to Nazis than Twitter is full of nazis. People on Twitter amplifies responses
- asdff 8y agoUnfollow people who are sharing these easy jabs at hateful people all day.
- chx 8y ago1. Reenable the API. 2. Done. Seriously, people have been pretty good at this before. Build a bot that autoblocks anyone engaging me if they have <N followers or the account is less than N days old. And so on.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ahakki 8y agoThey really need to remove autothreading and replace it with a dedicated media type for long form text. People already use Apple Notes screenshots for that purpose.
- lone_haxx0r 8y agoIn other news: Mcdonalds' plan to get people to stop eating junk food.
- chrisbrandow 8y agoI think human conversations at scale with strangers is inherently difficult to solve. We are prone to quick, context-life reactions. Threading management only gets you so far…
- aloisdg 8y agoHN, Reddit and most newsgroups are not so bad.
- onion2k 8y agoHN has an appalling reputation outside of HN. People refer to it as "the evil orange website". EDIT: It's "angry orange website", not "evil orange website". Not so bad after all.
- oblio 8y agoHonest question: which people? HN is too US/California/Bay Area centric for my tastes (most people here are probably from there), it talks a bit too much about money and jobs, but it's still a decent resource.
- onion2k 8y agoI was wrong about the name. It's "the angry orange website". https://twitter.com/search?q="angry%20orange%20website" https://twitter.com/search?q="angry%20orange%20website" - that's just a sample of HN's 'haters'. HN has its share of people who are awful and post horrible opinions (see the discussion about any article on JavaScript, health care, wealth, etc). I believe HN has some value left which is why I still post here, but I can absolutely see why people have abandoned it, and I certainly don't talk about HN with people in real life.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kprjo 8y ago
- _bxg1 8y agoGet rid of retweets. Make like counts invisible. These will mitigate but not totally solve the problem. I don't think anything more can be done.
- shambolicfroli 8y agoTo see where new behavior (by the platform) is needed, they should look at what breaks incipient good discussions, and how to prevent that. (I'll also note that the HN conversation on this post seems quite different in tone from the usual HN.)
- kprjo 8y agoAll the problems I read about Twitter are basically PEBCAK. "people say outrageous things!" okay so don't go ahead and read them. As an example, replies to Trump are always a shitfest. Don't read them. "there are evil nazis!" okay so don't follow them. "even if I don't do these two, other people I follow retweet those and I get to see them!" okay so mute, unfollow, or block that person. "even if I don't do these two, other people I don't know say outrageous things or follow evil nazis" that's none of your business. Twitter served me well for a long time, if you've tried to "figure it out" and couldn't (when it's the simplest shit ever) then just don't use it. Why should all services be catered to the lowest common denominator? The only thing I agree with is that they shouldn't show tweets other people liked in your timeline. But the rest is simply bullshit. It's like some people want Twitter to become something it's not and it's never been.
- Traster 8y agoArguments happen on twitter because you have lots of different communities that frequently accidentally collide. It's fascinating. Basically as it turns out communities on the internet work calmly when they're homogenous - this is the beauty of reddit. When communities interact you get chaos, because suddenly you're confronted with thousands of people you disagree with. On reddit that's called brigading and can get you banned, but on twitter it's built into the platform. The result is that on reddit you get isolated communities - some of which are thoroughly toxic and churn out some of the worst of humanity. Twitter doesn't create that isolated groupthink environment but instead it is just a constant warfare between communities. What I don't understand thouhg, is why twitter thinks its a good idea to give away the one thing that makes their platform differentiated.
- rusk 8y ago> why twitter thinks its a good idea to give away the one thing that makes their platform differentiated. They've been doing this for a while in fairness, cut-by-cut: - algorithmic timeline (that can't be disabled!) - 240 character messages - "Threads" - "verified" users (that get different treatment) All in a vain effort to take what was a beautifully simple peer-to-peer microblogging platform and create something more like snapfacestergrameddit. And still no "edit" button.