7 ms·
Nope, humans were trying to figure out how to manage the consequences of nuclear weapons, which were judged to be a necessary strategy to end World War II to at
by crazygringo 8y ago
Nope, humans were trying to figure out how to manage the consequences of nuclear weapons, which were judged to be a necessary strategy to end World War II to attempt to defeat fascism and save democracy.
Not "just to see what would happen" but to know how vulnerable our Navy would be to the very real threat of atomic attack from the Russians, and thus to responsibly inform strategy and tactics should that nightmare ever come to pass.
Testing decontamination also necessary to inform e.g. necessary fleet sizes in case of nuclear war -- could ships ever be reused or not? An existing shipyard is the logical place to do that, and unfortunately widespread environmental consciousness just didn't happen until the landmark publication of Silent Spring in 1962, more than a decade later.
Storing the contaminated sand on the ship and sinking it was a pretty reasonable thing to do at the time, not "just to use it as target practice" but to kill two birds with one stone.
Nobody's perfect, but you seem to really be judging people from several generations ago according to current societal standards, and completely misportraying their motives.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThere has also been an awful lot of humans doing stuff "just to see what would happen" across history. From ice-picks for faster lobotomies, through widely available quack remedies to project A119 - "I wonder what would happen if we nuked the moon". Let's not presume high moral motives in everything our forefathers did, nor to all of our current generation either. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_A119 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_A119
- paulddraper 8y agoIt's how we got a lot of our good inventions too. Also half the stuff that shows up on HN.
- jacquesm 8y agoIncredible that revealing that would be considered a violation of national security, conceiving it should have been considered a violation of national security. The dumbasses that came up with this idea were fortunately overruled by people with a bit more sense of what the public response to such vandalism would be.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAs 'paulddraper notes, doing things "to see what would happen" is a recognized research strategy that created a lot of science and technologies we enjoy today. This thinking, a childlike curiosity of sorts, is something you seek in good researchers. As for A119, the issues with the project were entirely political. The idea of bombing the moon is a good one; it's a legitimate way of collecting scientific data in lieu of being able to deploy a drilling team on the surface, and something that's been done with non-nuclear impactors. See [0], [1], [2], and probably a bunch of other cases I don't remember today. It's easy to say that "nukes bad humans stupid", but there are aspects to this idea - and a bunch of other so-called "peaceful uses for nuclear weapons" - that illustrated human smarts, not stupidity. -- [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LCROSS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LCROSS [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SELENE https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SELENE [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moon_Impact_Probe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moon_Impact_Probe
- monetus 8y agoDoes that type of aggressive research just assume that the systems being impacted are durable enough to withstand the destruction (2tons of tnt, in one of your links), or has that really been studied? I don't know the context of this, but I can't help but think of how many of the ocean's submersibles damage the ecosystem.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThe Moon has some very convenient features for such research - namely, it's a big, dead rock. Hard to think up a bad thing that would happen from hitting it with a satellite, or even a bomb. We already know it receives a regular beating from the solar system, in form of meteor impacts.
- monetus 8y agoI don't see one of the impact probes having as much force as a meteor, but I could see it being enough to throw off a fragile system. Yeah, its not like bombing ganymede or mars' ice-caps. I'm just curious if they are going to accidentally collapse some cave network, or give it a temporary atmosphere of dust. Edit: thanks for the response btw
- CalChris 8y agoHiroshima and Nagasaki were August 6+9, 1945. The Effects of Nuclear Weapons was published in 1950. Bikini Atoll was March 1, 1954. We already had a really good understanding of the consequences of nuclear weapons without needing to tow the Independence back to SF, sandblast it and sink it off the coast nearby. This was just stupidity. This was just the military ignoring what we already knew at the time.
- jjoonathan 8y agoJust how much information does the bombing of Japanese cities provide about the survivability of US naval assets against a nearby nuclear detonation? Ditto for an H-bomb on an island? Ditto for decontamination procedures?
- fredsanford 8y agoBetween your post calling the military stupid when it was just as likely a political decision (money?, who knows.) and the top level parent expecting people in the '40s and '50s to have the knowledge we do in 2019 I'm not sure what to think of this current generation. A very Clintonian version of US history...
- sathackr 8y agoMy 13 year old often has issues putting himself in the position of those with less knowledge than him. He somehow thinks young children should know as much about things they should and shouldn't do as he does. Or that animals have a cognitive ability similar to humans "I don't know why the dog wants the cookie, he knows chocolate is bad for him" I don't know what to make of it. I hope it's just the age, but since it seems to be a wide-spread problem....maybe it's something in the water. I don't remember having those kind of gaps in understanding at that age.
