6 ms·
This is stupid. All the demos are on public roads. George Hortz needs to chill before he ends up in jail.
by rightbyte 8y ago
This is stupid. All the demos are on public roads. George Hortz needs to chill before he ends up in jail.
- aphextron 8y ago>This is stupid. All the demos are on public roads. George Hortz needs to chill before he ends up in jail. There are literally thousands of community members using this software on a daily basis, driving thousands of miles in real life situations daily. I've been commuting to work with it for 3 months now and it's the most lifechanging piece of tech I've come across since the iPhone. I get on the highway, engage the system, and sit back sipping my coffee for the next 45 minutes. It costs $800 to get fully setup with an EON/Panda/Giraffe and almost every Toyota, Honda, and Hyundai since 2017 is now supported. Check out some of the videos on youtube and you'll want one too.
- mayniac 8y ago>I get on the highway, engage the system, and sit back sipping my coffee for the next 45 minutes. Please, do not do this.
- aphextron 8y ago>Please, do not do this. I get that people are unable to comprehend the fact that true level 2 autonomy is here and ready to use, but it is. It's perfectly safe to sit back completely disengaged from the controls on OpenPilot, so long as your eyes are on the road (which the software enforces with head tracking). Any sort of situation that could require you to take control is warned in advance.
- mayniac 8y ago>Any sort of situation that could require you to take control is warned in advance. And what about false negatives, where something happens but it doesn't warn you? The fact that comma.ai pulled out of releasing the comma one when the NHTSA asked them some fairly basic questions is a massive red flag. They can't even guarantee that openpilot will detect low slung trailers or motorcycles [1]. If they want to develop and release autonomous cars of any level they should be going through proper procedures and regulations, not just sticking a "for research purposes only" sticker on everything and distancing themselves from any responsibility. There are far, far too many unknown unknowns when it comes to autonomous vehicles. If you're already forced to keep your eyes on the road, stop being lazy and do everyone around you a favour: grip the steering wheel, keep your feet on the pedals, and focus on the road. [1] https://opc.ai/faqs/does-openpilot-see-people-animals-motorcycles-low-slung-trailers-plastic-bags-baby-strollers-or-other-objects-on-the-road-wvmsxx https://opc.ai/faqs/does-openpilot-see-people-animals-motorc...
- aphextron 8y ago> If you're already forced to keep your eyes on the road, stop being lazy and do everyone around you a favour: grip the steering wheel, keep your feet on the pedals, and focus on the road. You do that, and I'll continue enjoying my self driving car.
- jensvdh 8y agoUntil it kills an innocent pedestrian. What are you gonna do then?
- jazzyjackson 8y agoThis is extremely reckless
- aphextron 8y ago>This is extremely reckless I find driving without it to be reckless at this point. Humans are susceptible to distraction, OpenPilot is not.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoThat might be the elephant in the room: contemporary driving is reckless _to begin with_. Autonomous assists are bringing this to light - not necessarily making it more or less reckless.
- tjpnz 8y agoNo more reckless than doing the same with Tesla Autopilot.
- gjs278 8y agoyou need to chill. he will not go to jail for writing software and releasing it. the fact that you think it’s ok to jail people for programming makes me want to throw you in the gulag instead.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoIt's unlikely he chills until someone dies or property in excess of hundreds of thousands of dollars is damaged, and an attorney pursues him personally. A hacker ethos is no defense against a personal judgement you can never repay in a lifetime. Unlike most judgments, punitive damages awards are not dischargeable in bankruptcy as long as the relevant cause of action was based upon willful actions. The audience won't be a room full of domain experts, but a jury of twelve.
- snazz 8y agoNo Tesla programmers have been arrested for Autopilot-related crashes.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoTesla makes it extremely clear to its users what the shared responsibility model is for Autopilot features (through warning messages at each Autopilot engagement and in the user's manual for all Tesla vehicles), and has general counsel on staff to reinforce this through legal actions indemnifying their staff. Openpilot is a drastically different model. It is a software breadboard for your own vehicle. For example, this is laughable (from the repo): (Top) > openpilot is an open source driving agent. Currently, it performs the functions of Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) and Lane Keeping Assist System (LKAS) for selected Honda, Toyota, Acura, Lexus, Chevrolet, Hyundai, Kia. It's about on par with Tesla Autopilot and GM Super Cruise, and better than all other manufacturers. (Bottom) > THIS IS ALPHA QUALITY SOFTWARE FOR RESEARCH PURPOSES ONLY.
- djsumdog 8y agoI remember Germany regulators wanted Tesla to stop branding it as "auto-pilot" when really their features are more like Lane Assist and Adaptive Cruse that many other vehicles have. Also, Tesla's have had their share of issues (the car that ran into an off-ram barrier killing the driver, the guy who was passed out for hours before his Tesla crashed), but they're also a large enough company they've probably settled some or all of these cases out of court.
- 8y ago
- lixtra 8y agoOne side of me agrees, the other thinks of the Wright brothers. Oh wait, they got someone killed.
- djsumdog 8y agoHe did? Wow, I have never heard this story: https://www.thoughtco.com/the-first-fatal-airplane-crash-1779178 https://www.thoughtco.com/the-first-fatal-airplane-crash-177... ..he killed an Army Lt during a demonstration, and took some pretty bad injuries to himself.
- rightbyte 8y agoYe, it is cool. How ever, I feel there's a huge difference between pioneering flying and risking the general public's lives to feed your proprietary machine learning model. Because Hortz hasen't released that part of the software right? Last time I checked it was still closed source.
- HALtheWise 8y agoI am genuinely interested, do you think that the Wright Brothers should not have developed the technology that they did because of the risk that someone would get killed? I am having trouble imagining any way (at least at the time, but probably today as well) of inventing manned flight without anybody dying in the process.
- amptorn 8y agoInventing manned flight without anybody dying would have been completely possible. Use more caution, pay more attention to safety. But that's not the right hypothetical. This is inventing manned flight without endangering or killing innocent bystanders.
- lixtra 8y agoI don’t think anything is possible risk free. So it comes down to your/societies risk tolerance how save, expensive and slow or risky, cheap and fast progress should be. Ideally the risk is taken by conscious and free individuals. But yes, bystanders will be hit as well. For manned flight it was totally worth the risk.