5 ms·
As I understand it the point of the leaks or not the documents per se but the actual leak of them. As stated elsewhere According to his essay, Julian Assange
by ThomPete 16y ago
As I understand it the point of the leaks or not the documents per se but the actual leak of them.
As stated elsewhere
According to his essay, Julian Assange is trying to do something else. Because we all basically know that the US state — like all states — is basically doing a lot of basically shady things basically all the time, simply revealing the specific ways they are doing these shady things will not be, in and of itself, a necessarily good thing. In some cases, it may be a bad thing, and in many cases, the provisional good it may do will be limited in scope. The question for an ethical human being — and Assange always emphasizes his ethics — has to be the question of what exposing secrets will actually accomplish, what good it will do, what better state of affairs it will bring about. And whether you buy his argument or not, Assange has a clearly articulated vision for how Wikileaks’ activities will “carry us through the mire of politically distorted language, and into a position of clarity,” a strategy for how exposing secrets will ultimately impede the production of future secrets. The point of Wikileaks — as Assange argues — is simply to make Wikileaks unnecessary.
http://zunguzungu.wordpress.com/2010/11/29/julian-assange-and-the-computer-conspiracy-%E2%80%9Cto-destroy-this-invisible-government%E2%80%9D/ http://zunguzungu.wordpress.com/2010/11/29/julian-assange-an...
- zachrose 16y agoThere's a similarly interesting line of thought going through the Rubberhose encrypted file system, an earlier Assange project. In both cases, the moral victory is not an immediate part of the action or product. It's about the secondary effects of living in a world where coercive force is no longer rational.
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoThis seems naive to me in at least two ways. That revealing past secrets will somehow make governments more transparent - they'll use encryption and off-record remarks, watch what they say, ensure records are destroyed, tighten security protocols. But IMO, and it is just that, they will still keep the same secrets and have the same covert conversations and exchange the same messages.
- ThomPete 16y agoAssanges point is that the harder you make it to be secretive the less conspiracies you will get (he uses a somewhat different definition of conspiracies) It's not by any metrics naive it's exactly what is going on right now. Overreactions decreasing the ability to communicate. That's what Assange by his own words are after.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>Assanges point is that the harder you make it to be secretive the less conspiracies you will get If someone wants to whisper something in your friends ear, and seeing it you step closer, does the third party whisperer quit or do they usher you friend away so that they can keep the secret? Making it harder to keep secrets means that people are more secretive. Decreasing the ability for people to communicate is not at all a good thing IMO. If diplomats can't do their job, acting as intermediaries and smoothing over relationships between countries then I don't think that is going to help anyone unless they desire anarchy. >It's not by any metrics naive it's exactly what is going on right now. Could you expand on this I'm not at all clear what you're saying.
- ThomPete 16y agoIt's not about keeping secrets but about communicating them. You are making it harder to communicate thus you are making conspiracies harder. You are slowing down things.
- dkarl 16y agoI have seen this argument before, and I still do not understand. If the leaks have no concrete consequences, if the public does not react, doesn't that teach governments that they have nothing to fear from exposure and that they may go ahead with business as usual?