4 ms·
Some random questions I always wonder: Do we really have reliable numbers as far as public debt in China AND what the central government has as far as money, a
by duxup 8y ago
Some random questions I always wonder:
Do we really have reliable numbers as far as public debt in China AND what the central government has as far as money, and what they could do about it?
Could China now be large enough that they could just ... cancel some debt and tell the world "That's right, we did it, you gonna just not do business in China?"
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoNo. The US can't do that. And the US is bigger than China. No one is so big that they can remit their debts and still get low interest loans. Of course China could raise their taxes to pay for their spending, or they could keep printing money and devalue their currency. But no one can not pay debt and keep getting low interest rate loans.
- dageshi 8y agoI think they can when the vast majority of the debt (nearly all of it) is locally owned and denominated in their own currency. What stops them simply saying "all this debt we owe to ourselves is cancelled"?
- DeonPenny 8y agoVast inflation, being label a currency manipulator, tariffs, and basically stealing most of chinas household income and giving it to corporate would leave a sour taste in their citizen's mouth causing unrest.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoThe same thing that stops the Federal Reserve from doing that. You can't get something from nothing. If the market has priced in that $30T is on reserve, and you just say, lol nvm -- you get incredibly fast inflation. The market reacts to that $30T not being priced in anymore.
- dageshi 8y agoWhich market? The only thing that's directly attackable by the market is the chinese cny peg/trading range and china controls the convertibility of the currency, they can perfectly legally stop their own citizens from taking money out of the country while protecting their peg with their USD reserves. Their bonds aren't in foreign hands, so there's nothing liquid to panic sell or short, there's nothing for the markets to directly apply pressure with. If the currency doesn't fall I don't see where this inflation comes from, cancelling debt essentially owed to a state owned bank just re-starts the credit cycle.
- imtringued 8y agoThe Fed, the ECB and Japans central bank managed to "lol nvm" trillions dollar, euro, etc into the economy without impacting inflation at all. If there was such an easy quick fix for inflation then those institutions would come knocking at your door and beg you to help them.
- Leary 8y agoThey can't cancel external debt. But they can restructure debt between State-Owned-Enterprises (SOEs) and state banks.
- simonh 8y agoThat's a default and plenty of countries have done it in the past, but at ruinous cost. For debts in domestic currency they can just print the money, at the cost of severe inflation. For foreign debts they basically have to pay ruinous interest rates on any future borrowing and face the possible freezing and appropriation of foreign assets. Bear in mind they need dollars to do things like buying oil and food.
- dageshi 8y agoI believe the huge majority of debt in china is held by the chinese themselves, very little is actually held by foreigners, so were they to cancel debt they could easily do so with little knock on contagion to international investors.
- MuffinFlavored 8y agoWhat effects would them cancelling their own debt that they hold have? Their currency should inflate because of that... right? But it won't?
- DeonPenny 8y agoNo they'd have to explain that more to it's people bcause they'd basically be taking most Chinese citizen money by printing more rmb. This would cause mass inflation, poorer consumer, social unrest because product prices would skyrocket overnight, and a lower standard of living.
- chasd00 8y agoThey don't have to explain anything to the people. Don't forget who the people of China are dealing with. If they get too far out of line tanks will literally roll down city streets.
- DeonPenny 8y agoThese aren't the same chinese they are dealing with. This generation has money and could easily leave. Those chinese now run the CCP