12 ms·
For those who don't want to read the opinion: SCOTUS holds that Apple can be sued for alleged monopoly of the Apple App Store. It does not decide whether or no
by jcranmer 8y ago
For those who don't want to read the opinion:
SCOTUS holds that Apple can be sued for alleged monopoly of the Apple App Store. It does not decide whether or not this alleged monopoly exist.
Interestingly, it's a 5-4 decision, with Kavanaugh writing the decision, joined by the 4 liberal justices. Probably the most unexpected alignment of the current term!
- charliemil4 8y agoEdit: friends, apologies for upsetting... first, I find the accusations horrendous. I am more just amused that K chose to write the opinion. Politics is a funny game. It’s hard to swallow, but we need a third constitutional convention because this stuff is wrecked in the us.
- davidu 8y agoPrior to the confirmation insanity, Kavanaugh was viewed as one of the best supreme court justice nominations for all sides. All the confirmation hearings did was potentially radicalize him to the right. One of the best things about being a supreme court judge is that he no longer has to care about being reappointed or elected. He's not doing damage control, he's just being a supreme court judge.
- beart 8y ago> Kavanaugh was viewed as one of the best supreme court justice nominations for all sides What is this based on? Everything I've read up to today, even ignoring the confirmation events, has indicated that Kavanaugh is not a desirable choice for those on the left side of the political spectrum.
- davidu 8y agoMy understanding is that when compared to alternative, qualified, right-leaning candidates, he was the most moderate. This is just based on people I know who have worked with him and tried cases in front of him.
- hadrien01 8y agoHe's the second most right-leaning Supreme Court justice: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-conservative-is-brett-kavanaugh/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-conservative-is-bre...
- burfog 8y agoThat is a year old, guessing based on what he did before being appointed. His actual votes put him much closer to the middle.
- jpmattia 8y ago> He's not doing damage control, he's just being a supreme court judge. As of last week, Rasmussen (a conservative polling firm) was sampling support for impeachment of Kavanaugh. It's possible that Kavanaugh is completely ignoring the topic, and has dedicated himself to the high-minded topic of jurisprudence. It's also possible that he is aware of such polling and is building support should the winds change.
- bena 8y agoThat's an interesting rewriting of history. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brett_Kavanaugh_Supreme_Court_nomination#Opposition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brett_Kavanaugh_Supreme_Court_...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- joezydeco 8y agoBut I've seen some speculation that after all the awfulness of the confirmation hearings accusing him of being a hard-right leaning justice that he would actually try (consciously or not) to show he's not locked into that mindset.
- davidu 8y agoThat certainly could be true. I like to believe supreme court justices remember that with that role comes with the truest ability to be impartial and unbeholden.
- rectang 8y agoThe justices probably don't believe that they are partisan. Rather, they believe that their own perspectives represent objective truth.
- debacle 8y agoThe same things (and worse, IIRC) were said of Roberts, and while I disagree with some of the rulings he has made, he's been remarkably unpartisan.
- davidu 8y agoI believe all of these justices care a lot more about their legacy of justice and the sanctity of the court than anything else.
- akhilcacharya 8y ago> Kavanaugh was viewed as one of the best supreme court justice nominations for all sides No he wasn’t. He was considered a partisan hack at best and was less popular than most previously confirmed justices. He did get approval from the Amy Chuas and Neal Katyals and Akhil Amars but that says more about elite Ivy League in-groups than anything else.
- HeWhoLurksLate 8y agoWas he not shunned by the Ivy League in-groups, as per [1]? I don't think this is as simple as it seems to be. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/we-were-brett-kavanaughs-drinking-buddies-we-dont-think-he-should-be-confirmed/2018/10/04/923cf6ac-c821-11e8-b2b5-79270f9cce17_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/we-were-brett-kavana...
- akhilcacharya 8y agoThat was post hearings, not pre hearings as implied by the GP.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bitwize 8y agoIt held that Apple could be sued by end users. Apple's argument was that only app developers had standing.
- dmix 8y agoApple's argument was that 3rd parties set the prices on their platform not them (app developers), so they shouldn't be held liable for the monopolistic effects this creates.
