22 ms·
Tenants win right to physical keys over smart locks from landlords
- raverbashing 8y agoGood Having an internet connection up is less essential than, you know, being let into your home. Smart locks are "acceptable" (with caveats) as long as they have a physical key override. People forget how reliable old solutions are. Maybe they will remind after getting locked out a couple of times.
- isoprophlex 8y agoLet's not forget the time-proven insecurity of your average IoT device, coupled to generally terrible security practices in (any given organisation)... I'd rather deal with physical keys. Whoever is in control of your API keys is opaque for the tenants. If you think your physical keys are compromised you can just replace the cylinder.
- wilde 8y agoThe fun part is that being locked out isn’t a disincentive for the landlord who installed the lock.
- iicc 8y agoFirefox can block muted video from autoplaying: about:config media.autoplay.allow-muted false
- fxfan 8y ago"hacker" news. Thanks.
- deadbunny 8y agoNice. Thanks. Also for any Firefox Sync users, you can sync about:config preferences: 1. Open about:config 2. Right click > New (Bool) 3. Preference name = services.sync.prefs. + name of setting; true eg: services.sync.prefs.media.autoplay.allow-muted
- the_pwner224 8y agoAnother way is to use a user.js file, place it inside the FF profile folder (~/.mozilla/firefox/random-string.default) contents like this: user_pref("browser.download.folderList", 2); user_pref("browser.download.useDownloadDir", false); user_pref("browser.download.dir", "/tmp"); // ... You do have to manually copy it between computers, but putting all the prefs in here is easier IMO than dealing with a large number of services.sync.prefs.xxx in about:config. And you can place the user.js file in Dropbox/etc. and just make a symlink to it on your devices, so changes get synced automatically after the initial setup.
- ihuman 8y agoDoes that mess with websites using muted video as a gif replacement?
- mattigames 8y agoyes
- joncp 8y agoCNet lost their javascript privileges on my machine a long time ago. This extension is a godsend: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/disable-javascript/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/disable-javas...
- meower 8y agoYou might not even need it if you are already using uBlock Origin. It can disable JavaScript both per-site and globally.
- Y_Y 8y agoMost house locks are trivial to pick in about 30 seconds, and what I've seen of "smart" locks isn't much better. I think if you were really serious about preventing intruders (rather than discouraging opportunism) you need alarms and cameras and someone with a big stick.
- gmueckl 8y agoHow about having some actually solid walls and doors first instead of the cardboard-like materials of many US apartment buildings?
- Insanity 8y agoFamily recently bought a house in the US, and it is pretty. But it is mainly wood by the looks of it. I do wonder how well that works (for y'know, not being fire hazard and not being terribly insulated, being able to whither bad weather conditions, ..). I have not visited their new place yet so I can't comment on what it is like to live there. But houses in Europe just look more sturdy. That is one thing that makes me think investing in housing in the US is a bad choice. The houses just don't seem like they are build to last. (Again I am judging it just by the looks and I could be completely wrong about it!)
- gmueckl 8y agoWell, during the Seattle "Snowpocalypse" (that is, the few actually cold days in the area last winter), the heater (actually, the AC doubling as heating unit) in my apartment had to work overtime to make up for the bad insulation. The worst offender was the balcony door that was just a normal wooden door with no proper rubber seal around it and even pretty big open gap between it and the floor. The single pane windows probably didn't help, either. If this is average for the construction in the US, then there is a lot of room for improvement. You can absolutely build lasting wooden houses with adequate fire protection and good insulation. But it seems that there's not a lot of incentive to do so on that continent.
- 8y ago
- PunchTornado 8y agosmart locks are useful when you airbnb your apartment. otherwise I don't see the use for it.
- throwayEngineer 8y agoRunning? I don't like carrying keys
- Freak_NL 8y agoYou don't have a place to put a single key, but you do lug along a smartphone to unlock the door again? Just put the key wherever you put the smartphone. My running pants came with a special key pocket. Before that I just hung a spare key on an old shoelace around my neck.
