21 ms·
A request to drill for lithium near Death Valley
- jseliger 8y agoThis article isn't too far from The Onion, but it does point to some of the constraints and general drag faced by anyone doing anything in this country, or at least California.
- eesmith 8y agoIt reads nothing at all like The Onion, and the rest of your comment comes across as outright dismissive of pollution and ecological concerns.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tracker1 8y agoSorry, but environmental impact is really important to consider. Party of why I've been a bit bullish on Tesla and the Prius is the destruction for rare Earth metals and shipping everything all over the world is not insignificant. The problem is, as soon as you bring a bigger picture or talk about the economic offset to Green anything, you're labeled anti science. Politically I'm libertarian and conservative leaning centrist, I refer to myself as a pragmatic libertarian. I absolutely am in favor of some policy to protect the environment. Not to the point that some would extend things though. All the same, it's very concerning to me the amount of ewaste produced, badly disposed of and restrictions on end user maintenance and right and ability to repair. I'm also surprised how far the left has gone away from classic liberal values.
- SECProto 8y agoMassive carbon taxes would create a nice environmentally accurate way to account for externalities. If you need some taxes on lithium, cobalt, etc to account for same, I assure you $20/gallon gasoline would still ensure the electric car to come out on top. The difference is relatively minor externalities during manufacture of electric vehicles, and massive (difficult to conceive) externalities of use of fossil fuelled cars
- tracker1 8y agoIs building all the parts for a Tesla, including mining and shipping less environmental impact over 10 years than a gas car getting 35mpg at 10k miles per year considering the additional impact of battery replacements and proper disposal? How about against natural gas, even considering fracking vs lithium mining? Also, I never suggested using taxes for either.
- SECProto 8y agoThat's a difficult thing to calculate - taxes on the manufacture of different inputs makes that transparent to calculate. Shipping is almost inconsequential - I bought my $16000 Yaris and it was shipped from Japan to eastern Canada. If the carbon cost of the fuel to ship is included, manufacturers will self-select where to manufacture (or will charge appropriately to deliver) I fundamentally feel that disposal of lithium ion battery packs from cars should be viewed as a cheap source material, not a cost. Side note, if you drive 16000km/year... Maybe you don't need a Tesla? That's only 40-50km a day. Get something much cheaper with 100km range, and rent a car the half dozen times you need more. Edit: responding to your edits: carbon is carbon, does it matter if it comes from natural gas or a different source?
- tracker1 8y agoCarbon isn't the only factor damaging the environment.
- King-Aaron 8y agoI've seen the electric car lifecycle vs ICE car lifecycle trope get rolled out quite often, but neither parties (those for or against) can ever provide sufficient modelling on either side of the argument. I'd be interested to see a study done into it however, if ones been done. Mostly it seems to be based on perceptions rather than facts. It can be noted however that the components in an electric vehicle can be more readily recycled than parts in a traditional ICE vehicle.
- 8y ago
- dnautics 8y agoI think the basic premise that propertization schemes (e.g. nox or sox permit markets which are empirically successful or catch permit based fishery management) would keep environmental destruction in check is correct... but we also have an economy where governments stimulate consumption to get good metrics.
- Tade0 8y agodestruction for rare Earth metals and shipping everything all over the world is not insignificant. Actually, comparing to the lifetime emmisions of a regular vehicle it is. For example a container ship full of hybrids from Japan arriving in Europe or the US is responsible for emissions in the order of what a full tank of gas per each of those transported vehicles would create. Meanwhile your typical hybrid over its lifetime saves more than its weight in gasoline - thrice that in case of taxis. I blame Top Gear for over-dramatizing how much shipping and production matter. Most of the environmental impact always did and will come from the usage of a vehicle.
- billjings 8y agoWho knows how it will play out, but you can't blame these people for sticking up for this area. I visited Panamint Dunes earlier this year, and it is just astonishing. That critters and plants live there at all has got to be a fragile situation, because there is not much there. And they do.
- mrpopo 8y agoWe will not run out of Lithium (or any of the other rare metals powering the "green" revolution, the electric batteries, the electro-magnets, catalysts, cameras, IOT), we might simply destroy more of the environment mining it. When do we stop? For those who speak French, I recommend talks and books by Philippe Bihouix, in which he explains the environmental and societal challenges associated with our new thirst for rare earths and metals. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bx9S8gvNKkA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bx9S8gvNKkA
- SECProto 8y ago> When do we stop? Sometime after we stop mining fossil fuels, I hope.
- ElKrist 8y agoWhat do you mean by we will not run out of any rare metals powering the "green" revolution? Bihouix agrees that we may not run out of it in a geological sense. However he also argues that the extraction will become harder (lower concentrations to deal with) and is one of the fallacies of the "green" revolution
- thiago_fm 8y agoJust go watch a video about pre-salt oil in Brazil and how hard it is to extract it, almost an engineering miracle... and people still do it, as a good field might take some initial investment, but in the end might cost like $15 a barrel to extract with current technology, making it economically/environmentally viable. Even better than fracking. But as with any extracting work, there are downsides. People having been mining/drilling etc for centuries, I doubt people in hacker news can discuss all there is into those topics and the environmental impact. I think now we should look for better alternatives to the current way wreck with the environment, eletric cars are better than the ones moved by oil -- by a wide margin, even taking in account that you need to mine lithium. Just check the environmental implications of fracking, yet -- people still do it. There is always a way. What governments and police makers should care is to understand the environment implications and create a good legal framework and there is law enforcement, so companies do it correctly. We can either let this fear aside and believe humanity will need this step to perhaps takes other and find more efficient ways of creating energy. Or we can die in fear by keeping this dependency in oil, which btw, we will run out soon. Earth itself is a timebomb with 7bi people, with the current way we do things. We should be definitely pushing for changes and figure out what we could do in order to get rid of this problem. Also invest more into fusion energy. Develop new shit, basically. We have had much progress in history because people were bold and tried new things. If nowadays humanity is ruined by fear of doing things and press, earth is going to become nothing and humanity will collapse. Don't get triggered by this fear.
