6 ms·
I don't quite get what people expect... do they think that once google creates something, they are obligated to continue it indefinitely? That seems like an unr
by cortesoft 8y ago
I don't quite get what people expect... do they think that once google creates something, they are obligated to continue it indefinitely? That seems like an unreasonable expectation.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoI expect a "smart hub" to interoperate with a broad variety of devices. I expect existing banner features to not be revoked over petty turf wars. Google just made themselves irrelevant in yet another market.
- bunderbunder 8y agoNo company is, and expecting any company to continue spending money on maintaining a service even if they've decided it isn't profitable is pollyannaish. To that end, I'm not sure I see the value in framing this specifically as a Google thing. Google is maybe the most visible because of how many products it has, and how popular many of them are. But really, this sort of thing is a problem that's inherent to any IoT devices that rely on proprietary cloud services, in whole or in part.
- walterbell 8y agoThere's a difference between an IoT manufacturer going out of business, which causes related software services to terminate, and an IoT manufacturer failing to deliver on device claims made before the sale took place.
- bunderbunder 8y agoThere's also a difference between how we want things to work, and how they actually do. These services typically include some language in the EULA to the effect of, "We can disable parts of this device from our end, for any reason, at any time." And agreeing to those is almost certainly precondition for using the device. Which absolutely sucks. But it's the legal and consumer protection environment we live in right now. Pretending it isn't is -- hang the downvotes, I'm gonna double down on this -- pollyannaish. Until things change, your only real recourse as a consumer is to refuse to buy products that are sold under those sorts of terms. Which, unfortunately, does mean steering clear of IoT devices that rely on proprietary cloud services.
- walterbell 8y agoEULAs do not override national or state regulations on device fitness for purpose.
- cf498 8y agoI expect a company to continue a service for the foreseeable future (lets say the normal duration of the warranty on the product) if it is necessary to use a product i just bought. Otherwise I expect a refund or it feels very much like fraud to me. Legislators should get involved here sooner then later.
- Nullabillity 8y agoThere is a huge difference between the product naturally breaking a while after the warranty expires, and the product deliberately self-destructing as soon as it's no longer the manufacturer's problem.
- sixothree 8y agoMaybe they could develop an AI that predicts when Google services will get shut down so that users can make sounds decisions about how much to invest in them. Maybe it could even predict its own demise...
- hedora 8y agoThe thermostat I grew up with was retired (voluntarily—it still worked) when it was ~40 years old. If the thermostat manufacturer had somehow actively broken all the light switches, lamps, etc. in my parents’ house, even 40 years after the purchase of the thermostat, they would have been criminally liable. Safety-critical() physical infrastructure is different than internet services. Applying laws for one to the other makes no sense. () remember when all the Nests’ batteries died at the same time one winter?
- walterbell 8y agoSome countries have laws which require devices to be fit-for-purposes that were advertised prior to sale. If consumers purchased a product based on claims made by Google, and those claims are not true, will regulators get involved? US Federal Trade Commission, https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements/410531/831014deceptionstmt.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements... (1983) > The basic question is whether the act or practice is likely to affect the consumer's conduct or decision with regard to a product or service. If so, the practice is material ... because consumers are likely to have chosen differently but for the deception ... the Commission will find deception if there is a representation, omission or practice that is likely to mislead the consumer acting reasonably in the circumstances, to the consumer's detriment.
- _bxg1 8y agoMy girlfriend recently bought a sleep tracker device, from the store, new with shrink wrap, only to take it home and find out the service required to operate it had already shut down.
- DiabloD3 8y agoI've been seeing things like this in TJ Maxx lately. I don't know if anyone at TJ Maxx even understands that these are not items they can sell, as they don't work anymore. I think they think they're just fancy watches.
- mikeash 8y agoWe expect web services to go away eventually. We expect physical products to keep working until they physically break. The problem is when companies sell physical products with a web service as a fundamental part of the product. Companies want to treat the web service like any other web service, while their customers reasonably expect their physical product to act like any other physical product. Edit: I want to add that this is a really easy problem to solve. Support or create an open standard for the communication between the device and the server. Allow the device to be reconfigured to communicate with other servers. Then you can shut down your service and owners can keep on going. Better yet, make it so that our device can communicate on the LAN without needing a server at all. These problems exist not because they’re some inevitable fact of life, but because these companies see more value in not fixing them.
