4 ms·
It's rather weird to ask a huge number of mostly-good airplanes to be thrown away for PR reasons, rather than fixing them. (Not to mention that these planes ha
by skybrian 8y ago
It's rather weird to ask a huge number of mostly-good airplanes to be thrown away for PR reasons, rather than fixing them.
(Not to mention that these planes have never crashed in most countries, even with an admittedly serious bug.)
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>It's rather weird to ask a huge number of mostly-good airplanes to be thrown away for PR reasons Welcome to the internet where other people's money doesn't matter.
- Aeolun 8y agoI don’t know about you, but in my real-life other people’s money doesn’t matter either.
- nikofeyn 8y agoit’s not just pr reasons. they tried to hot patch this airplane design with software, and now they are hot patching that fix. it seems it is a fundamentally flawed design that they tried to hide and get away with rather than doing the right thing. i know i don’t want to fly on a 737 max ever, and this whole ordeal with boeing and the faa has made me less confident in the airline industry as a whole. your parenthetical still shows some finger pointing towards “poor” countries’ pilots and ignores the number of crashes and reports for as young as this plane is and the numbers in use.
- skellera 8y agoPilots are highly trained. They go through many hours of simulated flights. After an incident like this, any pilots still flying a MAX will be drilled on this specific failure. If you start to see pilots refuse to fly it, that’s when you should worry. Aviation adapts to problems and it always has. Southwest installed additional gear on their planes to help prevent this when the first plane crashed. It’s not far fetched that companies in countries with lesser regulations might skip out on training or plane enhancements that would lessen the chances of this problem.
- hirowan 8y ago> After an incident like this ... Clearly, that didn't happen, or a second MAX wouldn't have crashed under very similar circumstances. > Southwest installed additional gear on their planes to help prevent this when the first plane crashed. Southwest ordered the MAX with an AoA indicator; it wasn't retrofitted. > ... to help prevent this ... It's questionable whether the AoA indicator would've made a difference. However, an AoA disagree alert that is standard in the previous 737 gen was "accidentally" made part of the AoA indicator extra feature set on the MAX, and the AoA disagree just _might_ have made a difference. [1] > It’s not far fetched that companies in countries with lesser regulations might skip out on training or plane enhancements that would lessen the chances of this problem. An AoA indicator is not mandatory anywhere in the world. [1] https://www.aviationtoday.com/2019/05/06/boeing-angle-of-attack-disagree-alert/ https://www.aviationtoday.com/2019/05/06/boeing-angle-of-att...
- codedokode 8y agoI doubt that. Pilots get used to flying on an autopilot and often make mistakes when they have to control everything manually. Recent example is a crash of SSJ100 in Moscow where the pilots failed to land the plane manually when the computer turned off. If you make controls more complicated, pilots will make more mistakes in critical situation.
- skybrian 8y agoThe fix taking a while to get right is not evidence for "fundamentally flawed". You have a strange idea about how to assess risk. It's like faults are somehow contagious.
- jschwartzi 8y agoThe notion that you can fix an aerodynamic stability problem in software by making a software program mimic the flight characteristics of an older plane is fundamentally flawed. And the notion that we can just patch the system later if it turns out you did it wrong is dangerous. You're betting with human lives that this time you've got it right.
- TomVDB 8y agoWhy is it fundamentally flawed? There’s no question that Boeing’s implementation had major issues, but there is IMO a higher burden of argument(?) to declare that a fundamental inevitability. This could simply be a case of Boeing incompetent/reckless/...
- Aeolun 8y ago> It’s like faults are somehow contagious. They are. If 737 MAX was rushed to market and this is the first issue we become aware of, how many more are hidden? If Boeing makes a habit of rushing planes to market without certification, how many more ticking time-bombs are flying around?
- Farradfahren 8y agoThats a perfectly fine diesel-plane - we can rebuild it, we had the technology.
- owenversteeg 8y ago>(Not to mention that these planes have never crashed in most countries, even with an admittedly serious bug.) In... Most countries? That's such a weird standard to hold an aircraft to. Even very serious aircraft issues before typically only resulted in crashes in a handful of countries! Did I read that wrong or do you want 100+ of the 200ish countries in the world to have experienced a 737 MAX crash before scrapping the MAX?
- skybrian 8y agoJust putting the safety record into context. Actually, I think if the planes can be fixed (and I'd be shocked if they couldn't), the two crashes before the fix will no longer be relevant for assessing safety.
- hirowan 8y agoYou're putting the safety record into chauvinist context, to be exact. An AoA failure is sufficiently rare for it to have only occured in a couple of occasions in - shockingly - only a couple of countries.
- skybrian 8y agoOkay, I probably should have calculated the number of successful flights to avoid this. But, nowhere did I say any country is better than any other. That's your inference.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cjbprime 8y agoI can help with that -- the MAX is suffering hull losses per flight completed at a rate about 100x that of comparable planes like the A320. Totally off the charts.
- 8y ago