4 ms·
Legal action requires you to be able to prove they still hold the data. If they only use it for something where other factors affect the outcome (ad targeting,
by Nextgrid 8y ago
Legal action requires you to be able to prove they still hold the data.
If they only use it for something where other factors affect the outcome (ad targeting, etc) they can still keep your data forever while hiding behind plausible deniability the other factors provide them (from outside, there’s no way to prove that a particular ad was served to you because of your data instead of another factor they use as input for the algorithm).
- i_cant_speel 8y agoThere are a lot of mouths to keep shut on the inside. If anyone responsible for building the fake delete tool spoke out, Google would be in trouble.
- Nextgrid 8y agoIf people couldn’t be unethical at scale then Facebook wouldn’t exist at all and yet it does, so I’m sure the same would be possible at Google.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThat's different. People can easily be unethical at scale when incentives align. What they almost never can be is coordinated at scale against the individual incentives - whether for good or bad.
- kkarakk 8y agoAlso maintaining that deleted data is an issue, can't just magically move it to your datacenter in the mountains. someone will notice the movement of data even if it's automated. i suspect google just extracts as much data as possible from the photo, maybe trains an algo or two with the metadata and then deletes
- pgeorgi 8y ago> from outside, there’s no way to prove that a particular ad was served to you because of your data instead of another factor they use as input for the algorithm Create an account, use it to excessively look for tea pots until you predominantly get ads for tea pots. Store the cookie[0] that encodes your user id. Delete the account. After the advertised account retention period, try the cookie again in an otherwise squeaky clean session that gives random ads without the cookie: Tea pots? Something survived. No tea pots? No targetting. (and yes, the onus to demonstrate your accusation well enough to convince a DPA is on you, IMHO as it should be) [0] or whatever bits of data are necessary: try to recreate the tea-pot session after a logout without logging in officially to determine what's necessary.
- Larrikin 8y agoI don't believe for a second they keep the data at a company of Google's size. But they don't need to anymore if they just feed your data through some neural network training that outputs a black box filled with weights. They can legally show your data is gone but now their model knows that people with similar browsing history, location, etc have a weak signal for tea cups. You'll get the occasional ad for them if their other networks don't filter out all the history for appearing suspicious. Google can bring in a bunch of experts saying how much data they've processed and no one really knows how the ML algorithm learns, etc. They've improved their model none the less even if you delete your data after the fact.
- skinner_ 8y agoAnd that is fine by me. Using my behavioral data to train an underfitting model is very different from actually storing my behavioral data. Sure, the word 'underfitting' does the heavy lifting in my previous sentence. But I don't think that overfitting is even feasible at this scale. Google does not train models that just memorize the habits of 3 billion people. Such a model would be useless.
- Nextgrid 8y agoUnless your behavioural data is enough of an outlier to identify you.