3 ms·
When you do that, here's my little suggestion for a policy: a carbon duty. It seems to me the biggest argument against doing something is that any action we ta
by bryanlarsen 8y ago
When you do that, here's my little suggestion for a policy: a carbon duty.
It seems to me the biggest argument against doing something is that any action we take would be useless if country X doesn't do anything.
But with a carbon duty, this is much less of a difficult collective action problem. Impose a significant duty on products coming from countries which are not meeting some reasonable target for carbon emissions.
- trickstra 8y agosooo all other countries will pay for it while US will keep pumping oil and burning coal? With US leaving the Paris Accord? That sounds very strange.
- Angostura 8y agoSoooo, we introduce a set of trade tariffs where imports are tax depending on the degree to which the exporting country has already imposed a carbon tax on manufacturer.
- leesalminen 8y agoBut CNN has spent the past month telling me that tariffs = bad. I guess they’re OK so long as they’re introduced for noble reasons?
- DanHulton 8y agoI mean... yeah. Tariffs are bad for the economy. But if you're willing to slow down the economy for a good enough reason, then yes, it's okay.
- SkyBelow 8y agoSo tariff's are a tool that can be used for good or bad? So, was the message the previous poster receiving that tariff's are bad, or that the current use of tariff's are bad? If it was the former, it disagrees with your message.
- baq 8y agoWait is this place CNN or is it HN?
- SkyBelow 8y agoI'm not clear on how that factors in. The previous poster's point was that there was a push of the message that 'tariffs are bad' that seems to have some level of social acceptance, but now that there is a desired use of tariffs there seems to be a change in opinion. That is overall a very weak standard of evidence, and taken by itself isn't worth much at all. But taken with other incidents in the past few years people might reach the conclusion that there is a great deal of double standards being used to measure certain politicians. This results in a comment said in passing that signals they feel that the current acceptance or lack thereof of tariffs is another case of that double standard. Perhaps one could argue that such said in passing remarks are not acceptable for the level of discourse excepted by NH comments (though this risks becoming recursive).
- mikeash 8y agoTariffs implemented by an idiot with no economic justification are bad. Tariffs that capture externalities are good.
- trickstra 8y agoYou are missing the point. Imposing tariffs is a way to force other countries to follow some rules. But if your own country doesn't follow those rules, what sense does it make? And that's the situation here, because the 3 largest CO2 producers are US, Russia and China, naturally, because they are biggest. But China actually invested heavily into solar and lowering their CO2, such as electric buses, while US left Paris Accord, rejected Green New Deal, started more oil drills and did a bunch of other things that actually increased their CO2 production. So if anyone should impose carbon duties, it's everyone else around US to force US to start following the rules.
- Angostura 8y agoI talking about the other countries. Import import duties reflecting the cost of the global pollution created by the manufacturer of the goods.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoI purposefully left out a bunch of details because then people start debating the details rather than the main point. So I used the very nebulous "meeting some reasonable target for carbon emissions". If the country imposing the carbon duty isn't also meeting the "reasonable target" then the carbon duty becomes very hypocritical and ineffective at influencing other nations. I also didn't say that it has to be the US imposing this carbon duty, I see it as most effective if it's a small group of countries working together to try and grow their action into a large group.
- ikeboy 8y agoYup, last year's Nobel winner in economics has suggested exactly that https://issues.org/climate-clubs-to-overcome-free-riding/ https://issues.org/climate-clubs-to-overcome-free-riding/
- everdev 8y agoThis still falls into the "country X doesn't do anything" trap. If France imposes a carbon duty but Britain doesn't, British companies will have access to cheaper goods. British citizens will have greater purchasing power and British companies will have an economic advantage. France might say, "Britain doesn't do anything about climate change" as they're supporting the carbon emissions in other countries by importing their goods. This would still only work if enough countries banded together to enforce it that it became too difficult to grow an international company without access to carbon duty countries.
- simonpure 8y agoMost recent proposal in the US - Energy Innovation and Carbon Dividend Act of 2019 https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/763 https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/763