5 ms·
What I wonder: why did it take them this long? Walmart has warehouse-sized stores that are close to almost everybody. And most of America's houses are already v
by wpietri 8y ago
What I wonder: why did it take them this long? Walmart has warehouse-sized stores that are close to almost everybody. And most of America's houses are already visited 6 days a week by a delivery person. Walmart could and should have made a deal with the USPS a decade ago. It would have been great for all concerned.
Instead, they let Amazon practically own the concept, eating away at their huge distribution advantage.
- joering2 8y agoDeal with USPS? Would be hard to find a manager who can make this work and not obviously post it as a huge disaster on their resumee. USPS continues to bleed money, is always understaffed, continues to misplace the mail and is bugged with pretty old technology that is hard to upgrade. Add unions to it and you have a perfect government entity altho USPS is not actually a government organisation. If anything it would make more sense for Amazon mail to offer USPS a helping hand ;)
- atwebb 8y agoI have had way less issues with USPS than UPS, especially considering the volume of mail coming via USPS. I think it is underpriced for the value it delivers, especially media mail.
- neilv 8y agoI generally really like using the USPS, though not as much as when I could ship a Priority Mail Small Flat Rate Box for $4.95. USPS is very effective for some purposes, and I have the impression that, overall, they take integrity of delivery seriously. I also like that the workers are getting pensions, and the ones I see seem committed to the work. USPS's reputation has also saved a few eBay sales, when the buyer said they didn't receive the item. I ask the buyer to please double-check that it didn't get mixed in with the junk mail or something, and say that, if it's not there, I'll refund them in full immediately and ask the USPS Postal Investigator to figure out what happened. Every double-check thus far has found the package.
- jdeibele 8y agoWow. USPS continues to bleed money but that's due to the mandate from Congress about pre-funding pensions. That's a requirement that nobody else has - see the articles about the 3rd-largest coal company declaring bankruptcy and shedding its pension obligations. Is always understaffed? Yeah, there are lines a lot of the time. So go to USPS.com if you can and buy postage online. Go to the offices that have ATM-like machines if you can't. My usual problem is that I have a letter that I don't want to send Priority Mail and I've gotten out of the habit of having 10 different amounts of postage labels. Misplace the mail? I signed up for their service that sends me a picture of almost every piece of mail that gets delivered. The last problem with the mail that I can remember having was dropping off a check at the airport while leaving on a trip. The contractor suggested that mail there got extra inspection, which delayed it. I'm not sure that's right but I can see somebody dropping something "bad" in the mail right before they leave the city/state/country. They're certainly not perfect and I bet it's not any more fun to work there than when "going postal" was a thing. But I'm pretty happy with USPS.
- neilv 8y agoThe unusual pension funding requirement forced on the USPS might be an instance of: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIt might have that dual purpose, but I’d rather them have to properly fund their retiree healthcare and defined benefit pension expenses than be in the situation that most governments are in where today’s taxpayers get to pay for benefits earned in prior years. Ideally, they would get rid of those retiree healthcare and defined benefit pension benefits and just pay their employees more in cash, and let them buy annuities if they want. That would make the whole operation far more transparent and get rid of possibilities of corruption and numbers games being played with these deferred pay agreements.
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoPerhaps. But any company who makes the claim of pensions or "we'll promise to pay you more later" should be legally required to store that in escrow. So if/when they try their little bankruptcy schemes, it won't work.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lbatx 8y agoThe USPS is most certainly a government organization. It's mentioned in the Constitution. (that's the first clue). Where people get confused is that it's called a "independent agency" which simply means it doesn't fall under a Cabinet-level post. It is, however, controlled by Presidential appointees (that't the other clue it's part of the government).
- trophycase 8y agoRemind me again why a tax funded organization needs to make a profit?
- lbatx 8y agoStrictly speaking, their operations are not tax funded. Their operating budget comes from selling postage. There's a whole complicated discussion about their pension, which apparently gets some Federal funding, but day-to-day they are not tax funded.
