7 ms·
It’s time to outlaw stalking-based business models. If you just break up Facebook but don’t outlaw the underlying scummy business model something else will just
by Nextgrid 8y ago
It’s time to outlaw stalking-based business models. If you just break up Facebook but don’t outlaw the underlying scummy business model something else will just take its place.
- istjohn 8y agoPeople are waking up to the importance of privacy. If FB had competing social networks, consumer choice would matter. As it is, we have false choices like FB vs. IG.
- dageshi 8y agoTwitter?
- bluGill 8y agoDoesn't solve the same problem.
- adventured 8y agoFacebook, Twitter, Reddit, LinkedIn, Instagram, YouTube, Pinterest, Snapchat Those are by far the dominant social networks in the US. They all compete in terms of fighting for limited user time. WhatsApp is kinda sorta in that group, however it's not particularly popular in the US. Tumblr used to be, it might as well be dead now, it's going the way of MySpace (sold off a few times, passed around, until it's hardly valuable at all). Snapchat competes primarily with Facebook and Instagram. At the edges there's some competition with sites like YouTube, Reddit, Imgur (and other image sharing networks). Instagram competes with core Facebook, which is of course why they ate them. Also with Snapchat. To a lesser extent YouTube, Pinterest and misc image sites. YouTube competes with Facebook and their goal to build a much larger user video platform. To a lesser extent they compete with Snapchat and Instagram, particularly on very short form user video. Reddit competes with Twitter and some of the smaller niche social networks like Imgur. There's some limited competition between Reddit, Instagram and Pinterest. LinkedIn competes with Facebook. Microsoft scored a nice protected fiefdom in LinkedIn. It suffers no serious competitive threat other than incompetence. When you examine the competitive landscape, it's very clear that Facebook has no direct competitor to their core platform. And further, Instagram has far overwhelmed its competition. Facebook core is Facebook's Google search, Instagram is Facebook's YouTube, all are monopolies at what they do. The scope of Facebook core + Instagram + WhatsApp is breathtaking, it must be something like 2.6 to 3 billion monthly actives now when you include everyone across all three major platforms. The most interesting social network among the group, is Pinterest. If they don't screw things up, they'll have a far better business than Twitter over time. It's a dramatically more mainstream product with direct, obvious, superior monetization potential. None of the other social networks can compete well with what they do (not without contorting themselves into a pretzel and risking their existing userbase and business).
- dondawest 8y agoI have never heard anyone say that Pinterest is the most interesting ANYTHING before. What do you consider to be their obvious superior monetization potential? And is their anything else about Pinterest that makes you find it so interesting?
- kermitismyhero 8y ago>Tumblr used to be, it might as well be dead now, it's going the way of MySpace (sold off a few times, passed around, until it's hardly valuable at all). That will turn around quick if Pornhub actually succeeds in buying it.
- dexwell 8y agoI recently launched Cardbox, an app that reimagines your address book as your definitive social network. No timeline, no posts, no ads, no data monetization; just contacts. As an independent place to stay connected, it enables people to leave social media without losing their social network (an important distinction). It also makes it easier to discover and try out new apps (just link them to your card). Check it out maybe :) https://cardbox.app/ https://cardbox.app/
- humanrebar 8y agoI think "surveillance capitalism" has a better ring to it. Maybe "corporate surveillance" if we want to be less ideological.
- maxaf 8y agoI think "surveillance capitalism" better reflects the underlying incentives, and is less likely to be confused with some other nefarious phenomena, such as surveillance of employees, or surveillance of other corporations by their competitors.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoIt's the advertising market that drives all of this. As you rightly point out, history is proof that the ad dollars don't care what the platform or who the messenger is, as long as they are easy to use and effectiveness can be measured.
- neuronic 8y agoAnd it will keep driving all of this because aside from enthusiasts and privacy focused people, nobody is willing to pay for Internet services such as FB, WhatsApp or IG. Few people are willing to pay for news. How many subscriptions am I supposed to have anyways if my go-to information consumption mode is to cross check several websites? I don't want to be confined to NYT, Der Spiegel, Wired or WSJ. I want all of them whenever I please. The Internet made this possible and now we are on the road to taking this away again. At the very root of all of this is the Internet's financial reliance on advertisements. Advertisement based business models need to die but at the same time we cannot lose the free, accessible Internet as it used to be.
