4 ms·
No, it did not “have a bad propensity to stall”. That’s a very imprecise statement in the first place but if you take it to mean, it would try to stall during n
by kortilla 8y ago
No, it did not “have a bad propensity to stall”. That’s a very imprecise statement in the first place but if you take it to mean, it would try to stall during normal flight conditions, it’s definitely false.
Airbus aircraft are “safe” despite the fact that dual conflicting pilot input is averaged without stick feedback (see the Airfrance flight from Brazil). If electronics being used to fly the aircraft upsets you, you’re going to be in for a real shocker on any airbus.
- marcosdumay 8y ago> That’s a very imprecise statement in the first place but if you take it to mean, it would try to stall during normal flight conditions, it’s definitely false. The precise wording would be that it is dynamically unstable, and the ball is with Boeing now to prove it's not the case. Also after all we discovered on the last weeks, Boeing better make a good case, or they won't convince anyone. The US aviation industry is about to change. I don't know into what, but it's not in a stable situation.
- JudgeWapner 8y agoif it didn't have a propensity to stall, why did they add the MCAS system?
- inferiorhuman 8y agoNo, it did not “have a bad propensity to stall”. Okay, how's: you can use thrust to pitch up a 737 beyond the authority of the elevator. Airbus aircraft are “safe” despite the fact that dual conflicting pilot input is averaged without stick feedback (see the Airfrance flight from Brazil). There is an aural warning (DUAL INPUT) on Airbuses with conflicting input.
- kuzehanka 8y agoSo much ignorance and misinformation about this issue even on HN. The parent comment and entire thread is 100% correct. There is nothing inherently unstable or unsafe about the MAX 8. It has a pitch-up characteristic that's mild compared to some other commercial jets like the 757. The only reason MCAS was put on that plane was to allow the MAX 8 to share a type rating with the rest of the 737 family, to make it so that it handles like any other 737 despite the pitch-up characteristic. Go ask any commercial pilot, go watch any of the commercial pilots on youtube who have commented on this, go look on stackexchange. The notion that the MAX 8 is inherently unstable, or unsound, or dangerous, is a laughable myth to anyone in the industry. I get that the news cycle is financially rewarded for fearmongering, but I really expected people who frequent HN to know better and do some cursory research into the topic rather than posting comments that perpetuate bullshit. There are several major issues with what boeing has done, such as the alleged failure to reclassify MCAS as a critical system after flight testing. But instead of discussing these legitimate issues, public debate seems to have been directed towards a bullshit myth about the airframe being inherently unstable. This has been eye-opening and dispelled my notion that HN had above-average quality of discussion on technical topics.
- JudgeWapner 8y agoyou're concerned about "comments that perpetuate bullshit". To me, the real bullshit is that a computer drove 2 aircraft into the earth. If we're so mistaken about what happened here, maybe the boeing engineers are similarly mistaken about how flight control systems work. I think they're the ones who have "ignorance and misinformation", like how many AoA sensors are required. Or whether a vigorous elevator UP position from the stick should be ignored and in fact counteracted by an opposite stabilizer position. Tell me what perpetuates the arrogance in the software departments at boeing that the computer knows better than the human. Unlike the pilots, the computer has nothing to lose. Yet the computer won the final decision. But calling this out is just the "news cycle financially rewarding" ... something ?
- inferiorhuman 8y agoIt has a pitch-up characteristic that's mild compared to some other commercial jets like the 757. Do you have any personal experience with or references for this claim?
- elpatinante 8y agoThat's not quite correct. When the aerodynamics of a plane was not designed to push forward the mounting of the engines, you have more reinforcement. That alone causes an uneven distribution for lift not accounted in the design itself. THIS is what causes the plane to nose up. But that doesn't mean stress is not put on the frame itself and mechanical parts that will be, on a daily basis, "abused" to the point of metal fatigue. You see, when it comes to aerodynamics, it's easy to test it on a simulator. And it seems boeing's 737 max passed with flying colors. Then, it had to fly. That's the moment when test pilots came to a conclusion that the design will not work. Boeing's solution was a software "fix" and it needed to relay on 1 sensor to pass certification. So, what do you have? NO TRAINING on this airplane, a bugged software system, poor aerodynamics, poor design choice, stress on elevator, etc. The ethiopian airlines plane had such force that pilots were not able to manually turn the trim control wheel. Do you know how much force that plane had to have that the jack screw couldn't be operated manually? THAT is a severe design flaw. THAT is what is being investigated. Who is investigating Boeing? Boeing is investigating Boeing. Boeing on 5/7/19 admits it knew they had a severe problem but it can still be fixed. Who certified the fix? Boeing. But now the FAA is investigating that fix which was promised by April. Again, this is a severe design flaw with still many unknowns yet to be found.