- throwayEngineer 8y agoI just use a code.
- bloak 8y agoA proper programmable lock would let you set a temporary password. You could then leave the house wearing just some cheap clothes and get back into your house even if someone stole your clothes while you were swimming in the lake. Sounds good to me. No smartphone. No Internet. No surveillance. There would be a high-entropy emergency password in a sealed envelope hidden in your brother's house in case you ever locked yourself out. But I don't think the market will produce secure programmable locks at a reasonable price until some government regulator lays down a standard that manufacturers can follow.
- whttheuuu 8y agohmm... Carrying a smartphone vs carrying a smartphone and a key chain. I wonder which is preferable..
- cesarb 8y agoDon't you carry at least an ID card? Most keys are much smaller than an ID card, taking the key out of the keyring and putting it together with the ID card would only make the resulting package a bit thicker.
- mehrdadn 8y agoWhat happens to such a smart lock if it loses access to electric power (or internet access if it needs one)? Is there a key backup? Do you get locked out of your home if you don't have said backup key with you?
- ulucs 8y agoMy current apartment has a "smart lock" system for entry into the building. The system becomes unresponsive with no electricity, which means you're locked out. But you can kick open the door anyways, so at least that's an alternative to being locked out.
- lawlessone 8y agoJesus, what if that failed in a fire?
- ziari 8y agoNearly all smart locks can be mechanically unlocked from the inside (as required by fire safety regulations).
- more_pylons 8y agoIn the case of a fire tenents try to get out of the house and usually there is a normal manual turn lock on the inside of the door that works without electricity. For the fire fighters, I assume they break down the door anyways?
- iamatworknow 8y agoIn my apartment building all of the external access doors are held closed by electromagnetic "locks" that require a key fob to open, unless we lose power, in which case there's no battery backup and they're all unlocked.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoAdd "or the manufacturer decides to deactiveate the servers on which the locks are dependent and the email informing landlord winds up in the spam folder" to the mix.
- thrower123 8y agoI'm so glad to live in places where you don't have to lock doors
- leoh 8y agoWhere do you live?
- superkuh 8y agoMost places that aren't cities and even the suburbs when the cities are <20K pop.
- throwayEngineer 8y agoI just have security cameras. I don't even think about my safety or home when I have 5 cameras indoor and outdoor
- netcan 8y agoReminder that technology changes power balances, and raises the question of who controls it. It's easier (both physically and in terms of dispute) for whoever controls the smartlock (landlord, presumably) to "change locks," for example.
- adwww 8y agoWhen I was last renting (in the UK) I changed my locks the day I moved in, then swapped them back to the original cylinders when I left. I thought it was pretty good practice not to have a door with an unknown number of previous tennants, cleaners, letting agents, landlords etc with access.
- pjc50 8y agoGood idea - I did this when I bought my house but didn't bother on rental properties. "Euro Cylinder" locks are standardised and really easy to change.
- lqet 8y agoIs this legal? At least here in Germany, the apartment owner is allowed to enter your apartment using his key in emergency situations. [0] I can imagine that you can be held liable if, for example, a fire breaks out in your apartment, the apartment owner notices it, tries to enter your apartment to extinguish it, cannot enter because of changed lock, and the building burns down. [0] as others have mentioned below, this does not seem to be enforceable, even if it is part of the contract, and you are free to change locks after moving in. You only have to give the landlord access to the apartment in case of emergency, and he may enter forcefully if you don't do that (or if you are not present / have changed locks).
- Sendotsh 8y agoIn Australia you’re legally allowed to change the locks on your rental but you’re required to give a copy of the new keys to your Agent within x hours (my contract says 24hrs). We do it for all properties and highly recommend it, as we’ve had an ex-contractor (had worked on renovations) walk into our rental a week after we moved in, letting himself in with his keys thinking no one had moved in yet. Wifey was on the couch and let out a hell of a yell, and we chased him out before calling the Police.