- DannyBee 8y agoThat is mostly irrelevant to this part of the case, which was about standing. Your parent comment (which is getting downvoted) is correct. Under previous precedent (Illinois Brick), only app developers would have standing to sue, and that is what apple argued should happen here.
- macleginn 8y agoHow can this be irrelevant to this part of the case if this is precisely why, as per Apple, end users don't have standing? The court rejects this argument and points out that who sets the prices is actually a technicality, which is less important than who buys from whom.
- DannyBee 8y agoThe parent comment is not talking about standing in a meaningful way. It talks about whether Apple should be "liable for the monopolistic effects" "liable for the monopolistic effects" != standing. Standing is literally about "who has the right to sue at all". Not whether they are liable or not. That comes later.
- zamalek 8y agoDespite what the Apple lawyers claimed, wouldn't the actual interpretation be: Apple could sue app developers? The developers are the ones "producing the concrete bricks" and Apple is the one "directly purchasing the concrete bricks." By arguing this way for this case, and setting precedent, Apple would have been able to manufacture a loop hole by subsequently using the more accurate interpretation. It's a very healthy precedent for app stores, regardless.
- khawkins 8y agoI think the fact that he sided with the liberal justices in favor of Planned Parenthood was less expected [1]. Especially considering his hearings were plagued with disruptions and protests from pro-choice activists. [1] https://www.politico.com/story/2018/12/10/supreme-court-planned-parenthood-defunding-case-845056 https://www.politico.com/story/2018/12/10/supreme-court-plan...
- curt15 8y agoKavanaugh agreed with Merrick Garland most of the time during his tenure at the DC court of appeals.
- perpetualpatzer 8y agoPresumably true, but that stat may be less telling than you think... Last year, every Supreme Court Justice agreed with every other justice most of the time, except Sotomayor/Alito (they agreed 49% of the time)[0]. [0] https://www.scotusblog.com/statistics/ https://www.scotusblog.com/statistics/
- noelsusman 8y agoMost judges agree on most cases. This is true on the Supreme Court and gets more true as you go down the hierarchy. That doesn't mean the disagreements aren't important.
- NowThenGoodBad 8y agoIf I had to guess, he knows that when things turn back around, he wants any and all reasons for people to be on his side. Keep a close eye on his decisions post 2020.
- binaryblitz 8y agoSupreme Court justices are appointed for life. There would be no reason to rule either way based on the election cycle. That's the whole point.
- docker_up 8y agoI think this proves that Supreme court justices are not aligned with any political parties. They take their roles very seriously. Kavanaugh looks to be very much a worthy Supreme Court Justice, same as Roberts who was elected by Bush (whom I hate more than Trump). I'm glad he was able to survive the ridiculous antics he went through and I think he will be a good justice regardless of what people think his allegiance was.
- AWildC182 8y agoProves is a strong word... It's a data point to be sure, but it's not proof.
- docker_up 8y agoIt really does prove it. If they were completely aligned with politics, they would have ALWAYS voted in a predictable way. They may have more conservative or liberal tendencies, but to think that that all Justices will vote the way that people want to pigeonhole them into is ridiculous.
- robbrown451 8y agoYou are seeing things in a very black and white way. I suppose it proves they aren't 100% (not 99.9999%....100%) bound to always make decisions precisely aligned with a political party. But no reasonable person suggested that.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt gives me a little hope that the justices sometimes still had their own opinions instead of just following the party line as they often do.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tomp 8y agoWhy would they follow the party line? They literally don't answer to anyone except their own conscience. In addition, they can remain in power for decades, during which time a party's policies can change drastically...