- tremon 8y agoand effectiveness can be measured I don't think this is a prerequisite at all. Isn't most marketing focused on the persuasiveness of the seller, instead of the effectiveness of the product?
- manigandham 8y agoRegardless of what metric is used, ad platforms get more money by proving they're better at said metric, so measurement is required.
- saintPirelli 8y agoI don't think it's possible to outlaw what Facebook does without unforeseen consequences. Facebook is fast-food for the mind. You know it's bad for you, you know you shouldn't do it, you know there are healthier alternatives, the fact that corporations profit off of making people fat and sick is outrageous, but you can't very well outlaw the concept of beef in a bun.
- NeedMoreTea 8y ago> but you can't very well outlaw the concept of beef in a bun Well you can. Lots of things have been successfully restricted in the past, in lots of places. It doesn't have to give rise to the mob, illegal smuggling or iniquitous burger dens that so often is the American experience of outlawing things. Or you can just tax it until lettuce becomes appealing.
- panglott 8y agoPeople aren't mad because Facebook runs a social network or presents users with a newsfeed or provides a messaging service or stores users photos. Lots of companies do those things without complaint. People are mad at Facebook because the company constantly lies about privacy issues, makes one agreement with its users about their privacy and then does something else, and just generally treats the privacy of its users with complete contempt.
- saintPirelli 8y agoPeople aren't mad because MacDonalds runs a chain of restaurants or presents consumers with food or provides a easy way to get a meal. Lots of companies do those things without complaint. People are mad at McDonalds because the company constantly lies about health issues, makes one statement about the origins of their food when really it comes from somewhere else, and just generally treats the concerns of its consumers with complete contempt.
- panglott 8y agohave never been more on board with breaking up McDonald's. ;)
- pmart123 8y agoLet's not forgot social media platforms did organize an Egyptian revolt. When there have been natural disasters or terrorist attacks, Facebook has sent notifications to people's friends telling them they are ok. Also, tons of small brands now can exist due to Facebook and Instagram, and these companies can now do so from any location in the country or world. Facebook is a very metrics driven company, and privacy has been a remote concern for the company. I think they have dug their own grave if they even want to venture into finance or healthcare like Apple is doing. I would not trust Facebook with my health records or bank account. But, Instagram is great for finding vacation ideas and spotting new products or trends. Twitter IMO now often is a much better source of information than the NYTimes. Also, let's not forgot the NYTimes has its own axe to grind here.
- ATsch 8y agoWe should also not forget the genocide in Myanmar which has been enabled by and attributed to a lack of moderation and the prevalence of hateful fake news on facebook.
- reallytho9 8y agoYes, and once in a while kidnappers might even let you have a beer or walk around the yard. But soon enough it’s back into the basement you go. The point isn’t that Facebook is all bad, just that it’s mostly bad. And all of those things you mentioned can, and do, exist without Facebook. There was a world before Facebook, there will be a world after Facebook.
- dominotw 8y agoMost ppl in the world don't have credit cards to pay for a service online.
- criddell 8y agoAdvertising doesn't require surveillance.
- dominotw 8y agoWhy are they doing it then, if its not required.
- c0vfefe 8y agoBecause targeting is very profitable.
- dominotw 8y agoso effective advertising does require surveillance? Is there way to to know if companies like FB would be sustainable without surveillance or would they simply die out ? in other words, would banning surveillance business kill FB, Google ect? Would we still want that law if that was the case?
- bluGill 8y agonewspapers, have done just fine without it for several hundred years. Radio and TV likewise can't do it. Duck Duck Go doesn't use it and they do okay. There is a lot more money in surveillance based advertising, but it isn't the only way.
- c0vfefe 8y agoIt hasn't been technologically possible until recently, and now that it is, businesses are strongly incentivized to use it, in order to keep up with the growth of competitors that do used tracked advertising. Privacy-focused mass-market products like DDG and Firefox will very rarely be able to keep up with the giants that prioritize profit. As long as users disregard their privacy, there'll be businesses ready to entice them with customized features, and of course advertisers will reward that too. That's why regulation is the only real way out (GDPR, etc.).
- criddell 8y ago> It’s time to outlaw stalking-based business models. Data generated by users implicitly or explicitly should be protected in the same way other highly personal data is protected. I'm talking specifically about health data and video rental records and (in some states) library records.
- robin_reala 8y agoIt is in the EU. The US just needs to adopt something similar enough to GDPR to have teeth.