11 ms·
Journalists Are Reporting Their Colleagues to HR for Political Opinions
- zxcvvcxz 8y agoProgressives are not liberals. They are sad and mentally weak people who cannot handle other opinions existing.
- mc32 8y agoAka the weaponization of HR for political reasons. Obviously this is a tactic to fend off non-mainstream thinking in the guise of political correctness (feeling safe/not safe). HR is loath to be in the crosshairs, so they’ll probably tend to try and hire milquetoast staff.
- justin66 8y ago> HR is loath to be in the crosshairs, so they’ll probably tend to try and hire milquetoast staff. What? The traditional solution is for people to not talk about politics about work. In corporate America breaching that line is often regarded as much more serious than any of the particulars of the politics being discussed. Not because anyone is "milquetoast" (seriously??) but because people are paid to get work done.
- anongraddebt 8y agoThe current American socio-political environment is a vortex of escalation right now. Moreover, we seem to be moving from rabid polarization to a calculus of hatred. I'm not sure there is a controlled transition from this state, except for a sudden (and potentially violent) 'release valve'. ---- I hope my claim is false. I have zero desire to witness/observe the types of historical events that fall under the above category.
- rapsey 8y agoPeople say it was worse in the past. I disagree. In the past there was Vietnam which was just a big thorn. The current situation seems to just be a descent into insanity.
- abfan1127 8y agoWould you agree that in the past was worse, but we handled it better? Its better now, but we handle it worse?
- rapsey 8y agoI think that is a pointless way of looking at it. There was no internet then and the media landscape was a lot more different as well.
- chmod775 8y agoIn the past society used to challenge opinions more directly and immediately, sometimes even descending into outright "intolerant" behavior. Now the pendulum has swung and even the most eloquent, tame, and well thought-out argument is at risk of being labeled as intolerant of something. Add to that that echo-chambers have gone from what used to be small groups of people to the massive ones that exist on the internet today, and we are at a point where many people aren't used to having their opinions challenged. Reactions of people suddenly confronted with an opinion outside their comfort zone vary from responding with fallacies, seeking protection by an authority figure (HR, police, etc.) to losing their composure.
- nerdponx 8y agoI wasn't alive during the 60s and 70s, but from everything I've read and watched of that era, I don't think this has ever been true.
- chmod775 8y agoI'm not sure if "60s and 70s" is supposed to be some kind of strawman, because I specified no such thing (I was really thinking of a time period slightly later than that), but the Zeitgeist in that period was influenced by what happened earlier, so I'll humor you. Here's the sentence I assume you're referring to again: > In the past society used to challenge opinions more directly and immediately, sometimes even descending into outright "intolerant" behavior. The end of segregation fits well into the time period you specified, so let's use that as an example. - 1955-1968. Martin Luther King Jr becomes spokesperson and leader in the civil rights movement. - 1956. Montgomery bus boycott. - 1961. Freedom Riders. - 1965. Beatles refuse to play in front of a segregated audience. - 1965. Showdown in Selma. - 1968. De jure segregation is fully outlawed in the United States. You can imagine that all of these topics were publicly debated back then. Labeling someone a racist or intolerant would've been met with "Yes, I am. So what?" by some people, so that didn't even work as an "argument" by itself. For even more perspective, have a look at these surveys[0] conducted in the period 1960-1970, featuring such questions as: - "Do you think most Negroes believe in nonviolent action or do you think most Negroes would like to use violence in their demonstrations?". - "I'd like to ask you if you were in the same position as Negroes, if you think it would be justified or not to march and protest in demonstrations?" Imagine having that kind of discussion today. Yeah I can't either. People would be outraged and try to get someone fired. Maybe rightfully so. It took three decades for half of the opinions that were expressed back then to become "taboo", and another two decades for us to arrive where we are today, where pretty much anything that isn't a mainstream opinion on the matter is now a dangerous topic. Hence the pendulum metaphor. The predominant viewpoints have become entrenched and are being defended against any opinion that doesn't smell the same. Anything that just might threaten them, even if there is no obvious conflict, is labeled "racist", "intolerant", "left", "right", etc and shot down on sight. Debates back then weren't less heated, but there were more "real debates" and there were significantly less taboo topics and opinions. Edit: I rambled on for a long time, so to get back to the issue at hand, please imagine "Story 1" or "Story 2" from the article were set in 1960. They just wouldn't be plausible anymore. Nobody could feel "unsafe" or "shaken up" over these opinions - they are tame compared to the opinions publicly expressed back then. [0]: https://www.crmvet.org/docs/60s_crm_public-opinion.pdf https://www.crmvet.org/docs/60s_crm_public-opinion.pdf The PDF contains public opinion polls about some of the events I listed above, I recommend having a look at it.
