11 ms·
What resonated with me is how impossible it is, as a kid, to make sense of being in the school system. The interaction with an administrator was school discipli
by klodolph 8y ago
What resonated with me is how impossible it is, as a kid, to make sense of being in the school system. The interaction with an administrator was school discipline gone awry... but it could have easily been something else. (Discipline is the most likely, there are tons of misguided zero-tolerance policies.) I'm lucky that my parents were advocates and organizers and that they knew people in the school administration. When a teacher emotionally abused me in class I was in a different class the next week. When I ran out of math classes to take at high school, I took them at college.
Years afterwards I was tutoring a high school student in mathematics. They asked me a question about school and I felt a moment of panic, as I remembered all of the shit that I went through.
By the time I finished college, it made sense to me. I could make it through an awful class or cut through red tape and weird requirements. I knew that I had survived a couple decades of bullshit, I was still here, and a little extra bullshit wasn't going to kill me. But at age 14, I remember being angry and upset all the time about things that happened at school.
- baby 8y agoHeck. I'm still making nightmares about being back to school.
- asark 8y agoMid 30s, same, and my k-12 experience wasn't even bad. I wasn't really bullied. I was popular enough, and moved between a few different friend groups, some of them semi-cool (though one of the nerdier groups was my "home"). School's just that traumatic, I guess. I worry about that for my kids. Unlike an adult, if you're in an environment that's making your life hell (and normal school life is friggin' intolerable, from an adult perspective, without awful-yet-common levels of bullying or social bullshit happening), you don't have any real way to get out except to wait. Assholes can't be "fired". Hell, someone might commit battery and be back in the seat next to you before long, let alone lesser crimes. You can't really get transferred, with any certainty. You can't quit and go somewhere else, and anyway the environments are so screwed up you'd probably end up somewhere that's still bad, even if it's better. You can't even do much to avoid the jerks. The school work itself's a mess even in the best case, and wastes huge amounts of time—any bright kid's gonna notice and find it, at best, very annoying. You're not even being paid. Keeping the kids indoors all Winter while the sun's out (recess is nearly dead around here, even at the good schools, and they avoid going outside anyway if it's even a little shitty) is dooming tons of them to short-sightedness (insufficient bright sunlight during formative years, turns out that's the main thing that does it), SAD, and probably contributing to obesity. It sucks.
- jostylr 8y agoIf you have the option of a Sudbury school nearby, you may want to look into that for your kids. The students and staff run the school jointly and students get down to the business of living life instead of doing bs work. Students are part of an accepting and just community which gives them all a compassionate and tempered view towards others. The price is giving up the gold stars (academic metrics of success) and simply accepting that a child has an inherent drive to find a successful path in life if given the opportunity to pursue it in a supportive environment. The community as a whole is responsible for deciding on the rules and what to do when they are violated, including possible expulsion (student) / firing (staff) though, being a community, such things happen only as very last resorts. Everyone gets to tell their side of the story and the community decides as best it can with no one in a position of needing to do a knee-jerk response to cover themselves. Compassion and limits coexist.
- ianai 8y agoConversely, I was bullied relentlessly for years. It warped my perceptions so badly that for years into my adulthood I couldn’t exactly identify when it finally ceased. Public school has to be the worst way we could teach little humans how to behave to one another without just going lord of the flies. I’ll never fully move past it. That stuff is permanent to some extent.
- maxheadroom 8y ago>I’ll never fully move past it. That stuff is permanent to some extent. Likewise. I've never been to a reunion because fuck those guys (and gals).
- jrjarrett 8y ago> Likewise. I've never been to a reunion because fuck those guys (and gals). Oh, do go if you've been able to have any success at all in your professional career. The only way I ever got thru the years of bullying was to know I would go to college and get a good job and succeed. Going back and seeing how many of my tormentors never moved beyond high school, live in the same place, and look 10 years older than me is DELICIOUS.
- pnutjam 8y agoobligatory: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/final-exam-dram https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/final-exam-dram
- chaostheory 8y agoReminds me of this story https://expo.oregonlive.com/news/erry-2018/06/75f0f464cb3367/targeted_a_family_and_the_ques.html https://expo.oregonlive.com/news/erry-2018/06/75f0f464cb3367... (audio) http://snapjudgment.org/no-one-calls-me-shooter-0 http://snapjudgment.org/no-one-calls-me-shooter-0 It's basically an autistic kid who was falsely accused by an Oregon public HS of being a potential gunman. All of this based on a vague offhand comment by a random student. The school and police refused to provide details until a few years later. When the school released the details, they didn't bother to even interview the other kid who made the random comment before jumping to crazy conclusions.
