3 ms·
> AV1 is an open and free format, but if people really wanted to replace GIFs they could've done it with H.264 or VP9 or VP8. They have. The "gifs" on reddit o
by masklinn 8y ago
> AV1 is an open and free format, but if people really wanted to replace GIFs they could've done it with H.264 or VP9 or VP8.
They have. The "gifs" on reddit or imgur are generally h.264, even if you upload gifs they'll get converted to video files.
TFA's just saying those should be switched to AV1, or an AV1 source should be provided.
I'm not sure they're right though. h.264 will be larger and of lower quality especially at low bitrates, but clients can offload the decoding to hardware whereas with AV1 most or all will be decoding in software.
- tjoff 8y ago... and it is a complete mess. They try to to decide which format you want based on your client. Thus if you hotlink an image directly you don't know anymore if it will load or even if the format the next guy will see has sound. I've linked "images" purely because of the sound and other viewers got a version without it. And many times it just won't load. This is supposed to be simple...
- Dylan16807 8y agoSome sites (looking at you, imgur) are really bad about that. Doing what this article recommends shouldn't cause those problems, though. The only notable risk is linking a format that mobile can't load.
- silversconfused 8y agoOften you can just load the same url with .gif on the end and it will work, since they make many formats available with the same base filename.
- tjoff 8y agoHow is that not a complete dealbreaker though? I as a user can't possibly be expected to know and deal with whatever the recipient of my link uses. A magnitude or two of data and worse quality is a small price to pay for something that actually works and still loads in realtime, even on mobile, anyway.