- Qw3r7 8y agoSoviet Russia once predicted that the USA would Balkanize. Things could get interesting.
- maxxxxx 8y agoFunny that this prediction came true for Soviet Russia :)
- tyingq 8y agoSecondary to the main point, but complaining to HR for any reason is tricky. Their number one priority is to protect the company. Even if you feel that aligns okay with your complaint, they may not. They are also free to change their minds at any time.
- jawns 8y agoThese are flimsy examples of journalists being punished for not falling in line with groupthink -- and I say this as someone who has worked in several newsrooms with relatively uniform ideological views that did not match my own. The first case describes a columnist who wrote a piece that his colleagues disliked so much that they complained to HR about him. But it doesn't quite add up, and I'll tell you why in a minute. The second case describes what sounds like a case where an intern and a staffer were discussing a political issue and got into a heated argument, and the intern complained about it. But it doesn't sound like he got in trouble with HR for his opinion; he got in trouble for the way he expressed his opinion. So I don't think these two examples are really strong cases of journalists being punished by their employers for not holding a certain ideological view. And I think people need to understand that just because a journalist is reprimanded for expressing their personal views, it doesn't mean their employer has done something wrong. In some cases, keeping your personal views to yourself is part of the job requirement. For instance, if you're a news reporter covering politics, you _shouldn't_ be going around telling people your personal opinions about politics. In fact, doing so can get you quickly kicked off the beat, because you're (ostensibly) supposed to be objective and unbiased. On the other hand, if you're a columnist or writing an op-ed, the whole point is to share your opinion, and I think most writers and editors understand that there are going to be columnists with whom they strongly disagree. And that's why the first story seems so strange to me. If a newsroom staffer were to feel so incensed by a particular colleague's column that they think it shouldn't have been published, I would expect them to go to the section editor who signed off on it, or the managing editor, or the editor in chief, and urge them to take it down or retract it ... not to complain to HR that they feel unsafe.
- luckylion 8y ago> I would expect them to go to the section editor who signed off on it, or the managing editor, or the editor in chief, and urge them to take it down or retract it ... not to complain to HR that they feel unsafe. And nobody would expect people abusing the "report content" feature on Twitter, YouTube, FB etc to silence people they disagree with, yet here we are. HR will probably give less push back than an editor.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 8y agoJesse Singal is hardly a disinterested observer, he's a producer of anti-trans opinion pieces. https://jezebel.com/whats-jesse-singals-fucking-deal-1826930495 https://jezebel.com/whats-jesse-singals-fucking-deal-1826930...
- justin66 8y agoInteresting. I thought I detected the whiff of bullshit when reading the "about" on this blog, which looks disingenuous. I don't think I'm going to dig too much deeper. The main idea is to cover instances in which science and social-justice-advocacy get in fights, with an eye toward helping them get along better.
- amputect 8y ago"cover instances in which science and social-justice-advocacy get in fights" This is especially funny when you remember that Singal has a long-standing problem with the American Academy of Pediatrics, and objects to their evidence-based protocol for treating transgender children, and he personally prefers the approaches advocated by a discredited conversion therapist.
- malvosenior 8y agoIt doesn't seem odd at all that someone with non-favored political opinions would be concerned about attempts to silence non-favored political opinions through the use of HR. Out of curiosity, would you say that Jesse Signal's reporting would warrant reporting them to HR if you were their coworker?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wyoh 8y agoJesse Singal is not "anti-trans", that's a rather disingenious description of his work. He is pro-trans but his work explore some controversies with the current trans-movement, for which he gets a lot of harassment.
- major505 8y agoThis is the main problem when you consider free speech as "hate speech". I had to hear a sermon from my young brother who is 15, that something I said was "hate speech" (basically an opnion on abortion if I`m not mistaken), something he learned in school. I had to explain to him to no avail that theres not such a thing. There is only speech, and or is totally free, or is not free at all.
- LostJourneyman 8y agoFree speech means that you won't be prosecuted/persecuted by the government, not that you're free from social or societal ramifications. Hate speech is one of the exclusions (see Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire decision, ca. 1942) of Free Speech, but again: no legal action is being taken here so this is irrelevant.