- MrLeap 8y agoYour story reminds me of something that happened to me in high-school. I registered for a challenge english class. I lasted about two weeks because of a strange grading policy the teacher chose. If you didn't turn in ANY assignment, regardless how few points it was worth, your grade in the class would be set at a hard F. If you wanted to pass, you had to turn in assignments late. She'd give you a zero for the late assignment, but your grade would be allowed to calculate. I found this policy led to her doing ridiculous nonsense, like having extremely long essays be worth 3 points. and then a three question quiz worth 40 points. Her whole setup just struck me as bizarre and kafkaesque. So, I went to my guidance councilor and changed classes. Less than a week later she tells her remaining students that she had a dream that I was shooting students and teachers from a tree with a sniper rifle. Some friends I still had in the class relayed this to me and it rattled me a bit. I asked around to a few other teachers / administrators about it and got shrugs. Same same but different I guess. ..I have a lot of stories about teachers.
- Xelbair 8y agoI had only two horrible teachers to be honest, so i consider myself lucky. One was in both primary and middle high, the other was at my university. First one basically stripped me of my ability to count big numbers in my head - i could multiply and divide 4-5 digit numbers easily. She just didn't believe it and marked everything as failure unless I've written down everything step by step. Latter on she was my chemistry teacher - average grade for my class was just one mark above failure. When we got new teacher i could score top grades easily - not because she was more lenient at grading - but she actually could convey her knowledge. At university we had a numeric methods teacher who didn't grade the method, but the result. a single mistake in writing things down resulted in a failure of whole assignment. We never did any theory, just did everything by hand. Thankfully numeric method teacher at my masters was way way better - he was actually teaching us.
- rayiner 8y agoWhat drove me crazy about K-12 is that all the bullshit zero tolerance policies affected mainly the normal kids. The real problem kids didn’t care, and continued to wreak havoc. It’s the main reason I send my kids to private school, even though the public schools where I live are good.
- dev_dull 8y agoI really hated that. It’s a system that punished people who were trying to do the right thing.
- educationdata 8y agoDon't private schools also have zero tolerance policies?
- mipmap04 8y agoUsually they have the policies, but choose not to enforce them. The rule is there so they can expel or severely punish kids at their discretion, but typically don't want to because that represents lost revenue if the kid leaves.
- mrguyorama 8y agoThe biggest pressures on school administrators and teachers are parents through direct screaming and anger, not politics. If you want to have a good schooling environment, make sure to put a parent sized amount of support behind teachers that are good, even when they come to you and tell you little jimmy is being a right asshole and needs to be disciplined
- rayiner 8y agoStudents who engage in serious misconduct, or repeated disruptive conduct will be “counseled out.” But private schools are generally small, closed communities, which creates a high level of trust and allows routine misunderstandings and disputes to be resolved reasonably. Also, there are strong disincentives to “going nuclear” for both the school and the parents. The schools obviously stand to lose revenue, but the parents also stand to lose their monetary and social investment into the school.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CydeWeys 8y agoWow, we had quite similar upbringings. My dad was the co-president of the county's Gifted & Talented Association, and like you I was always in the best classes and magnet programs (even if that required busing), and when I had bad teachers, my dad got me swapped into the best teacher's class within a week. I even had a similar issue with a teacher, but fortunately that was later in high school and I was able to handle it by myself. This teacher, in fact: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/tasneemnashrulla/a-renowned-high-school-math-teacher-has-been-accused-of https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/tasneemnashrulla/a-reno... And yeah, having someone in your corner who knows how to navigate the school system and get the best for you is super important. I wouldn't be where I am today without his guidance, plus all the extra-curricular science and math activities/competitions he took me to on weekends or for summer camps.
- skookumchuck 8y ago> And yeah, having someone in your corner who knows how to navigate the school system and get the best for you is super important. This is very typical of the bureaucracies that run socialism. It becomes a system of bartering favors, connections, and influence. (Instead of money.)
- krageon 8y agoThis is a typical feature of any bureaucracy, which basically describes every large power to some degree (some of which are more bureaucratic and others are less).