- jfk13 8y agoIn my experience (UK), a typical rental agreement will require you to inform the landlord/agent and provide them with a key, or even get their prior consent to make the change. (I'm not sure if there's actual law on the subject or if it's purely down to the terms of the contract.)
- pjc50 8y agoThe comments seem to be missing the two key aspects: accessibility and surveillance. The smart lock requires you to have a charged, working smartphone that you can use in order to get into your own apartment. One of the claimants is 93 and lacks the manual dexterity to do that. On top of that, smart locks can report when you enter and exit your home to the landlord; and, if under the landlord control, can provide other people with a pseudo-legitimate access to it. I don't know what the tenancy law is in NY, but in the UK this is supposed to require the permission of the tenant except in an emergency. (Does anyone have the search expertise to find the actual case from NY public records?)
- est31 8y ago> charged, working smartphone Not just that, you also have to install a proprietary piece of software onto the phone from a third party and accept their TOS. > can provide other people with a pseudo-legitimate access to it I think in the news story the smart locks were only installed on the front door not on the doors to the homes. If the landlord installed them on the doors for the homes as well, that would be very troubling indeed.
- dictum 8y agoWhich then pings Facebook/Google/some other third party about your activity.
- OrgNet 8y ago> charged, working smartphone > Not just that, you also have to install a proprietary piece of software onto the phone from a third party and accept their TOS. Also, the lock has to be charged at all times... is that the landlord's responsibility?
- checkyoursudo 8y agoFail open, uhhhh A burglar's dream. Fail open and get your stuff jacked? Or fail closed and have to ingress/egress via the window (or worse)? I can imagine smart locks with no secondary opening mechanism being installed in my old dormitories at school. People already locked each other in with the penny jamming trick. Imagine if you could do that either by disrupting the power supply or setting up a cell/wifi jammer?
- danpalmer 8y agoThere are many issues with smart locks, but one thing I'm quite interested by are the entry policies you could set. As a renter, two things spring to mind: the ability to immediately remove previous tenants access to the home, and the ability to potentially enforce the legal notice period for the landlord entering the home (in the UK a landlord must provide 24 hours notice before entering).
- jakobegger 8y ago> the ability to immediately remove previous tenants access to the home This has a massive potential for abuse. Imagine if your landlord could just take away access to your appartment remotely whenever they want.
- handzbagz1 8y agoBut that would be managed by the letting agent who would have to impose access limits on themselves and people just aren't good at imposing limits that apply to themselves.
- sc11 8y ago> the ability to immediately remove previous tenants access to the home This doesn't really require a smart lock. In Germany it's common to replace the lock immediately once you rent a place and put the original lock back in when you move out. This prevents the landlord, previous tenants and whoever else might still have keys from entering without your permission.
- gmueckl 8y agoUnless the landlord does it, this is actually illegal as far as I know. The locks are property of the landlord and they have a right to enter the apartment under certain circumstances (previously announced visit, danger, ...).
- Faaak 8y agoNo it is not. The locks are the property of the landlord, but their usage is not. You can change the locks at the only condition that you put them back afterwards.
- syshum 8y ago>>>Lisa Gallaudet: characterizing the settlement as a win for the tenants is "misleading." two seconds later >>Lisa Gallaudet: when parties come to an agreement to resolve litigation, it's a win for both sides." So is this lawyer being misleading by calling it a win...
- glastra 8y agoAdd 'only' to the first sentence. Problem solved.
- noego 8y agoDoes anyone know if these tenants were covered by any rules preventing the landlord from not renewing their lease? If not, the landlord could always choose to not renew their lease the next year, install the smart locks, and then lease out the apartments to tenants who have explicitly acknowledged and approved of the smart locks. I wonder if the courts would still try to enforce a no-smart-locks policy in that case. If they did, it would set a major precedent against landlords being able to customize their own homes and renting it out only to tenants who are okay with it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CydeWeys 8y agoYes, rent stabilization/control requires that the leases be renewed. And yes, these kinds of smartphone locks are often used by landlords as a way to try to harass out their rent controlled tenants, who are less likely than younger market rate tenants to have or know how to use smartphones.