- 781 8y agoA laywer was fired from a Harvard position at student pressure because he defended Harvey Weinstein: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/11/us/ronald-sullivan-harvard.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/11/us/ronald-sullivan-harvar... We are on the road to the Soviet Union, where your lawyer turns and testifies against you because only a criminal would defend a guilty person.
- stcredzero 8y agoArtists in niche media, like Magic the Gathering are being targeted: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1CC2Zy76zfM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1CC2Zy76zfM YouTuber who got his start in tabletop games commentary was assaulted at GenCon, and recently settled his lawsuit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASc2EPZBIoA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASc2EPZBIoA Comics artist Ethan Van Sciver was targeted for his political views, once involving vandalism of a shop. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmrAnkKCoFU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmrAnkKCoFU He went indy again, and ended up with one of the most lucrative comics Indiegogos: (> $800k) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YSODv4yD3Lg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YSODv4yD3Lg
- JaimeThompson 8y agoOh TheQuartering I really enjoy how he pretends that only the "left" as he calls it wants censorship. His deletion of comments that provide examples of censorship from the "right" "center" "others" appears to show he cares more about views and outrage than actually presenting facts. But he should not have been assaulted.
- stcredzero 8y agoOh TheQuartering I really enjoy how he pretends that only the "left" as he calls it wants censorship. I spent a lot of railing against censorship from the right. In recent years, there's a combination of many factors: Activists on the left who want to silence views they don't like, who also know people in tech and social media who have the power to enact it. So now most of the danger is from the left. The media power of networked viral distribution, plus monetization is so great, it's a game changer. It's in the same class of innovations as the printing press. (Both in the potential to democratize free thought and to control ideas.) In 2019, there should be a "right of discovery" in the same way our society acknowledges "freedom of the press." In 2019, the failure to acknowledge this new reality would mean that the public is ceding their ability to discover new information to gatekeepers enabled by mega-corporations. Indirectly through those mega corporations, the public is then ceding such power, to governments. (As is happening in China now.) It would be a kind of meta-censorship. It's not technically censorship, however it's actually more powerful.
- samfriedman 8y agoUsually when I read a headline like "X are reporting...", "Y is becoming...", etc. I expect to see some data that shows a trend, with analysis from the author to convince me that the trend is significant. This article is two anecdotes, one of which has since been "credibly contested". It reads to me like an author looking for anything to support a story they already knew they wanted to write, rather than a story that evolves from the facts and data available.
- zelon88 8y agoI don't like this piece. It's so vague there's really no story here. "Employee A had a disagreement with Employee B who filed a complaint with HR. HR investigated and took no action." Oh the persecution! > The mere involvement of local ‘authorities,’ whether school administrators or HR or whoever else, in adjudicating mainstream political disagreement can of course have a chilling effect on people’s expression of their political beliefs. That's their job. They go out and verify the claims and take action where neccesary. Since no action was taken one can assume no action was neccesary. That doesn't mean we revoke Employee A's right to complain to HR next time they have a problem. And it's important to note that if 90% of your workplace has a problem with your personal opinion, maybe your expression of political beliefs needs to be chilled. That doesn't mean don't believe what you feel and don't vote how you believe. That just means that if you have a pointed stance on race that flies in the face of civil discourse society is going to step in and make sure you hear the echo's of society. It's the same feedback loop that ensures KKK members know, without a doubt, that they're doing something wrong. That's a good thing. It doesn't mean they can't drink the Kool-Aid, but it means they should probably think twice before selling it at the supermarket.
- tomc1985 8y agoPerhaps, but anecdata like this is telling of an underlying political sickness that is affecting people (if they're true)
- lr4444lr 8y agoAll true. There still should be repercussions for weaponizing HR to make someone's life miserable when your only evidence is "accusing his column ... of making them ‘unsafe’" or feeling “shaken up” after a conversation with a colleague. The right response from HR, in absentia of any further evidence from the complainant, is either to recommend to the supervisor to deal with it tactfully or refer the complainant to the mental health resources he needs.
- nerdponx 8y agoI imagine this would fall under some kind of anti-harassment law/policy
- duxup 8y agoNot sure I buy into this blog's description as there is so little detail. I certainly have concerns about the scale of some opinions being quashed by corporate of collegiate oversight. But at the same time I see folks with strong opinions very very quickly go to "this is only happening because I have X opinions" and in reality they're just jerks about those opinions and the consequences are related to being a jerk, not their opinions.
- dbt00 8y agoExample A could be the author himself. And example B is already discredited. So that’s not super inspirational...
- gumby 8y agoSeems unlikely. I'd think that if either of these situations happened the affected person would publicise it for maximum value.