4 ms·
Little bit of a preface; I dislike bitcoin because of scaling reasons and reasons due to power consumption per transaction. So don’t assume I’m a supporter. Th
by dijit 8y ago
Little bit of a preface; I dislike bitcoin because of scaling reasons and reasons due to power consumption per transaction. So don’t assume I’m a supporter.
That said, how is this different from having physical cash in a bank, or a digital ledger that pushes money elsewhere and is only caught much later.
The answer is only that it’s an immature global system, there’s no (current) list of black market coins, which is entirely possible to create- meaning hacked bitcoins would not re-enter circulation and the value diminishes wildly.
The effect you’re seeing currently is due to an immature currency market which has never been held to the same standard as our fiat currency market. It also hasn’t been battle tested over hundreds of years. Of course it is deficient.
I’m not excusing them, I wish that people with little to no security chops would not be involved in financial matters, but a lot of these companies sprung up out of hobby projects many years ago and one could argue that the industry they’re in has changed around them. It’s not as big a deal if someone steals 4000 bitcoins if they’re worth 20c each.
- rabbitonrails 8y agoBlacklisting certain coins is a form of centralization.
- 7373737373 8y agoWhy? Everyone can decide freely which coins to accept. Regardless, by law, accepting these coins would already constitute possession of stolen goods, and would therefore be illegal. The "legal fungibility" is already zero.
- tty2300 8y agoBitcoins are not specific units. They are more like water, infinitely dividable. If you stole a bucket of water and then pour it in to your swimming pool and then distribute the content of your swimming pool to 100 different people, who has the bucket of stolen water?. Bitcoin also doesn't track the movement of specific coins because they don't exist. Its just a list of transactions. A wallet with $100 in it gets $5 in and then sends out $5. How do you decide if this was the $5 that went in? Is it first in first out?
- jstanley 8y ago> A wallet with $100 in it gets $5 in and then sends out $5. How do you decide if this was the $5 that went in? Is it first in first out? Even assuming you mean "address" rather than "wallet", you can decide by looking at which UTXO was consumed. This is a drawback of Bitcoin.
- jfk13 8y ago> Everyone can decide freely which coins to accept. If that were happening at any scale, the coins would be essentially worthless as a currency. They only make sense if there's some kind of agreement as to what is an acceptable/valid bitcoin. But then having a blacklist of "stolen coins" requires an authority that curates the list.
- 7373737373 8y agoOne disadvantage of the Bitcoin/Ethereum architectures is that one cannot give permission to receive a currency transaction first. A common strategy of hackers seems to be to distribute stolen digital currencies among many addresses of non-participating actors, therefore losing money, but obscuring their own identity. If a bank robber came to your door and offered you a share of money, you wouldn't take it either, especially if this transaction is public. Even though several billion dollars of cryptocurrency (compare with hundreds of billions of dollars) have already been stolen, my guess is that taking these coins out of circulation wouldn't affect the system much. If that doesn't happen, everyone participating in cryptocurrency might become more and more legally liable. "What color are your bits?": https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 "Treasury designates [...] digital currency addresses": https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm556 https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm556
- tty2300 8y agoWho controlls the blacklist? A black list is essentially a tool to drain anyone's wallet
- 7373737373 8y agoOn the contrary, it will increase the value of your assets due to less coins in circulation. Governments could easily mandate such blacklists to be used (in fact, assuming you are a US person, you are already barred from interacting with certain addresses, see the treasury link above), I think it's only a matter of time until this happens. And compared to the fiat currencies, such requirements are much easier to verify, at least in non-private digital currencies.
- akerl_ 8y agoThe difference is that I have physical cash in the bank and the bank is robbed, I don’t even have to really think about the financial impact of the news: even if the bills I deposited are stolen, I can walk in to another branch of the bank the same day and still access the funds. Bitcoin in its current form can’t have a useful “black market list”, because that list has to be generated somehow. Do you make a central authority in charge of list management? Or do you trust some fraction of the population to “vouch” that coins are bad? All the options would either open the door to immediate abuse or require a central authority that doesn’t exist. Regarding the immaturity of the projects: your comment isn’t really a response to the parent commenter. I agree that many bitcoin companies today started as hobbits projects. But why should we tolerate that they’re operating in an industry which can so easily lose millions of dollars for users, but operating with the security guarantees of hobbyists running a hobby webpage?