- Jedi72 8y ago> this is a really easy problem to solve. Support or create an open standard... We call it the tech industry but 90% of it is actually politics. Big money influences things the most but everyone basically looks out for their own interest, right down to programmers shilling their favourite language/framework. Thats what makes this a difficult problem.
- Joky 8y agoAre the physical devices not working after this change, or rather some of the applications developed for these devices need to switch to another API?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThere is no other API to switch to, as Google controls the protocol, no open standard exists to replicate the Nest API server, and Nest devices don’t support targeting a self hosted API. If you as a user or third party provider integrated with this API and rely on it for functionality, you have no alternative nor recourse.
- Joky 8y ago
- village-idiot 8y agoGoogle kills off products and services with wanton caprice and a complete disconnect from the needs of their users. While all services end, Google is liable to pull the rug out from under you at any moment. This is even more egregious if they kill off anything that physical devices use, as they basically just reaches out and broke a product you bought in good faith.
- thunderbong 8y agoIf I am the product, I demand it be there forever!
- wpietri 8y agoI think that many people naturally expect Google to work like a lot of other companies, which are focused on satisfying individual customers. Google, though, is unusual that most of their users are not Google customers. They are the product. So Google's relationship to most individuals is statistical, not personal. If they care about me as an individual, I have never seen the slightest sign of it. I also think that a lot of things at Google get started and killed not on the business merits, but due to shifting internal politics. Most of my Google friends have left, so I don't have recent examples, but from what I hear Google Plus is a fine example of something launched because a powerful executive got excited. As the political winds shifted, though, it got neglected, and then eventually killed. Another interesting example for me is Google Reader. I liked the product, but was never clear to me why they built it. They ignored it for a long time and then shot it in the head. Giving it away crushed the market for commercial RSS readers. Once they stopped, that market came back, proving that Google could have had a successful commercial product if they had bothered to run it like a real business. So no, I don't think we expect them to continue all things indefinitely. But I would love to see a more clear logic for what they will continue to support, because from my perspective it's erratic. I would be very unlikely to build a company that depended on Google; despite having used them for 20 years, I still don't think I can predict their business strategy. In contrast, I've been using Amazon for a similar period, and I have a pretty good idea of what they'll do. I'm not worried they'll EOL the AWS services I use, for example.
- doodliego 8y agoWhy should anyone let a Google self-driving car on the road? They will just end support for it whenever "internal politics shift." Let's ban Google from working on life-saving medical devices, because they will just get bored and stop supporting the software.
- blotter_paper 8y agoOn the other hand, EOLing an IoT pacemaker with short notice might bring some light to this issue.
- icebraining 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- glangdale 8y agoThe fact that there is a Google Graveyard does not imply that someone thought that every service that Google creates should last indefinitely. I view it more as a useful reminder of how frequently Google does this - a good idea if you're about to make something Google does part of your workflow or habits. There are also some products in there that were killed in a fashion that seemed capricious and difficult-to-explain in terms of popularity, usage and continued cost to Google - notably Reader and Code Search.
- Nullabillity 8y agoIf they choose to make it dependent on an external service then yes, I expect them to keep that service available indefinitely, for free. Consider it an incentive to avoid dependencies on external services.
- blotter_paper 8y agoAlternatively, given that you already know that they won't reliably keep those services available indefinitely, you could consider this incentive as a consumer.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoDo we want to let the low morals of companies hamper technological development? Perhaps there's a legislative solution. Although in the UK the Consumer Rights Act has no time-limit, so in theory of your thermostat stops working because the company decided to pull the plug then you can get refunded, at least.
- blotter_paper 8y agoIt's hard for me to buy into the idea that allowing a company to launch a product with a given feature hampers technological development. Requiring that a company runs an API forever if a product depends on it (and commit to refunds if that doesn't work out) seems like it would raise the barrier of entry to release such products, thus resulting in fewer products in this space (especially from smaller companies). That sounds like it would hamper technological development to me.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoThe product could be "a thermostat that works until 2021" though, then companies wouldn't be hamstrung with supporting old devices beyond the promises they'd made? Like giving a warranty, or making a parts/repair promise. I'd like to see something like a requirement to publish interoperability details, or code that runs on a major OS that operates as a server, to facilitate long term user-led support, too.