- baud147258 8y agoMy brother is working in the construction business on the other side of the Atlantic, he's started to sell flats which use smartcard + reader instead of physical keys.
- astura 8y agoHow does this work during a power outage?
- aphextim 8y agoIf it is at all a decent system most boards that control the door locks have battery backups for this situation. Our keyfob/door lock system at our small office works in this way where if you were to lose power the boards still operate on their own independent system via battery power up to 48 hours with no power. Even on a server controlled system the server client only issues updates to names/keyfobs on the control boards and even if the server computer were to go down any current information still works as intended with no power and the boards operating on battery (which most last 48 hours and the batteries are cheap to replace so unless it is an extended outage you are fine)
- aeharding 8y agoI see where the story is coming from. Devil's advocate: I think it would be really cool and great for security if the smart lock manufacturer could notify you if your landlord accessed you unit. I can see pros and cons for both sides, is all...
- Dubai786786 8y agoThis is also standard practice here in Brazil. https://topfreewebgames.com/showbox/ https://topfreewebgames.com/showbox/
- SEJeff 8y agoLeslie Carhart, a relatively well known infosec community person posted about this: https://tisiphone.net/2019/01/28/security-things-to-consider-when-your-apartment-goes-smart/ https://tisiphone.net/2019/01/28/security-things-to-consider... Turns out she was right... https://twitter.com/CharlesDardaman/status/1101626510333673474 https://twitter.com/CharlesDardaman/status/11016265103336734...
- friedegg 8y agoI've been following her adventure in this area. She kind of had to become an expert on it quickly when her own apartment decided they were switching to one of these systems, and there was no opt-out short of moving.
- SEJeff 8y agoSame. I've followed her awhile because she's amusing and generally quite sensible. She was absolutely right to be scared of these.
- sara7262 8y agoWho is Satan and why there is evil Best video about this with proofs https://youtu.be/AWNM1-xYI5E https://youtu.be/AWNM1-xYI5E Funny monkey using phone in video Don't think just you can use phone See how he is searching and watching own monkey videos on phone http://bit.ly/2DS4p2R http://bit.ly/2DS4p2R See what happened when a lion was trying to kill man http://bit.ly/2H2zsKc http://bit.ly/2H2zsKc
- hijinks 8y agoAs a landlord.. why would I want a smart lock? If there's one thing you learn as a landlord is if it can break, it will break. Why would you want a tenant calling you at 2am because the smart lock won't work.
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoI won't use electronics and certainly not a cellphone on the Jewish Sabbath. A "Smart Lock" that requires a cell phone is unfair for people who choose to opt-out of using technology for whatever reason.
- weliketocode 8y agoNote that this was just a settlement, not a 'won' case. As per me, I'll stand with the smart locks. They're better for everyone. For landlords: - change locks by adding/removing users & passcodes - tenant forgets their code in the middle of the night? Remind them of the code For tenants: - No more lost keys; just remember a simple number or use your phone Some of the anti-lock tech arguments here are just silly. Landlords aren't going to use an electronic lock to harass you anymore than they'll use a regular lock. They'll have access either way. But a landlord can use an electronic lock that's hard to open for the elderly, you say! That's NOTHING compared to having a heavy deadbolt that doesn't fit quite right and requires excess amounts of force.
- yrro 8y agoI wonder how likely a landlord would be to share the code upon receiving a suitable urgent-sounding text from an unknown number, containing only the property address and tenant's name (or perhaps not even that much...)
- weliketocode 8y agoJust as likely as an ordinary locksmith would be to help the same person out in the same situation I'm sure.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoSmart-locks are a non-option for observant Jews on the sabbath.
- orthoxerox 8y agoThou shalt not operate a smart lock on the day of the Lord?
- fernandotakai 8y agoafaik orthodox jews cannot operate anything electrical on sabbath (which leads hilarious stuff like sabbath elevators https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbat_elevator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbat_elevator).
