5 ms·
I've never understood why so many people were/are so bullish on Uber. I understand that ride hailing is a big deal, but it doesn't feel like it's that hard to l
by criddell 8y ago
I've never understood why so many people were/are so bullish on Uber. I understand that ride hailing is a big deal, but it doesn't feel like it's that hard to launch a new ride hailing company.
I'm basing that opinion on what I've seen in my city. When Uber and Lyft left Austin, there were lots of alternatives that had existed or popped up to fill the space.
Aside from brand recognition, what does Uber have that the others don't?
- thatoneuser 8y agoBrand recognition is huge. It's easy on HN to abstract this away as a simple scheme, but your customers are entrusting their lives. Lyft and uber initially had to pay out of pocket hourly wages to get drivers on board. Yes you can pretty much have insurance a car and a simple app and recreate the service but there's much more in it for anyone but big players. And why would they try jumping in at this point?
- freddie_mercury 8y agoI don't think brand recognition is huge. In my city I've seen people jump from Uber to Grab to GoJek in the space of 3 years as each new entrant slashes to win market share. No one has had any trouble switching.
- unreal37 8y agoThere's brand recognition. And then there's brand loyalty. Uber has a lot of recognition, but not necessarily loyalty.
- lkbm 8y ago> When Uber and Lyft left Austin, there were lots of alternatives that had existed or popped up to fill the space. I tried to use one or two of those alternatives. Setup was a pain and I ended up taking a cab. I have at least one coworker who couldn't get a ride because he was in South Austin. Additionally. if your company is only in one city, visitors have to know about, install, and setup a new app just so they can use you; it's just as easy for them to take a cab. Last time I needed a ride in DC, I used the Lyft app that was already on my phone. There was no friction in being in a different city. Maybe there was a local alternative in DC, but who's going to look up local ride sharing companies and install yet another app when the app they already use at home already works? Even hailing a cab is easier than installing a new app for one or two rides while you're in a new city. Uber and Lyft have network effects.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SOLAR_FIELDS 8y agoReally? I’ve mentioned it on here before but I used Fasten as a rider pretty religiously in Austin whenever Uber and Lyft left and it was just as easy to set up and hail rides as with Uber and Lyft. I switched back to Lyft when they came back only because the rides subsidized by VC money ended up being cheaper but if they were same price I would happily switch back to some other software. Regarding your second point whenever I travel internationally one of the first things I do before traveling is to search for rideshare <cityName> on the internet. Whatever pops up I just download that app and set up my payment before I even get there so I can seamlessly hail rides. Often there is a thread on TripAdvisor waiting for me that compares the options.
- lkbm 8y agoI think Fasten declined my card. I then tried FARE, but it wasn't working either for some reason, and I was in a hurry, so instead got a cab instead (which I paid for with the card Fasten didn't like). I hadn't expected to be in DC--My connecting flight was cancelled, so I needed a ride to the bus station. But I think if it had been planned, I would have Googled "is Lyft in DC?" and seen that I was all set. Maybe I could save a few bucks by installing an alternative service, but it wasn't worth it to me to bother. (On the other hand, my price insensitivity is largely because I only take a Lyft/Uber about six times a year, so they might lose heavy users more quickly.)
- unreal37 8y agoUber and Lyft have "network effects"? How? Explain that. I couldn't tell you what car sharing service any of my friends use. When I was in Malta earlier this year, there was no Uber. I downloaded an app called Taxify while sitting at a cafe, and called a car from it. It's not a huge barrier to download and install another app, even when trying to call a car.
- peripitea 8y ago
- computerex 8y ago> Aside from brand recognition, what does Uber have that the others don't? Brand recognition is no small thing. Hyper growth is what a lot of companies are going for, because that's the model that lead to amazon dominating the world. Ubering being a verb is very valuable.
- disgruntledphd2 8y agoHypergrowth from re-investing profits is very different from hypergrowth from kind investors. One of those leads to massive profit (eventually), and we'll see what happens with Uber.
- computerex 8y agoDisagree. Everything is a trade off. You can either choose to aggressively grow at the expensive of burning cash or you can try to focus on becoming profitable. Many companies bet that the growth story is better than early profitability. Market seems to agree. Remember, even Amazon loses money on almost everything and their cash cow is AWS.
- _bxg1 8y agoEase of competition aside, I still think Uber is a massive bubble. Ride-hailing is of dubious actual utility, it's been causing traffic problems (and has been getting regulated accordingly), it has ethical problems with regards to employment (and faces constant threat of regulation from that angle too), and above all else, it's clear at this point that it will never be profitable while it relies on human drivers. Investing in it is basically a hail-mary that we'll get fully autonomous vehicles within the next couple of years, and even in that best-case scenario Uber would be a strong-but-not-world-eating company (the traffic problems would still exist, and operating costs would skyrocket in the short-term before they go down). I can't fathom how it's worth nearly $10 billion dollars. I almost want to short it.
- freewilly1040 8y agoDubious utility? It's a massive improvement over cabs for the consumer.
- _bxg1 8y agoIs it though? Cabs have apps now. What makes them different? If the answer is the price, well, that price is unsustainable and denies thousands of people a living wage.
- criddell 8y agoThe answer isn't price (IMHO). It's the quality of service. I'm mostly talking about better cars, friendlier drivers, and rides that show up when they say they will. I haven't used a cab app. Are the taxi apps similar to Uber and Lyft's where it identifies the car and driver and you can track the location of that car on a map? Do drivers and passengers rate each other?
- SOLAR_FIELDS 8y agoAnswer: it depends. When I lived in Malmö they had Taxa97 which was basically the same as Uber/Lyft. You can schedule rides, rate drivers, map view, and see the price of the ride before you take it. same with the taxi apps in Denmark. Other places have not as nice taxi apps. But in general taxis having to compete has generally brought them in line with U/L, at least in most of Europe. The only major difference with the taxi apps is that the drivers are first party instead of third party so the companies have a perverse incentive to trust their drivers more than the riders. Of course, the more competition you have the less of this behavior you see.
- rhcom2 8y agoUber Eats?
- OrgNet 8y ago> I've never understood why so many people were/are so bullish on Uber. Uber is bullish, maybe that's why?
- vitorgrs 8y agoHere in brazil the most popular is Uber and 99 (which Didi, from China, is basically in charge). The price on both is basically the same here in my city, but I still use Uber because one little thing: Uber has fixed price. I know how much I'll pay for that ride. Simple as that.