4 ms·
I wonder how this will play out with IP, given that Lenovo has been manufacturing a Windows Mixed Reality headset using Microsoft's VR/AR tech? They'd have to t
by taneq 8y ago
I wonder how this will play out with IP, given that Lenovo has been manufacturing a Windows Mixed Reality headset using Microsoft's VR/AR tech? They'd have to tread very carefully to avoid stepping on any MS patents etc. with inside-out tracking.
Also, once again (as with Valve vs. HTC) we see the pattern playing out:
1) Platform owner develops new tech to be used on their platform, tries to foster an ecosystem
2) Third parties develop products based on the tech
3) Third parties launch competing platform because in the end, platforms are more profitable than hardware
4) Market is fragmented and we can't have nice things
- yumraj 8y agoThis is how it will play out: 1) MS will sue Lenovo. 2) China will threaten MS with consequences including no access to China market. 3) MS will withdraw the lawsuit and lick its wounds.
- jjeaff 8y agoMaybe, but China makes up a very tiny fraction of msft revenue. The only reason they would give in to threats from China would be if they believe that in the future the piracy problem in China will go away for them.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoFrom my 9 years working in Microsoft China, I think Lenovo, Microsoft, and China all have a very good relationship. I’d be very surprised if Microsoft took action against Lenovo, I would be astounded if they went anywhere near where the Chinese government would admonish them.
- WorldMaker 8y agoI wouldn't be surprised here if Microsoft was even intentionally lending the IP. Microsoft doesn't want to be the sole hardware vendor in a category, so encouraging HoloLens clones is probably somewhere on their explicit agenda.
- nbevans 8y agoI don't think Microsoft is that dumb. They have business in China that they want to protect. They will certainly have China advisors available to their board to prevent such miscalculations. And that is assuming Microsoft considers Lenovo's product as an infringement (they might not); Lenovo may have paid for whatever IP they have used - or they may have found creative ways to avoid it.
- yumraj 8y agoIt is sad that all the comments are basically implying that MS, or any company by extension, should just accept IP infringement by Chinese rather than take action against it. How the hell did we get in this mess.... Why don't companies understand that Chinese market is a one off access. The moment some Chinese company copies IP, that access is gone. It's a very myopic strategy to accept such losses as a trade-off for doing business in China.
- strmpnk 8y agoWhat makes you think Microsoft intended to keep hololens-class devices manufacturing to themselves? This could be a relationship just like PC OEMs like Lenovo already have, licensing things with a royalty. The prominence of the AR apps in windows (preinstalled in many cases) well before the hardware that Microsoft made themselves was ready for mass adoption makes it clear that they want Windows and that ecosystem to have a play in AR and VR. We've seen hardware plays like this in the past with the Surface design which seems to have too odd of a cadence and release cycle to be purely motivated as a product offering. The design was meant to be an influence on the market, which helped windows machines remain relevant in a space where Apple sees devices like the iPad fitting.
- taneq 8y ago> What makes you think Microsoft intended to keep hololens-class devices manufacturing to themselves? Nothing, but they'll be wanting HoloLens-class devices to be running Windows. This thing runs Android. > We've seen hardware plays like this in the past with the Surface design which seems to have too odd of a cadence and release cycle to be purely motivated as a product offering. As you say, the Surface was aimed squarely at heading high end iOS devices off at the pass. Microsoft doesn't care too much about hardware. They care a whole heckin' lot about Windows. (Just like Valve with Steam, for instance.) The hardware is ephemeral, owning the platform is where it's at.
- HeWhoLurksLate 8y agoAnd their fancy Windows core thingy (I'm sorry, I've forgotten the name) that makes everything rely on the same core code but with different UI things. Platforms are great, and I'm honestly pretty pumped about Microsoft's more-open-source future.
- Haga 8y agoIntroducing the Android subsystem for windows
- zyx321 8y agoThe platform that Microsoft wants to push is not just Windows. It's Azure. The HoloLens 2 keynote made a big deal out of opening the ecosystem to Apple and Android clients.
- jayd16 8y agoLenovo already makes the Mirage Solo and the Rift S 6Dof headsets. This isn't their first rodeo.