5 ms·
Making software is about asking questions. You ask the questions necessary to figure out the best solution to a problem. If you have a "man only" team, or "anyt
by onion2k 8y ago
Making software is about asking questions. You ask the questions necessary to figure out the best solution to a problem. If you have a "man only" team, or "anything only" really, you're less likely to have people asking different questions - they're all going to ask the same questions if they all have the same perspectives, biases, etc.
Diverse teams gather more information which leads to better insight of edge cases, and ultimately to better products.
- hnaccy 8y agoTech companies today seem more homogenous in thought and educational background than gender or race.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoThat's a sexist view. Men don't have "the same perspectives" on pretty much anything.
- CJefferson 8y agoA man only team is likely to miss some perspectives, which it is much more likely women will have, in the same way a female only team will miss a male perspective.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoAny team is likely to miss some perspectives.
- CJefferson 8y agoTrue, and trying to optimise for everything won't work, but we can try.
- bubblewrap 8y agoMany software products don't need female specific features. There is the famous story of the Apple fitness tracker that couldn't account for menstruation cycles, but that is a rather specific example. And that approach is doomed to fail in general, because there are too many different people. If you can only think of appropriate features by having a representative needing such a feature on your team, you'd have to hire thousands of people to work on your product.
- scooble 8y agoSo what kinds of things are female programmers going to miss? What kind of roles can we decide a priori should go to a man?
- bubblewrap 8y agoCan you give some examples? I find it very hard to believe, for general software products.
- chobeat 8y agobut for sure they cannot have the perspective of a woman. And a white bro cannot have the perspective of an Indian or a Chinese or a Quechua. Asserting that white brogrammers cannot embody some perspectives doesn't say that they have a uniform background. It just asserts that your team will be made encompassing just that set of perspectives.
- growlist 8y agoI've never seen rigorous scientific proof that these claims for the nebulous benefits of 'perspective' are real, outside of issues that are highly specific to a particular group - and let's be honest, we are all far more similar than we are different (highly unfashionable view, I know).
- inertiatic 8y agoDid you just assume their perspective? Maybe they identify as such.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoGive me an IT perspective that a man can't possibly have, but a woman can. Give me an IT perspective that a white man can't possibly have, but an Indian/Chinese can.
- DanBC 8y agoPeriod tracking apps are often written by men and fail to be actually useful to women because they miss a bunch of stuff. https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2018/11/13/18079458/menstrual-tracking-surveillance-glow-clue-apple-health https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2018/11/13/18079458/menstrual-...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- treis 8y agoThat's a pretty dumb article. For example: >Glow was even worse. The first onboarding screen asks users to choose their “journey” and provides three choices: avoiding pregnancy, trying to conceive, and fertility treatments. If you go to https://glowing.com/ https://glowing.com/ you can see their tag line is "Modern care for your fertility". So a good chunk of the article is nothing more than complaining that Glow isn't what they want it to be.
- layoutIfNeeded 8y agoWhy do you think that all men have the same perspectives and biases?
- makgf 8y agoThe problem with these threads is that many people make generalized and probably unfounded assumptions (like the one that is the topic of the article). So in this case I do not see at all that software from "diverse" teams has gotten better. I fact I think that overall software has gotten worse in the past decade. There is no structure, quality or documentation. The only thing that matters is that "something visible happens" so it resembles a product.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoHmm, it's a good idea, but it relies on men and women being fundamentally different (which I think they are) which goes directly against modern feminism. If men and women are fundamentally different then there are good reasons to choose men or women only in a given situation (along normal stereotypes: women are better caregivers, men are better manual labourers). Recruiting in this way is illegal in a lot of places. >they're all going to ask the same questions if they all have the same perspectives, biases, etc. // Then shoudln't you choose people based on their ability to consider the specific perspectives you need? One of the things about people is the ability to adopt the perspective of others readily.
- necovek 8y ago> which goes directly against modern feminism. Not sure about what "modern feminism" is about, but the goal is fairness, which means treating women as women and not requiring male characteristics. Basically, detaching personality traits more common in one population (eg gender) from actual job requirements.
- atoav 8y agoI don’t think there is a widespread consesus within Feminism for the idea that women and men aren’t different — and honestly, everybody who says so didn’t bother to inform themselves. Different genders/races/cultural backgrounds/educational backgrounds are connected to having different experiences in life. Of course you can imagine what e.g. sexism looks like, but when it happens to you every other day as a woman you will have it much more present than a man. Same thing with other aspects, people who have different racial/educational/cultural backgrounds bring different experiences with them and they might offer them precisely at the point where you didn’t think about it, not because you are a bad person, but because emulating all other perspectives your self is exhausting. The variance between individuals of both genders and within races/nationalities/etc is big enough for you to look on the individual level. When you say “women are statistically on average better caregivers” and hire only women, not only are you missing out on very talented men, but the functionality of your team is reduced as well. E.g. because in some situation a male caregiver might be a better fit for a given client. Not because they are better or worse at their job, but because beeing male brings a whole set of experiences, cultural expectations etc with itself. The same apparently goes for other traits your employee might have. Most jobs require teams to react to new and unpredictable challanges and having a broad range of backgrounds, helps them to always have a team member whi knows how to deal with it, because of their background ans life experience. When you hire a team where you have a monoculture, it is hit or miss. It might work well for a certain job at a certain time, but if anything changes, your team might be less resilent, flexible and able to solve problems compared to a more diverse team.
- bubblewrap 8y agoYeah because all men are completely the same.
- F-0X 8y ago> Diverse teams gather more information which leads to better insight of edge cases, and ultimately to better products. This is just an assertion currently, and I am not inclined to believe it is true. I would believe it for more "people" and/or culture oriented problems, such as catering, but for the majority of software development problems, diversity in people is nothing compared to diversity of software development experience. Which, ironically if we take as given most developers are white males, we maximise on average by only hiring white males!
- scooble 8y agoBack in the day, saying that an all female team of developers would be somehow deficient and would write inferior software would be seen as sexist. The idea that this kind of a priori judgement is not only acceptable but laudible has come as a bit of a surprise. Not least because it would seem to justify rejecting female applicants for a role where a 'male perspective' is considered important.
- treis 8y ago>Making software is about asking questions. All that time I've wasted writing code...
- onion2k 8y agoCode is the answers to the questions you've asked translated in to something a machine understands. If you're not asking the right questions your code is essentially worthless because your product won't do what the user actually wants. Hence software is about asking questions.