4 ms·
Yes. It is crazy that people who get their insurance from an employer get a tax break (indirectly), while those that purchase it on the individual market do no
by seanmcdirmid 8y ago
Yes.
It is crazy that people who get their insurance from an employer get a tax break (indirectly), while those that purchase it on the individual market do not. Also, it messes up the risk pool: more affluent people who get their insurance from work are bound to be more healthier than the poor schlubs who are not affluent enough to get insurance from their job. As an insurance company, I could get away with charging group plans much less than individual plans.
Switzerland, which is basically where the heritage foundation copied what would become RomneyCare/ObamaCare from, does not allow for group plans. You simply don't get your insurance from work, everyone is shoved into the same individual plan market (with some weird probably overthought exceptions, like Post docs....). This very important aspect is missing from the ACA, but would be impossible to remove politically, full on universal healthcare is much more likely.
- mieseratte 8y agoSomething else I don't quite understand is why plans have drastically higher rates between tiny private-company and ACA bought. Lost my job at a small company, only three people with insurance, and wanted to purchase the same silver-level insurance through the ACA. I could've, for over 3x the total payment for the private plan. Even the lowest-level catastrophic was still $100 more than the total cost of the silver plan. Then there was the dental. Same plan, same dental insurer... but hey guess who gets a 6-month waiting period on that filing?
- gowld 8y agoWhy is there a waiting period on a filling? Any dentist can do that.
- ganoushoreilly 8y agoSadly there's a lockup period for most work besides standard cleanings within the first 90-180 days with a lot of providers. Mine had a 1 year hold on fillings and crown repair etc. Even then they only covered part of it at that. I also have the highest plan available from the Provider (employer paid in full) with a nominal annual deductible for the whole plan. Understanding what's covered and not, how much etc. is tough. Planning your dental care involves the Dentists looking at Timelines and fitting procedures around timelines more than priority simply because of the billing issues noted above.
- zaroth 8y agoNot waiting for the dentist, waiting for the coverage. With a new dental plan, if you didn’t have dental before, you can get cleanings but not other work covered for the first 6 months. Otherwise since most dental work is not an emergency, you would pay for one month of dental insurance in a year you had any work needed, and pay out of pocket for cleanings. If you had prior coverage and are just switching plans because of employment changes, then I believe the waiting period is waived. We used to have the same thing with “pre-existing conditions” in health care. You needed “prior credible coverage” to be able to get treatment for an existing condition in the first 6 months of a plan. Again, it’s to prevent people from only buying insurance after they get sick.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gowld 8y agoEven if you pay premiums for your employer health insurance, you get a direct tax break that individuals don't get. > it messes up the risk pool Only if you believe that it's "messed up" to pay for health care only for people who are economically productive...
- lotsofpulp 8y agoI interpret what seanmcdirmid wrote to mean it’s messed up that healthy (and usually economically productive) people can sequester themselves in groups that have lower health insurance premiums.
- bargl 8y agoI don't fully understand. Are you saying that in Switzerland it is illegal to have a group plan? This is something I felt would actually help the US move off of Employer based insurance for a while now. If every person is charged the same amount for insurance regardless of being in a group then we can more easily break from employer based insurance. Especially when I can see X job offers me 100,000 but pays 500 a month for insurance. And Y job offers me 110,000 but pays 0 a month for insurance. I can do the math on which one is better if both plans are the same. Anyway I'd love for the US to ban group plans completely. In the digital age it should be easy enough to administer a large plan with individuals instead of a group plan. I can see why after WW2 a group plan might have been better to administer, but I think at least most of those benefits no longer exist.
- seanmcdirmid 8y ago> Are you saying that in Switzerland it is illegal to have a group plan? Yes, group plans are not allowed. All residents are in the same risk pool. Also, all health insurance premiums are paid post tax (unless you are poor and get a subsidy). Employers themselves can only offer accident insurance.
- bargl 8y agoI love it. That's a practical way to force a more egalitarian system (Single payer or not) while not removing insurance companies in the mean time. Thanks for sharing.
- anarazel 8y agoGiven the fact that Switzerland is second in ppp adjusted health care costs (after the US, of course), I'm not sure modeling a system after the Swiss one is necessarily the best approach. The link is for 2016, but iirc the 2017 trends are similar. Haven't seen 2018 numbers yet. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.CHEX.PP.CD?most_recent_value_desc=true https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.CHEX.PP.CD?most_...
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoBeing the second most expensive still puts them way ahead of the USA. Also, Switzerland is a very rich country, they do get better results for the money they put into it (as measured by life expectancies).