3 ms·
It seems though that they now surface "authoritative" sites over clear user intent in their search. For instance, search for "has Infowars ever been correct" o
by colordrops 8y ago
It seems though that they now surface "authoritative" sites over clear user intent in their search.
For instance, search for "has Infowars ever been correct" on Google and then Duck Duck Go. For Google, you will see results that have nothing to do with the clear intent of the query, such as Wikipedia and mainstream news articles trashing Infowars. For Duck, you will get several results that actually answer the question.
Since Google pioneered natural language processing for search queries, and these sorts of queries worked fine years ago, the only conclusion is that Google is actively burying certain results to manipulate the narrative. Why does their natural language search break all of a sudden when I want to find out something that is unpopular?
- rat87 8y agoInfowars won't actually accuratley answer of it's been correct so Google is following the users clear intent and giving them good answers
- agentdrtran 8y agoDoing that search gave me a Quora link as the first result, and then two links to infowars...which is an awful result.
- colordrops 8y agoI'm seeing 2 out of 10 links as Infowars, links #3 and #4. The top two are Quora. mediamatters and rational wiki are examples of other front page results. They all directly address the query. Why exactly are they "awful"?
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoYou seem in your answers to be prioritizing "direct answer to the question regardless of reliability" rather than "useful information about the question's subject." I suppose there's an argument to be made for that, but it's an argument that leads to prioritizing a search engine that will return the answer "orange pinstripe" to the question "what is the color of the sky" over a search engine that returns a scientific article about how sunlight behaves in atmosphere. (In any case, this all seems a bit orthogonal to whether Google is right or wrong to prioritize widely-recognized news outlets over smaller ones when it surfaces searches for news articles, doesn't it?)
- colordrops 8y agoI don't believe it to be orthogonal. There is a deeper philosophical question that has barely been touched on what search engines should return in response to user queries, which also applies to surfacing news. In the past with Alta Vista, word matches were the heuristic and it was extremely obvious as to how to measure the quality of the result. Now you've got very abstract heuristics, such as intent of the user, trustworthiness of the source, whether the source is healthy and good for society, the correctness or honesty of the content, how much revenue will be made with particular set of results, etc. and the public is being left out of the discussion as to which heuristics are important to apply.
- twirlock 8y agoHow about as general rule of thumb, I tell search engines what to search for instead of the other way around?
- tapland 8y agoThat's wild. My results look like this: https://i.imgur.com/AtrMoLs.png https://i.imgur.com/AtrMoLs.png
- colordrops 8y agoThe person you are responding to is referring to DDG.
- m1sta_ 8y agoYou will get results that respond to the question. That's not the same correct answers.
- colordrops 8y agoHow could a search engine ever know what the "correct" answer is? Relevance is more important. In any case, Google's results for this particular query are certainly less "correct". They are more of a non sequitur.
- arcticfox 8y ago> How could a search engine ever know what the "correct" answer is? Relevance is more important. I strongly disagree, IMO actively surfacing a highly-relevant but incorrect result is worse than not surfacing anything at all. As for determining what the "correct" answer is, the authority of the source is certainly a good place to start. Obviously nothing is fool-proof, but Yahoo! Answers is certainly less likely to be correct than Wikipedia, for example.
- colordrops 8y agoLet's continue with my particular query as an example. I already don't trust Alex Jones and Quora and Yahoo answers. I have my own opinion as to which sources I trust and which ones I do not. So first I would internally give different weights to results based on how trustworthy I find them. Then, I would look at the actual content, and look to cross reference the details to assert their validity. Now with the Google results, there is nothing even remotely relevant to my search, so I don't even have candidates with which I could do further research into their veracity. Once again I think Google just thinks they are smarter than the average user, but it's making their search engine useless for certain queries. And I don't like the idea that a search engine should be doing the critical thinking for users. That's more dangerous than the content they are supposedly protecting us from.
- newen 8y ago
- whatamidoingyo 8y ago"For instance, search for "has Infowars ever been correct" on Google and then Duck Duck Go." Wow. Completely different results.
- bestnameever 8y ago>For instance, search for "has Infowars ever been correct" on Google and then Duck Duck Go. F I suspect Duck duck go's results come from Bing based on the result similarities.