- gcc_programmer 8y agoIf we can't even use electric vehicles, what's left? Horses?
- scarejunba 8y agoMaybe we use electricity to scrub carbon from the atmosphere, create fossil fuels, and burn that again. Non-zero-emission and high energy cost but carbon neutral.
- kenneth 8y agoI've been thinking about this. Gasoline is a much better form of energy storage than lithium-ion. Perhaps if we mandated that gasoline (or a similar fuel) be synthesized from carbon extracted from the air instead of dug out of the ground, we'd be able to get, say, carbon-neutral flight with current technology.
- kabouseng 8y agoYou should read up on thermodynamic laws...
- rcxdude 8y agoThermodynamics is OK with this. It's not a way of producing the energy, just a means of storing transporting it which has some advantages over batteries (that said, energy in vs energy out efficiency is not one of them right now)
- greatpatton 8y agoWhich is really bad as ICE have a very poor yield... The efficiency of the global solution (transforming carbon to gas -> gas to mechanical energy) will be under 20%...
- jerf 8y ago
- newnewpdro 8y agoThere's nore lithium in the ocean than anywhere else, it just isn't concentrated. I wonder if there's an opportunity for a combined seawater desalinisation and lithium extraction plant, if they could have complementary processes.
- inflatableDodo 8y agohttps://www.samcotech.com/is-it-possible-to-extract-lithium-from-seawater/ https://www.samcotech.com/is-it-possible-to-extract-lithium-...
- newnewpdro 8y agoInteresting page, thanks for sharing. Relevant citation from the page: > This approach leverages desalination waste streams rather than virgin seawater. This is because seawater desalination plants typically leverage RO, which produces both a purified water stream and a reject stream consisting of a concentrated brine solution. Reject streams are typically discharged to the sea, however, it is possible to recover lithium and other materials from the RO reject brine. This is typically accomplished via a multistep process involving the sequential application of chemical reactants to adsorb, desorb, and crystallize the lithium (or other desired constituents) in the brine. The precipitated salt is then filtered and the brine discharged.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoMakes sense to reuse the concentrated brine; IIRC that stuff is causing a lot of problems due to a huge local spike in salt (and other stuff) content of the water.
- inflatableDodo 8y agoDoes this cause you any problems when it seeps down into R'lyeh?
- myself248 8y agoThank you! I've been pondering this idea for ages, and I'm glad to see it's being looked into.
- inflatableDodo 8y agoWas reading that the brine off the back of a seawater desalination plant can have a ppm of lithium high enough to chemically precipitate off the lithium.
- martin_a 8y agoA war? Are the Russians at the border of Death Valley? How many tanks do they have? Have shots already been fired? What do the presidents say? It's headlines like these which are the reason you can't or should not really give a fuck about news anymore. There's only exaggerations, hype and bloated stories left in news. I don't even want to read the article when it's using a headline like this.
- cocochanel 8y agoAgreed. Compare that to the following paragraph, > A request to drill for lithium near Death Valley National Park has alarmed environmentalists, who say mining the metal is unacceptable, even if it is an essential ingredient in the production of zero-emission electric vehicles.
- geomark 8y agoRussians? I think you have already been influenced by news more than you wish :p
- solveit 8y agoYeah, it's not like they were the predominant threat to the US for ~50 years. Not everyone on HN is in their twenties.
- 8y ago
- saiya-jin 8y agoI wholeheartedly recommend visiting Bolivia's Salar de Uyuni (and rest of the country like Yungas death road, Titicaca or Potosi mines) - it is estimated that it contains 50% to 70% of the world's known lithium reserves in brine underneath the solid crust. It is a nature's marvel, sitting 3600m high, becoming a 70km wide mirror during rains, having less than 1m altitude variations so satellites are calibrated on its surface. I sure hope for greener future but would shed a tear if this wonder would be destroyed in the process...
- neonate 8y agohttp://archive.is/x9RBv http://archive.is/x9RBv
- chr1 8y agoI would understand if this was about mining in a forest or near a city, but what is the value of a desert where nothing grows and no one lives? Would people be also opposed to building canals and converting the desert to agricultural land?
- nradov 8y agoHave you ever been to the Death Valley area? Despite the name there's actually a lot of life in that area including several threatened and endangered species. We probably do need to mine there for the greater good but with due care to minimize the environmental impact. Yes I absolutely would oppose converting the desert to agricultural land. We have more than enough existing agricultural land. No need to wreck the desert.
- mc32 8y agoOnly few areas of DVNP have any flora or fauna. Most areas are devoid of life. I have no idea what section of the park this mine would be in, so your concern might be deserved, but also could be overblown.
- kgwgk 8y agoAnd the park is huge, larger than Connecticut in the US or Kosovo in Europe. About one third of the size of Switzerland or one half of the size of Massachusetts.
- francisofascii 8y agoOnly 3% the size of California. And 5% the size of Nevada.
- kgwgk 8y ago“Only”
- eesmith 8y ago
- Simulacra 8y agoSomething more interesting is lithium recycling. There’s only a few firms that do this work. A lot of it is sent overseas to be recycled. If the US government where to declare lithium a strategic mineral, it would force that lithium to be recycled here in America there by hopefully increasing a recycling market.