3 ms·
According to the unending stream of devs saying that they just want to ship iOS apps on macos, this is the most important thing. I agree with you entirely: I e
by olliej 8y ago
According to the unending stream of devs saying that they just want to ship iOS apps on macos, this is the most important thing.
I agree with you entirely: I expect a huge flood of awful software.
Marzipan for games seems more reasonable, but only because most games are "create a single window, and go fullscreen".
- saagarjha 8y agoMarzipan doesn't seem all that useful for games, since they'd be targeting OpenGL or Metal for their UI anyways (plus I think a lot of games use Unity anyways, which does a lot of the hard work from what I hear).
- olliej 8y agoplenty of games come to iOS before macOS now. Marzipan means (I think?) you get a lot of the the basics: get a window, setup a gl/metal context, start drawing. That's more or less the entirety of a game's output. Input then means adding a mouse/keyboard path in addition to touch events and it seems like that's something that should be easy :D Honestly the effort to setup a GL (and I assume metal) view is kind of annoying on macOS.
- saagarjha 8y agoMarzipan bridges almost every iOS framework (notably UIKit) to macOS. Games tend to not link against these.
- olliej 8y agoSorry, what I was trying to say is that basically all games want to do is get pixels to the screen - they're aren't really using the OS to do anything else: no system UI, etc
- saagarjha 8y agoThat's my point as well: you don't really need Marzipan for this. Putting pixels on the screen using OpenGL is already pretty easy for pretty much every platform.
- olliej 8y agoHaha I’m not saying you need this, I suspect for many devs using marzipan and adding mouse+keyboard handlers is probably less work than setting up a real Mac app. But for games I’m not super concerned as they’re not generally heavy on the OS UI.
- valleyer 8y ago> Marzipan means (I think?) you get a lot of the the basics: get a window, setup a gl/metal context, start drawing. That's more or less the entirety of a game's output. There's a template in Xcode to set all of this up for Metal. It takes about five clicks. For OpenGL, it's as simple as adding an NSOpenGLView to a nib.
- olliej 8y agoBut compare to just recompiling your IOS app to marzipan - you no longer need to have separate paths to initialize the gl context - all you need is the different event handlers. I like to imagine that a point+click name wouldn’t even need that.
- w0utert 8y agoYou're really grossly overstating the effort to port a typical full-screen OpenGL/Metal application over from iOS to macOS or vice versa. It's literally a 1-hour job at most to get a drawing context initialized and up and running even when starting from scratch. Any experencied dev who has done it before just re-uses what's already there and will be done in 10 minutes tops. Obviously you're not even 1% of the way of 'porting your iOS game to macOS' after that, the remaining 99% will be in re-implementing a mouse-based UI, and dealing with the fact that your running on hardware with completely different capabilities and performance profiles. Marzipan will not be able to help with any of that.
- babuskov 8y ago> That's more or less the entirety of a game's output. Output is only a very small subset of a game. You need stuff like UI layout or Scene graph with transitions, tweening, texture atlases handling, animation, etc. A good game engine like Unity or libGDX provides all that without a game programmer having to reinvent the wheel. See for example a list of classes the libGDX API provides: https://libgdx.badlogicgames.com/ci/nightlies/docs/api/ https://libgdx.badlogicgames.com/ci/nightlies/docs/api/
- scarface74 8y agoApple said during their subscription presentation that the games that are part of the subscription service will run on Macs, iPhones, iPads, and AppleTV’s. Speculation is that it’s part of the Marzipan effort.
- novok 8y agoWhat would be worse, marizpan apps or electron apps?
- olliej 8y agoboth are terrible, but I might actually lean towards marzipan being worse, because at least electron apps acknowledge they're not running on a phone? But I feel it's quite close
- saagarjha 8y agoMarzipan apps use fewer system resources, at least, and they tend to respond to platform conventions better (you know it's a low bar when I'm saying this about Marzipan :/)
- olliej 8y agotrue, battery life is probably better, but I'm still super worried by the ui convention and design. But yeah, we're not talking about high bars here :(
- fauigerzigerk 8y agoWe can always hope, but the Marzipan apps I have used so far (News and Stocks) are incredibly slow and don't adhere to platform conventions at all. I truly hope (and believe) that they are not representative of what Marzipan will be able to do in the future. I have never used a single Electron app that was nearly as bad. In fact all Electron apps I have used are pretty good (VS Code, Spotify, Exodus). Yes they do use more memory, but not nearly enough to pose a problem for my 2012 Mac mini with 8GB RAM.
- matwood 8y ago> but the Marzipan apps I have used so far (News and Stocks) are incredibly slow and don't adhere to platform conventions at all I agree. We do not have much to judge off of yet, so I'm holding out hope these are not final examples. Apple knew people would find out what was being worked on so went ahead and gave a small early preview. What we see at this years WWDC will be telling.
- threeseed 8y agoDuring the original iOS days there was a flood of awful software. And then the developers gained experience and now the quality is overall pretty decent.
- olliej 8y agoThe concern isn't necessarily that the software is /bad/, it's that you get a bunch of iOS apps that just get recompiled to macOS with no thought to the different interface being used, etc.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agothis is the most important thing To them, not necessarily to Apple nor their customers.
- olliej 8y agoI agree entirely, but nonetheless that's what they feel.