4 ms·
This is the key parts in one of the articles: >”Mandatory recycling programs aren't good for posterity. They offer mainly short-term benefits to a few groups -
by mc32 8y ago
This is the key parts in one of the articles:
>”Mandatory recycling programs aren't good for posterity. They offer mainly short-term benefits to a few groups -- politicians, public relations consultants, environmental organizations, waste-handling corporations -- while diverting money from genuine social and environmental problems”
And while the Three Rs make some sense, it’s overwhelmed by the above. The ‘crisis’ is kinda fabricated and a whole bunch of people make money off the fabricated crisis.
That’s not to say cheap consumerism isn’t s problem, I think if is, we should strive for quality and low impact, but beware behind every crisis are myriad bands of concerned groups making lots of money.
- TimTheTinker 8y ago> The ‘crisis’ is kinda fabricated and a whole bunch of people make money off the fabricated crisis. That’s exactly what many conservative voters suspect about climate change. They know they’ve been burned at least once over environmental issues. Edit: I’m not promoting climate change denial. Just pointing out that it’s possible to hold that view in good faith.
- hobs 8y agoThe reason why certain voters in the USA dont believe in climate change is because there's a dedicated network of corporations pumping money into the media that repeats this bad-faith claim. At some point it became table stakes for the conservative identity in America that you should reject climate change.
- eanzenberg 8y agoIts not that they dont believe it, they just think its not that big a deal. 4ft sealevel increase in 100 years
- VintageCool 8y agoI believe that's a recent movement of the goal posts; it's still quite common among conservatives to believe that climate change is a hoax.
- eanzenberg 8y agoPerhaps. Climate change has been scientific since what, the 70s or 80s? Only recently have we seen repeated significant increases in the global mean temperature. This means early skeptics now are forced to choose reality vs. being a conspiracy theorist. Politicians try to appeal to their base but both sides know climate change is 1) too far into the future to matter and 2) not much impact even in the far future.
- hobs 8y agoNo, "both sides" absolutely don't know this. In fact - climate scientists are talking about changes that need to be made in the next decade if we want to put off major ecological collapse.
- brightball 8y agoIt really didn’t. There are always a few loud people who will make a global warming comment on a cold day, but for the most part I’ve seen more sentiment around how we stop it from a global perspective without just penalizing ourselves. There’s also a very high degree of sentiment for more nuclear power and seeing opposition to it as double speak when it comes to climate change. Essentially, if you’re truly concerned about the environmental impact of coal power, etc but you oppose nuclear then you don’t really want to solve the problem as much as push a specific agenda. IMO the recent trade deals in Europe mandating high tariffs on imports from countries who don’t have a carbon policy in place is on the right track.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI think the biggest opponent of climate change is simply apathy. It is not that those people don't believe in it, they just don't care. It isn't as tangible or life quality effecting in the immediate term as air pollution was. It is more like the water will rise a bit, so what? Getting Americans to take climate change seriously will require a huge undertaking.
- eanzenberg 8y agoThe boy crying wolf has been crying for a few decades now. Didn’t Gore say we’d be underwater by now?
- mehrdadn 8y ago> They know they’ve been burned at least once over environmental issues. What is this referring to?
- TimTheTinker 8y agoRecycling.
- rdtsc 8y ago> They offer mainly short-term benefits to a few groups -- politicians, public relations consultants, environmental organizations, waste-handling corporations An important benefit is to the citizens who get to feel good about doing something to help the environment. This psychological / ritualistic aspect is probably just as important as the other ones.
- icelancer 8y ago> An important benefit is to the citizens who get to feel good about doing something to help the environment. But... it's not actually good for the environment?
- earenndil 8y agoIt makes the idea of helping the environment more prominent in people's minds, thereby making them more likely to do more to help it in the future (although it could have the opposite effect for some, making them think that because they already recycle they don't have to do anything more).
- Fezzik 8y agoI would argue that your parenthetical is more the norm, for the general population - given that people have the delusion that their zealous recycling is helping the environment, they feel like a large amount of their environmental-responsibility quota is fulfilled. They then pay little attention to all the actual harm they do through consumption and other activities. That is my perception having grown in a city that embraced recycling early (Portland, OR, USA) and where you are pilloried if you even hint that maybe recycling most things is a waste.
- dahart 8y ago> The ‘crisis’ is kinda fabricated and a whole bunch of people make money off the fabricated crisis. How much money? Who’s getting rich? Just curious, what is the recycling budget in the US compared to, say, water bottle & soda & plastic bag revenues? Are the small time politicians really more motivated and walking away with more pie than Evian and Coca-cola? Are you certain the crisis isn’t real? > beware behind every crisis are myriad bands of concerned groups making lots of money In a way, this feels like a way to cast FUD on recycling when it’s successful. It’s supposed to generate some revenue, and people are supposed to get paid to recycle. All services have industry, everyone involved makes some money, that’s how it’s supposed to work. At least with recycling, unlike landfill, some money actually comes back.