- xamuel 8y agoFrom Philip K. Dick's "Ubik" (1969): The door refused to open. It said, “Five cents, please.” He searched his pockets. No more coins; nothing. “I’ll pay you tomorrow,” he told the door. Again he tried the knob. Again it remained locked tight. “What I pay you,” he informed it, “is in the nature of a gratuity; I don’t have to pay you.” “I think otherwise,” the door said. “Look in the purchase contract you signed when you bought this conapt.” In his desk drawer he found the contract; since signing it he had found it necessary to refer to the document many times. Sure enough; payment to his door for opening and shutting constituted a mandatory fee. Not a tip. “You discover I’m right,” the door said. It sounded smug. From the drawer beside the sink Joe Chip got a stainless steel knife; with it he began systematically to unscrew the bolt assembly of his apt’s money-gulping door. “I’ll sue you,” the door said as the first screw fell out. Joe Chip said, “I’ve never been sued by a door. But I guess I can live through it.”
- hakcermani 8y agowow! Thanks !
- costcopizza 8y agoFinely placed, what a book! This passage made me laugh out loud.
- rexpop 8y agoAbsurd, wasn't it, even ten years ago?
- jermaustin1 8y agoI should put this kind of tech on my office door. If I want to leave, I have to feed it a dollar. An amazing savings plan or just motivation to keep working instead of going to veg out on the couch.
- chrisco255 8y agoOr if someone wants to interrupt you, 25 cents for admission.
- PeterStuer 8y agoAlexa, open the front door. I'm afraid I can't do that Dave.
- unreal37 8y agoInteresting that the vast majority of comments here assume the facts of the case. Nobody read the article. It's wasn't the door to their apartments! It was a common door to the building. The case was not "won", it was settled, and there is no precedent set.
- tracer4201 8y agoI’m in Bellevue, WA. My building uses smart locks. Instead of a cell phone, you have a small fob, a little larger than a quarter that you hold against the lock on the door to unlock it. The door is always locked. On one hand, it’s nice the door is always locked and I don’t need to worry about it. More practically speaking, if you go out the door without the dog, you’re SOL. What I really dislike is they can easily track when my spouse and I leave or are at home.
- joncp 8y agoYou could set up a fob-mixer party with your neighbors. If everyone gets together and swaps fobs every once in a while it would make it really hard for the landlord to track any one person.
- randyrand 8y agoI went from that to a normal key. I much prefer the normal key. I don't ever forget to lock my door, and once or twice I accidentally locked myself out with the old system. Also, I can make copies of my key if I like which I couldn't with the old system.
- galkk 8y agoWTF is with this site. Even with adblock enabled, it played video advertisement to me, and then started narrating the story.
- Animats 8y agoWhat if you have a Next door lock and your Google account is terminated for a terms of service violation?
- ijustwanttovote 8y agoIt's pretty stupid that I have to pay $250 if I get locked out of my place, because only the landlord has the master key card.
- the_watcher 8y agoThe headline here is misleading - the tenants didn't win any rights, they reached a settlement with their landlord in which they got physical keys. "Tenants win rights" suggests there was a case with a ruling that would establish precedent, which isn't what happened here.
- _cs2017_ 8y agoThe smart lock had a keypad that could be used to open it with a code. And to clarify, it was a smart lock into the building, not into individual apartments. How is this possibly a privacy concern? Also, the tenants didn't win a right to anything; they settled the case without going to trial.
- threezero 8y agoIt’s a privacy concern because it can still track your comings and goings. And even the codes were personalized to each tenant, so they could be tracked.
- _cs2017_ 8y agoAh yeah if it's personalized, then I understand. That said, it seems just asking the landlord to make the codes the same for everyone would have been far simpler than going to court over this.
- drilldrive 8y agoI do not personally use a smartphone, so smart locks would disallow me from using the apartment. These locks may be unlawful as a result (I am not familiar with tenant rights in general).