9 ms·
Something tells me people will find a way to complain about this. And that those people will be the same people that think Amazon's warehouse policies are oppre
by fastball 8y ago
Something tells me people will find a way to complain about this. And that those people will be the same people that think Amazon's warehouse policies are oppressive.
- vCorrect 8y agoTrue. Why not just employ people with a living wage, and then ask them to do a reasonable amount of things? Ohhhhhhhh... riiiiiiight... "profitability" and "being competitive."
- cheeze 8y agoIMO the best "counterargument" here is that those were jobs which paid folks who then paid into their local economy. That goes away with robots and becomes more revenue. Lots of folks are in favor of a "automation tax." I'm not sure how I feel. Note I'm not arguing these points, but merely pointing them out.
- avgDev 8y agoThe problem is that as we move forward and keep automating this will become a major issue in our society. I'm not sure if I support automation tax but it makes me uneasy. I work at a manufacturing company. We are slowly chipping away at data entry, manual processes. It only improves efficiency now, but eventually we will need less people.
- sphinxpy 8y agoI am in the same boat with my unease of the situation. Entitlements are already putting the US in crippling debt, however, I am worried that automation will destroy so many jobs that we need a universal basic income. Which I am personally not advocating. I am unsure of how I feel about it.
- RhodesianHunter 8y agoThe only entitlements that have any real budgetary impact are Social Security and Medicare/Medicaid. The former will only result in crippling debt due to mismanagement of the funds. The latter could (should?) be replaced with universal healthcare. The rest of the budget is mostly defense spending and debt servicing.
- cadence- 8y agoUniversal basic income seems to be the only viable way forward. So far I have not heard any other good solution to the societal problems automation is causing. The other alternative would be to slow the progress, but that’s even worse. We need to let people learn new skills, and universal basic income makes that possible. There will be obviously freeloaders, which is the main issue with this approach. This is extremely difficult problem to solve, and the current political climate makes it even more difficult to find acceptable solution Are there any other viable alternatives? How can we help people who don’t have marketable skills get back to work and contribute to the society?
- jcranberry 8y agoThe other solution I've heard is shorter work weeks.
- aey 8y agoIt doesn’t become more revenue. It maybe a cost reduction which in turn may increase profits, or reduce consumer prices. Either is a good thing. Amazon has a long track record of aggressively reinvesting its profits.
- cheeze 8y agoSorry, that's a much better characterization of it.
- aey 8y agoAmazon is the best of what capitalism can offer. They have basically crushed competition by focusing on providing better value, not building a monopoly through lobbying or a legal moat. Given that, I wish us economic policy was focused on allowing more Amazon’s to exist in more industries, and a social policy that focused on helping the folks that are acutely negatively impacted by competition.
- simonh 8y ago>Lots of folks are in favor of a "automation tax." I'm not sure how I feel. I think it's really important the operators of the horse drawn coaches, put out of work by the train I get to work in the mornings, are properly compensated. How is that to be funded without an automation tax?
- jodrellblank 8y agoPeople who operate horse drawn coaches can learn to operate trains. Once we automate everything the basic muscles of a human body can do without creative thought, that kind of comparable transition won't be possible and there will be 20-100 million Americans unemployed, hungry, and angry. You can have trite and dismissive mis-comparisons about the 1800s, or you can take it seriously and suggest some way society won't collapse in the ensuing riots. That would include you suggesting what new class of jobs are on the near horizon which can absorb hundreds of millions of low-skill human workers, without needing them to be smarter, but also can't be done by machines.
- drewmol 8y agoAnother negative impact of losing those jobs is that those folks paid income tax. When the operational cost of these tasks are transferred from payroll to capital expense the effective federal tax rate of what was payroll is lost (a ballpark 1.7% - 8.7%[0]) and the added automation cost is used as a deduction on a ballpark -1% - 1%[1] corporate income tax. [0]https://www.fool.com/retirement/2016/10/31/heres-what-the-average-american-pays-in-taxes.aspx https://www.fool.com/retirement/2016/10/31/heres-what-the-av... [1]https://www.vox.com/2019/2/20/18231742/amazon-federal-taxes-zero-corporate-income https://www.vox.com/2019/2/20/18231742/amazon-federal-taxes-...
- fastball 8y agoWhere exactly do you think those increased corporate profits are going?