- crooked-v 8y agoWell, obviously you wouldn't remember any thought processes as being weird, because at the time it would be subjectively normal. When it comes to the poor judgement of teenagers, most of the brain literally isn't completely assembled yet until age 21.
- burtonator 8y ago"Nope, humans were trying to figure out how to manage the consequences of nuclear weapons, which were judged to be a necessary strategy to end World War II to attempt to defeat fascism and save democracy. " Fascism and WWII were created by humans. If you were an alien species and observing the earth from afar it's pretty insane how foolish we look. We've built the worlds greatest nuclear arsenal, then pointed them at each other. The Fermi paradox plays into this. If life is possible throughout the galaxy where is everyone? It's possible that life just destroys itself.
- adventured 8y ago> If you were an alien species and observing the earth from afar it's pretty insane how foolish we look. There's no reason to actually believe that those very aliens aren't just as foolish and survived, competed and advanced in part through a process of killing their fellow tribes of aliens to reach supremacy.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIn fact, if game theory is something to go by, these problems aren't "human stupidity", but they're inherent in any system that has thinking agents who have values, and no way to immediately, simultaneously and fully meet all of them. The hypothetical aliens would have some of those issues too.
- tehjoker 8y agoIt's worth noting that European fascism was mostly defeated by the Red Army at the expense of millions of lives, not the US which got into it late. In the Pacific sphere, there is fairly convincing evidence that the bomb was not at all necessary to convince Japan to surrender that is worth reading about: https://foreignpolicy.com/2013/05/30/the-bomb-didnt-beat-japan-stalin-did/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2013/05/30/the-bomb-didnt-beat-jap...
- dTal 8y agoMore relevant to the assessment of the morality of dropping The Bomb is whether it was reasonable to think it was necessary at the time. (I can't confidently assert that one way or the other, though I'm sure opinions differed even then)
- pdonis 8y ago> to end World War II to attempt to defeat fascism and save democracy. I realize this is what people were told during the war, but it's kind of hard to accept that that was the real reason for WWII when Eastern Europe ended up controlled by the Soviet Union, which was, by any reasonable historical standard, a worse totalitarian government than Nazi Germany. Not to mention that by the time the tests referenced in the article took place, China had also been taken over by a worse totalitarian government than Nazi Germany.
- pm90 8y ago> which were judged to be a necessary strategy to end World War II to attempt to defeat fascism and save democracy. This is emphatically not true, and a common lie used by the US to justify atomizing Hiroshima and Nagasaki. By that time in the war, Germany had already been defeated, the Imperial Japanese Armed forces were already signalling a willingness to end the war, with the one condition that the Japanese emperor (who most Japanese view as divine) would not be harmed. The US (and specifically Truman and Leslie Groves) wanted to demonstrate the power of this amazing weapon that they had developed to the entire world.
- mieseratte 8y agoThe programs long predate the fall of Germany, and thus saying they were developed to compete with a German nuclear program are completely accurate and reasonable. The Japanese were in the war, and a land borne invasion would have bore heavy casualties. There was no clear and obvious certainty of Japans will to surrender, and there was political infighting, an attempted coup against the surrender. I'm tired of this inaccurate, revisionist, fringe crap coming up every time the atomic weapons program comes up. This is not mainstream history, but historical-fiction entertainers like the irresponsible Oliver Stone keep promoting it and people lap it up.
- pm90 8y ago> The programs long predate the fall of Germany, and thus saying they were developed to compete with a German nuclear program are completely accurate and reasonable. The existence of the atomic program is not the question. It is their _use_ against a nation that was on the brink of surrender. I'm sorry that the truth does not fit your neat model of the US. It stands to reason, that the only nation in the world to use atomic weapons against dense human populations needs to be scrutinized appropriately, and not hailed as the "hero", the decision to do so being "inevitable". Nothing about the use of nuclear weapons was inevitable, and their use simply egged on similar development in other nations and a general increase in the probability of nuclear holocaust.
- azernik 8y agoFor a more nuanced view of the decision process, I recommend http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2015/08/03/were-there-alternatives-to-the-atomic-bombings/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2015/08/03/were-there-alterna..., and other entries on that blog about the Target Committee and Truman's role on the process. Generally, my takeaway is: There was a moral argument to be made in favor of atomic bombing for political effect. However, that argument was not very influential on military decision making at the time - generally, the military philosophy was "we have a weapon, why would we not use it to the greatest extent possible?" This disconnect was so strong that when the civilians who were making these sophisticated moral calculations saw the manner and (more importantly) the rate at which the bombs were used, they put on the brakes.