4 ms·
This article rests on much of the common ignorance around these counterintuitive issues. I'll try to address the biggest ones: - New supply in a desperate shor
by BurningFrog 8y ago
This article rests on much of the common ignorance around these counterintuitive issues. I'll try to address the biggest ones:
- New supply in a desperate shortage situation will always be expensive. Interpreting that as new supply being bad is the dumbest thing you can do!! Yet it's extremely common in the housing debate.
No! The new supply is expensive because of the desperate shortage! There is no magical way to build cheap housing in a shortage, liked no one would notice it somehow... The old housing is just as expensive! Keep the supply up, and prices will come down!
- "This is all the fault of foreigners and speculators".
No! We all have the impulse to blame our problems on evil outsiders who are different from us and don't care about human values like we do. That's xenophobic bullshit 9 times out of10. Vancouver just has too few homes for too many people. There is no foreigner conspiracy. Just build and and it will be alright, alright?
Probably didn't change anyone's mind, but I honestly think those are the two biggest points.
- Dylan16807 8y agoIt's not xenophobic to say that money is flowing in to building ownership, and that this inflates prices. You might be able to find someone calling them evil but that's 9/10ths strawman. And it wouldn't be a conspiracy in the first place.
- BurningFrog 8y agoIf that's an accurate description of what's actually happening, sure. But I really doubt that's the case. Normally prices rise because supply is strangled by legal restrictions, controlled by the local property owning elites looking out for their property values. That's definitely the case here in California. I don't know Vancouver enough to say. When that happens the secondary effect is that housing in that area becomes a great investment. This attracts investment capital from all over the world, much of it foreign, since it's a big world. This in turn probably drives up prices even faster. And... I guess it's not even exactly wrong to say that the foreign money is driving up prices in that scenario. But it's also not at all a root cause!! Trying to regulate it is attacking a symptom, not the real problem, and will solve nothing. The real solution is to "legalize housing", as the slogan goes. Make it legal to massively build the housing that is demanded, and there will be housing for everyone. And as always in these situations, getting to the real solution is much harder, because there is real power in the way who benefits from the status quo.
- Dylan16807 8y agoIf the root cause drives half the price increase, and the speculation drives the other half, regulation to fight speculation can do a lot! You certainly do want to fight both. And if it's harder to speculate, that might also reduce the pushback toward increasing supply.