- drewmol 8y agoSo I'm misunderstanding the effect? Is the outcome such that the reducion in payroll will lead to increase in profits and then pressumably that profit will be taxed at a minimum of long term capital gains rate when returned to shareholders?
- fastball 8y agoNo, it's just that you are only now bringing in capital gains, when that's actually pretty important. If all these corporate profits are going to shareholders, who are then taxed on capital gains, don't you think that's a little bit higher than the 1% you were quoting? So maybe if you actually finished doing the math instead of stopping in the middle, you'd see that automation isn't the tax loss you're making it out to be.
- drewmol 8y ago>So maybe if you actually finished doing the math instead of stopping in the middle I'm glad we have you for this time, will finish the math next time ;-)
- jcora 8y agoDo you think they're good working conditions? Also, a pretty large contigent of the left argues for automation.
- psychometry 8y agoAutomation isn't the problem. These jobs being lost are terrible and no one should do them. The problem, as always, is capitalism. Amazon wouldn't be where it is today without its massive workforce, including its army of factory workers. None of the people losing their jobs will benefit from this increase in productivity, though. Those gains will go only to the people at the top. Meanwhile, there will be more competition for the low-level jobs that still exist, creating downward pressure on wages.
- Eridrus 8y agoThe gains will also go to those making the robots and those buying from Amazon.
- ed_balls 8y ago> those buying from Amazon Only if there is enough competition.
- fastball 8y agoWhich, given the fact that Walmart is experimenting with the exact same robots, it seems like there is.
- ed_balls 8y agoThat's oligopoly. True competition needs to have many different options e.g. food. I can go out to a restaurant, order something or opt-out from the market and buy in a shop and cook it myself. But straight from the farmer or I could even grow it myself.
- fastball 8y agoOk, still seems like we're good then?
- AlexB138 8y ago
- crispyambulance 8y agoThat's a simplification. Amazon warehouses ARE oppressive. And there's nothing superficially wrong with automating the picking and packing of boxes. The problems come later, and it's not Amazon's "fault" but rather a much larger problem that eventually we'll all have to deal with: what happens when "enough" people get involuntarily shoved out of the workforce, with vanishingly remote prospects of securing other paying work?
- CodeMage 8y agoOf course, and with good reasons. Before you wrote your comment, did you stop to think why people work inside Amazon's warehouses if the working conditions are so oppressive? It's because the alternatives are still worse. And now they'll lose those jobs and have to face those alternatives. Of course those of us who perceive this as an injustice will complain. The complaint is not directed at Amazon only, it's at the injustice of systemic oppression of the working class.
- mft_ 8y agoCan I just clarify: you're saying that Amazon, despite offering jobs which are (apparently) less bad than other alternatives, are participating in systemic oppression of the working class? In your view, what should Amazon do to not systemically oppress the working class?
- fastball 8y agoGive people Perfect Working Conditions™ (presumably). Or maybe have robots and then pay working class people to do nothing?
- blub 8y agoPay a living wage and offer humane working conditions. This is not rocket science...
- SpicyLemonZest 8y agoThe question is whether that's an achievable thing, or whether people will always complain that whatever Amazon does is a non-living wage and inhumane working conditions.
- mft_ 8y agoI guess (economics aside) that a wage increase is a simple concept to grasp. But I'm interested how Amazon's working conditions are "inhumane"? I've read about 'picking' jobs which require lifting, bend, and walking for many miles per shift, but this doesn't seem more inhumane than many other jobs requiring manual labour? And I've read about complaints about the rate of workplace accidents (this was highlighted in the UK recently) but it's hard to tease out more details here.
- egypturnash 8y agoAmazon has probably wrangled massive tax discounts with the cities and states their warehouses are located in on the promise of providing jobs. Get the automation working and the jobs vanish. But I bet those tax breaks don’t. And I bet Amazon will fight tooth and nail against places deciding to revoke them.
- sidcool 8y agoIt has become fashionable to paint everything in black and white. The solution to workplace abuse is removal of jobs? Really? Automation is not bad inherently, but it's socioeconomic impact has to be ascertained.
- fastball 8y agoYou're right, automation is not inherently bad. In fact, automation is inherently good. And yes, the solution to jobs that humans don't want is to eliminate those jobs with automation. Working in a warehouse packing boxes doesn't suck because it's Amazon and they are a big bad employer -- it sucks because it's working in a warehouse packing boxes. We don't need to "ascertain it's[sic] socioeconomic impact" before we pursue the elimination of such things.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]