- microcolonel 8y ago> Probably the most unexpected alignment of the current term! Not so! There are many decisions by Kavanaugh that "liberals" (it's weird to me that they're called than in the U.S.) will have trouble predicting the opinions of conservatives [0]. “Who was best able to pretend to be the other? The results were clear and consistent. Moderates and conservatives were most accurate in their predictions, whether they were pretending to be liberals or conservatives. Liberals were the least accurate, especially those who described themselves as "very liberal." The biggest errors in the whole study came when liberals answered the care and fairness questions while pretending to be conservatives. When faced with statements such as "one of the worst things a person could do is hurt a defenseless animal" or "justice is the most important requirement for a society," liberals assumed that conservatives would disagree.” And they're probably even worse at this now than they were in 2012, if the inanity of the mainstream moral caricatures is anything to go by. [0]: https://reason.com/2012/04/10/born-this-way https://reason.com/2012/04/10/born-this-way
- gamblor956 8y agoOne of the things that Haidt leaves out of his article is that the % of difference between liberals and conservatives was within the margin of error. His findings have also never been validated, even by other conservative scholars, and he refuses to provide the data from this study. (Also, the study was a survey given to people attending the Reagan Library during the work week, so a highly self-selective bunch...) (Jonathan Haidt was a hero of one of my professors...until the scholarly issues with Haidt's research came to light.)
- outside1234 8y agoThis is what is great about it being a lifetime appointment. There is literally nothing else for these folks to strive for except being well regarded in the history books, so they can finally do what they regard as the best thing to do.
- ttul 8y agoA ten year term ought to do the trick, though. And would allow the passage of time to undo any stacking of the court that a particular president wants to engage in.
- ashelmire 8y ago6 year staggered appointments. So 3 justices terms are up every 2 years. Means one president doesn't get to completely stack the court, but each has a fair impact on it, and we aren't stuck with judges with outdated ideologies forever (unless people vote for it).
- eridius 8y ago6 years is awfully short for this sort of thing. What we absolutely need to avoid is having justices have to care about reelection, which means we need to say justices can only ever serve one term, which means we need longer terms.
- ashelmire 8y ago> What we absolutely need to avoid is having justices have to care about reelection It's an appointment, so they would only have to convince the president. Or you can prevent reappointment at all.
- eridius 8y agoOk "reelection" is the wrong term, but if anything this is worse, because if judges can have multiple terms then it means they're beholden to the current president when their term ends and therefore will be heavily swayed by party politics. This is why judgeships are normally lifetime roles, though the important part of "lifetime role" is "only one term" and not "never ends".
- adrianratnapala 8y ago> Interestingly, it's a 5-4 decision, with Kavanaugh writing the decision, joined by the 4 liberal justices. Probably the most unexpected alignment of the current term! It isn't really. It's just the standard partisan split, albeit with one guy "crossing the floor". Such crossing is common but since most of the media is incapable of understanding anything but partisan point scoring, they portray the Justices as partisan hacks, which they are not. Heck, they aren't even that good at tracking point-scores, since the most common score at SC United (states) is 9-0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_term_opinions_of_the_Supreme_Court_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_term_opinions_of_the_Supr...
- ulkesh 8y agoWhile I agree that much of the time they do try to rule based on law, it is clear that precedent is being looked at as mere suggestions by this new court. I wonder what the score will be when the challenges to Roe hit their bench.
- marcoperaza 8y agoThat's not something unique about "this new court". The Court has never been all that respectful of precedent. From the Lochner era (reading a right to expansive freedom of contract into the constitution), to the "switch in time that saved nine" (vastly expanding the definition of 'interstate commerce' such that Congress could regulate anything), to the Warren court (which invented whole-cloth a slew of social and criminal justice rights), the Court has often gone in radical new directions and overruled previous decisions.
- sgustard 8y agoThe "vote alignment by ideology" view on this page linked elsewhere is instructive. https://www.scotusblog.com/2019/05/opinion-analysis-divided-court-allows-antitrust-lawsuit-against-apple-to-continue/ https://www.scotusblog.com/2019/05/opinion-analysis-divided-... Basically in order from left to right numbered 1-9 the majority on this case were 1-4 and 6. So it's only one step away from being a fully partisan split. >"they portray the Justices as partisan hacks" I leave it up to others to decide whether scoring each justice on a left-to-right continuum is any more nuanced than this.
- posterboy 8y agoNo, it rules exactly that it exists or not. That's a tertiary logic, although not a legit figure of speech. I mean, if they didn't rule that the monopoly doesn't exists, which would have stopped the motion, and neither decided that monopoly was a fact, then they decided for or.