5 ms·
If a company can escape their (financial, environmental, social) responsibilities by filing for bankruptcy before they have to pay out, they should be paying it
by Cthulhu_ 8y ago
If a company can escape their (financial, environmental, social) responsibilities by filing for bankruptcy before they have to pay out, they should be paying it forward.
In my country, pension funds are always separate companies from the employers; they have to deposit part of your wage into the pension fund, after which they can no longer touch it (because well, it's your money).
Of course, whether the pension companies handle it appropriately is another matter.
- lordnacho 8y agoThe example you're looking for is insurance, where it's an obvious problem. You can't just open an insurance company, take people's premium payments, and then go broke when there's a claim. But for other companies, normal limited liability bankruptcy is the default solution. Nobody thought coal companies would be a special risk in the sense of having liabilities way after their income. It's like if you invent an ice cream that turns out to give people cancer in 20 years, there's no recourse beyond what money the company has at that time.
- XorNot 8y agoI mean this really happened though: asbestos was exactly this problem.
- lordnacho 8y agoYeah agreed. Not clear what the solution is though. It's a bit blunt to just not allow limited liability, which is useful for a lot of things. But then what do you do instead?
- madez 8y agoWe must internalize the costs. 1) People must be held responsible for their actions no matter if it's in their free time or at work. You do it, you are responsible for it. 2) Those that give unlawful tasks to others as their boss must personally be held responsible no matter whether the task actually got implemented, or not. 3) The investors of avtivities must personally be held responsible for the activities they fund. It's their responsibility to know what they are funding.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI think it isn't a case of "nobody knew" so much as "everybody was in deep denial". Black lung was long known along with the effects of poor air as not good for your health. I have noticed a chain of rationalization cropping up a lot with preventable human health crises - often on a generational time scale. The sequence seems to be similiar to an ironic reshuffled subsection of stages of grief. 1. Bargining: "Yeah it is bad but is better than the alternative." (It makes money/keeps us from freezing to death.) 2. Acceptance: "It is a neccessity now." (Most of our industrial and personal exonomy is dependent on it.) 3. Denial: "It can't be harmful!" 4. Anger: "How could we know that it was bad?"
- asdffdsa 8y agoReminds me of: climate change, American government, inequality & the flaws in capitalist systems, using free internet services (fb, google), sedentary lifestyle and poor (processed food and excessive refined sugar) diet.
- bko 8y agoPension funds are generally defined benefit, as opposed to defined contribution. This means that they guarantee a retirement benefit. The problem with that is the companies often invest a portion assuming an unrealistic growth rate. The problem is worse when you consider that the effects of the underlying under-investment won't be felt until the current workers retire and start drawing on their funds. In other words, the people making the investment decisions today likely won't be around for the reckoning. This leads to a situation where a business today could be held hostage by employees from 30 years ago forcing current employees to suffer, prior employees to have their benefits cut and newer companies without these legacy costs to benefit. Defined contribution means the employer puts away a certain defined amount for every employee and the employee is entitled to that. This removes the risk of mismanagement of funds and gives employees responsibility to manage their own investments. An example is a 401k account. Most private businesses in the US switched over to defined contribution as its more sustainable and predictable. As an employee I also prefer defined contribution since my retirement is no longer dependent on the health of an employer a few decades from now.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoThe DB deficit is mostly down to the accounting rules used I have had briefings (off the record Chattem house rules) for one of the UK's Largest DB schemes - One that recently sacked one of the Big 4 and now runs self managed. You do wonder if the Accounting profession deliberately altered the rules around DB pensions to allow employers to shut them down. Basically in the UK if the worst case scenarios that DB pensions have to match came true you would be talking about a major break down in civil society and making sure you had a shotgun to defend your stash of tinned goods.
- thinkcontext 8y agoJust yesterday I saw: Nearly 100,000 coal miners at risk of losing pension money by 2022 https://www.daytondailynews.com/news/national-govt--politics/nearly-100-000-coal-miners-risk-losing-pension-money-2022/cD0EujbZJ859cKMUrrwZ2H/ https://www.daytondailynews.com/news/national-govt--politics...
- SilasX 8y agoUnless, of course, it's the US Postal Service that's offering the pension, in which case HNers jump out of the woodwork to give elaborate justifications of why pre-funding pensions doesn't make sense because "lol it doesn't pay out until later, what's the problem?" Edit: thread with lots of examples: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10596814 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10596814 In particular: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10597070 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10597070