- CaptainZapp 8y agoThe difference is that I have physical cash in the bank and the bank is robbed This may seem pedantic, but no! You certainly don't have physical cash at your bank. Only a miniscule percentage of monetary reserves are in physical form and a bank is not obliged (as a matter of fact it would be rather counter productive) to store physical cash on customer deposits.
- lathiat 8y agoIt’s also not really true. At least in many countries bank balances up to some amount (eg $250,000 in Australia) are insured by the federal government. But outside of that many things could cause the bank to lose your money. And there wouldn’t be a recourse for it.
- Khol 8y agoI suspect you're confusing money and cash - they're two distinct things. I would be incredibly to learn that my bank had anywhere near the amount of cash stored compared to the amount of money deposited there. Cash has storage costs and pays a 0% return where deposits with a central bank have historically paid higher than that. (This isn't universally true.)
- zepolen 8y ago> I dislike bitcoin because of scaling reasons and reasons due to power consumption per transaction. So don’t assume I’m a supporter. So you'd be okay with a bitcoin that didn't have require power consumption and scales? Because they exist you know.
- DonHopkins 8y agoBut PHP can do anything, what about some ssh? https://web.archive.org/web/20100701145902/https://blog.magicaltux.net/2010/06/27/php-can-do-anything-what-about-some-ssh/ https://web.archive.org/web/20100701145902/https://blog.magi...
- andrewla 8y agoBlacklisting coins won't work unless all the miners refuse to consider transactions containing them forever. Bitcoin has sender based transactions. All I (the possessor of black market coins) needs to do is to send a small number of coins to a large number of addresses (exchange hot wallets, exchange cold wallets, random people's addresses) and now the taint is spread so wide that in order to enforce the blacklist you need a positive declaration from each of the destination addresses that they are not the thief.
- jacobush 8y agoConsidering how few miners there are (if you are counting pools) I could see that being enforced politically. (By that I mean with guns.)
- SkyBelow 8y ago>there’s no (current) list of black market coins, which is entirely possible to create- meaning hacked bitcoins would not re-enter circulation and the value diminishes wildly. How would that be possible? Isn't the value based off of wallets, so what you need are blacklisted wallets, and trading with a blacklisted wallet blacklists your own wallet. This would also mean all coin mixers are nearly guaranteed to become blacklisted. At such a point, people will just choose to do business with blacklisted wallets instead. We can already trace coin flows between wallets involved in far worse crimes than theft, yet the entire bitcoin community considers allowing them to operate as a cost of doing business. I don't see why millions of dollars worth of stolen coins would prompt a black list system when child abuse sites using bitcoins didn't prompt a black list system.
- nickpsecurity 8y ago"The effect you’re seeing currently is due to an immature currency market which has never been held to the same standard as our fiat currency market." I don't think immature is the right word even though you're right about other point. The regular system has a lot of regulations, security, and so on to reduce repeating and some big risks. The cryptocurrency community lacks most of that. The reason they do is philosophical: they believe their own decentralized protocols and individual activities are better than [de-]centralized, government-regulated, traditional activities. The hacks are a logical consequence of people with that false belief doing things that logically follow from it. And don't work. They'd have been better off making a multinational, public-benefit corps with charters and contracts having tons of protections built in.
- username223 8y agoI agree, but think it's even worse. The various exchanges are immature, fly-by-the-seat-of-the-pants tech companies sitting on mounds of other people's cash. That makes them tempting targets. Worse, they are trying to protect that cash from everyone on the internet. If you want to steal actual cash from a bank, you need to walk into it and threaten a teller, and you're probably going to jail. If someone hacks into BofA and drains a bunch of accounts, the losses will be covered by the bank or the FDIC. If a bunch of people put cash in one place, then trust an immature company with no insurance to keep it safe, this will happen again and again. It's like a data breach, except easier money.
- buttcoinslol 8y ago> That said, how is this different from having physical cash in a bank, or a digital ledger that pushes money elsewhere and is only caught much later. Bank deposits are insured by the FDIC, and ACH transactions are reversible. Bitcoin is neither insured by the federal government or reversible...