- skookumchuck 8y agoIn a free market business, you can get special treatment, favors, etc., by offering more money. For example, if you want a better apartment, you pay more money for it. Under socialism, where supposedly everyone is treated equally and the apartments are supposedly equal, you get the better apartment using influence, trading favors, bartering, etc. For another example, when you need surgery, which surgeon do you get? Under capitalism, you pay more for the better surgeon. Under socialism, you get the better surgeon through influence, favors, barter, bribes, etc. The same goes for any service or product where nothing is exactly equal.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoHey, I don't want to be a dick here, but your heroic story is that your parents had the juice to get you into college math classes as a high schooler? How many kids don't have that going for them? Maybe the best lesson for them is learning how to deal with the machine. Not that it's right. But it's what they'll need to do.
- klodolph 8y agoI don’t get why you’re saying that my story is heroic. Could you explain? I was some kid who got lucky and had parents who could navigate the system, it never felt heroic to me.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoCheers, nothing against you - I was commenting more on the overall culture. I've taken every advantage I was offered as well (with varying degrees of success).
- skookumchuck 8y agoI took math classes at the local community college while in high school. All it took was signing up for them. No juice required.
- dllthomas 8y agoLikewise.
- faissaloo 8y agoMy school experience was horrible, there's a reason I left formal education as soon as I could, I'm pretty confident I've learnt significantly more since leaving school than I ever did in it.
- _hardwaregeek 8y agoWhat I found crazy about my school was the contrast between the pressure and the (lack of) power. We'd be given the workload of full time finance/medicine/law jobs, veritable Elon Musk workaholic situations, but no sort of power, no sort of control. Granted my school was better than most. The administration was fairly lenient and I can only think of one teacher whom I truly despised. But still, we were constantly at the mercy of teachers and security guards, gym teachers and assistant principals. We'd get hours and hours of homework and have to just smile and go with it.
- opan 8y ago> When I ran out of math classes to take at high school, I took them at college. It's interesting how this works. I remember I had an English teacher I really hated at one point in high school. It was pretty early in the year, so I went to my counselor in hopes of getting it sorted out in those first couple weeks. The teacher apparently found my reactions entertaining and kept singling me out to tease me or imply not taking the notes was the end of the world. My counselor said I couldn't just change teachers, but I immediately asked if I could switch to Honors English, and he changed his tune. I'm not sure if he was somehow oblivious to my angle or if he was just willing to help me out so long as we went by the rules. I'd been in Honors classes on and off before, and this got me a different (and much better, but that was maybe luck more than anything) English teacher. She was what I'd describe as a nice and calm old lady, rather than a feisty young teacher who starts fights with students for some reason. There was also less homework in the Honors class and the difficulty difference was negligible. It's amazing how within the same school things can go from so bad to so good. I have a lot of issues and regrets with my time in school, and I worry that if I ever have kids I'll have to put them through the same. I'm seriously considering homeschooling.
- pnutjam 8y agoI was an army brat who experienced several schools. I had problems and got into fights. The best school I ever went to was the DOD school in Panama. It had structure, the parents were forced to be involved. In the Army, you are responsible for the actions of your dependents, you are the one who sponsors them to live on base and their actions can show up on your military record. My kids seem to like school, I've consciously kept them in the same good school district. It's a bit too wealthy and not as diverse as I'd like, although there is a good bit of diversity. They key is to stay involved. Volunteer in the classroom when your kids are young and you have the chance. Make sure the other kids in you child's grade recognize you and their parents do as well. Don't let your kids get lost in the shuffle and work with people to create a community. //edit: I have 6 kids and my oldest is graduating next year, so I have experience.
- AnaniasAnanas 8y agoIt really feels to me as if a lot of teachers join the profession only because they are power-hungry and want some powerless kids to abuse, something like an authority complex. We had teachers at our school print low quality invitations to an event for the students and high quality ones for the teachers. We also had a kid that was expelled from school for insulting a teacher after the teacher insulted him much more heavily first. Every single person that I have talked to had at least four extremely crappy teachers while at school.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoI had probably 20 different teachers through the course of primary and secondary school. If I had 4 extremely crappy teachers in school, that would be 1 in 5. Anecdotally, more than 1 in 5 software engineers I've worked with are extremely crappy. At least 1 in 5 people in any job will be incompetent and inept.
- AnaniasAnanas 8y agoI am not talking about incompetent and inept teachers but straight up abusive. There were many more that were not abusive but were quite bad.