- wpietri 8y agoAt least for me, the USPS often does last-mile delivery for Amazon. Given that Amazon has already made this work, it seems reasonable to think that Walmart could have made it work as well. And personally I haven't had them lose mail in years. I know this varied by region, so maybe it's just where I live now. But if anybody can make a large organization up their game, it's another large organization who is paying a lot of money.
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoI was looking for cheap college furniture a year or two ago and Walmart had a similar 'walmart prime' where you pay x$ for free 2 day shipping above a certain price point for a year. So, they've had this for a while, but not the mindshare IMO. (Other specialty stores also have this, but the mindshare isn't there).
- amelius 8y ago> What I wonder: why did it take them this long? What I wonder: why didn't USPS start an e-commerce business?
- burkaman 8y agoI think that would require at least an act of Congress, if not a constitutional amendment. It also would need a huge initial investment to succeed.
- amelius 8y agoYes, perhaps, but they could have used third party merchants instead of having everything on stock themselves. It's all about the portal, not about the actual merchants.
- irrational 8y agoI live in a major metropolitan area that has fought tooth and nail to keep Walmart out. Within 10 miles of my house (which encompasses pretty much the entire metro area) there is only 1 neighborhood Walmart that is smaller than many convenience stores. I've never actually traveled to visit it. Even before Amazon made the 1 day announcement, we were usually getting Amazon packages in less than 2 days since there is a huge Amazon warehouse in the metro area. The closest Walmart superstore is about 2-3 hours away from the city in rural areas. It would seem that if they are using the superstores to support 1 day shipping to the city, it will be hard for them to compete with Amazon.
- duckfruit 8y agoI can attempt to answer this. (Disclosure: Used to work at Walmart, though as an engineer not an ops person). Most of the stores are optimized for in store shopping. What this means in practice is that the actual back rooms where the products are stored are relatively tiny (on the order of less than 10-15% the floor space of a typical Supercenter). The whole operation is designed so that the trucks can be unloaded as quickly and efficiently as possible, and most of the stuff can be stocked straight on the shelves where it is available for purchase. Inventory held in back rooms are minimal, and all the items in the entire store turn around extremely quickly. Contrast this with an e-commerce warehouse, which has to deal with a large 'long-tail' of demand. People are used to having a huge range of choice available, and they expect same or next day shipping on whatever they order. Now instead of having say 20 boxes each of 8 different kinds of toilet paper now you need maybe 10 boxes of 100 different kinds, and they all have to be organized such that they're easily accessible to the packing crew. To make an efficient warehouse, you simply need a different layout and assortment of products than is available in your average store. At the same time, the stores continue to generate the vast majority of revenue for your business so you can't mess up their operations too much. Not implying that it is an impossible problem to solve, simply a difficult one. I'm sure amazon will run into similar issues as they continue to integrate whole foods.
- bluGill 8y agoDo they have to? I need toilet paper. I get frustrated with eCommerce sites because they want to to figure out which of the 100 different ones is best - toilet paper is toilet paper. Let me choose based on size of roll and softness, give me the best price that meets my requirements. e-commerce makes it easy to have a million choices, but my local brick and motor store - because they have limited space - just gives me the choices I care about without too many.
- wpietri 8y agoThanks! This is very interesting. I agree that to do it efficiently at scale, you need to change a lot. But they could easily have started with an Instacart-like approach, where every night when the stores are empty they have people pull and pack from the regular stock. That gets them into the game, and as buying habits change, they can start optimizing for the patterns that emerge. There are a lot of levers they can pull to keep that from disrupting store operation, including geographic rollout, limiting product selection, and marketing spend. That's not optimal, of course. But neither is waiting until Amazon has a huge lead. So I still feel like they weren't thinking far enough ahead at a business level. Which as Clayton Christensen has shown, is pretty common for successful businesses.
- cflyingdutchman 8y agoWalmart is not actually using the Stores to deliver, but delivering 1-day from warehouses. Currently cheaper