9 ms·
> "See?! Unions are bad! Look at all the inconvenience they're causing our poor, hapless customers!" The corporate lobbiests are likely to then take that rhetor
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> "See?! Unions are bad! Look at all the inconvenience they're causing our poor, hapless customers!" The corporate lobbiests are likely to then take that rhetoric and push for regulations to prevent such groups of "contract" employees from being able to strike in the future.
They don't actually need any of that. All they have to do is to keep using basically the same pricing algorithm they already do.
If a bunch of drivers go on strike then any of the remaining ones automatically get paid more because the supply is lower (surge pricing). The higher pay attracts new drivers, or gets the ones who only drive during surge pricing to come out and work full shifts as long as the good money is there.
This is basically the same result for the company as conceding to the drivers' demands, except that it ends as soon as the striking drivers give up and reenter the labor pool.
The only way to get consistently higher wages is to maintain the higher fares and correspondingly the lower demand for drivers. In other words, some of the drivers have to stop working. Striking is just feigning solidarity as you hope it's somebody else who gets booted out of the job so you can earn more.
The only way drivers are going to get paid more is for enough of them to permanently stop accepting lower fares. But the trade off never actually goes away -- do you want higher fares or more hours? It can't be both unless some people stop driving, and if not enough other people quit the person who quits has to be you.
- shkkmo 8y ago> The only way to get consistently higher wages is to maintain the higher fares and correspondingly the lower demand for drivers. The drivers in NYC are striking for greater job security, not higher wages. The drivers not in NYC are striking for the guaranteed minimum wage that the drivers in NYC are guaranteed by law.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The drivers in NYC are striking for greater job security, not higher wages. And what happens when the company only has enough customers to provide that to 400 drivers when there are 500 drivers on strike? > The drivers not in NYC are striking for the guaranteed minimum wage that the drivers in NYC are guaranteed by law. Which they can already have by just not accepting fares lower than that.
- ameister14 8y ago>And what happens when the company only has enough customers to provide that to 400 drivers when there are 500 drivers on strike? They downsize or pass the cost to the consumer, just like always. Doesn't mean it's a bad thing to do.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoBut that's the whole point -- it means they need some people to stop working. If the workers are willing to make that trade off then they don't need the company's assent, they can just have the appropriate number of people quit. The lower supply guarantees more work for the remainder. The problem is everybody thinks they're going to be the one who gets "more work" and not the one who gets the axe.
- ameister14 8y agoYes, individuals aren't good at this. It's one of the reasons why collective bargaining works better than individual. That said, no, the company will not increase wages and add job security to the same extent with an external artificial decrease in driver supply. They'll do it in order to attract more workers and approach an equilibrium where wages and drivers meet, but if you artificially manipulate it without spelling these out it doesn't actually reach the same level.
- bhupy 8y agoWhy is passing on the cost of transportation to the consumer considered the optimum solution? Why not instead advocate for expanding the EITC so that the government fills in the gaps caused by lower wages? At the end of the day, we as a society (rightly) demand a minimum standard of living for everyone, and we collectively pay for that one way or the other. Either we pay taxes to fund a welfare state, or we pay inflated prices for goods and services to maintain wage floors. I'd argue that paying taxes for welfare is more progressive, as the burden falls on richer people. Paying inflated prices for goods and services is regressive as it's a burden that falls equally on the rich and the poor. What we're clearly seeing is a well functioning market driving down the cost of driver labor to the minimum possible price. This is good for consumers, since the good/service is now accessible to people lower on the socioeconomic ladder. If the problem is that some of these drivers aren't making enough to survive, then wouldn't a more optimum solution be to simply give them a little bit of money?
- falcolas 8y ago> The only way drivers are going to get paid more is for enough of them to permanently stop accepting lower fares. This makes the assumption that the payment, fare, and employment mechanisms are incapable of being changed to provide for greater pay and/or job security for Uber and Lyft employees (drivers, specifically).
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> This makes the assumption that the payment, fare, and employment mechanisms are incapable of being changed to provide for greater pay and/or job security for Uber and Lyft employees (drivers, specifically). What magic trick are you proposing that causes compensation to increase without increasing prices (and thereby lowering demand), when the company's margins are already low? The money has to come from somewhere.
- falcolas 8y agoFrankly, I'm not a transportation financial expert. The flip side of that is that taxi and black car companies have operated in this space without exploiting their workers for decades prior to Uber and Lyft. I take that to mean that there is a way to do it. Perhaps it will cost more, but if it raises the minimum lifestyle of my fellow humans (as opposed to lining investor's pockets), I'm personally OK with that.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe taxi companies did it by constraining supply, i.e. by not hiring as many people. So that solution is to give some people more by making the others unemployed. (And as dnautics points out, the people getting more weren't necessarily the drivers.) If that's all they want then all they need to do is round up some volunteers and have them quit. Obviously the problem then is that they wouldn't get many volunteers, but forcing people out of their jobs involuntarily is not really what anybody wants -- especially when it's them.
- dnautics 8y agoWhere do you get the idea that taxis weren't exploiting their workforce? Most taxi companies made money hand over fist by lending the medallions to the drivers and lending the vehicles to the drivers. They sidestep the issue of contractor vs employee by being a service provided to the driver; aka the driver is their customer, not employee.
- ameister14 8y ago>The only way to get consistently higher wages is to maintain the higher fares and correspondingly the lower demand for drivers. In other words, some of the drivers have to stop working. Striking is just feigning solidarity as you hope it's somebody else who gets booted out of the job so you can earn more. I don't agree. Start by grouping together as a collective, then lobby for employee status instead of contractor status. Striking isn't feigning solidarity just because there are scabs out there. It's acting in solidarity in the hopes that everyone will do it with you, so that you all can get better conditions.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y agoEmployee status won't do anything as long as Uber's margins are so low. Maybe if they had a monopoly and were just raking in cash, they could pay the higher costs out of that pile of money. But that's not what's happening. They're losing money hand over fist. There is no margin to absorb increased labor costs. So, they would have to pay a much lower wage to full employees. Benefits? Forget about it. Or they could charge a lot more, I guess. That would reduce demand for their services, meaning they wouldn't need as many employees. They lay off a bunch of people, and we wind up in exactly the same state as AnthonyMouse proposed -- fewer people driving.
- CharlesColeman 8y ago> Or they could charge a lot more, I guess. That would reduce demand for their services, meaning they wouldn't need as many employees. That's the solution they need to follow, though it's probably going to take some badly needed regulation to get there.
- icebraining 8y agoSo you're agreeing that they need to let workers go?
- CharlesColeman 8y agoIf the demand drops and that's the only way they can make it work, sure. Was I not clear?
- SilasX 8y agoAnother Uber strike thread, another commenter thinking it's profound to reiterate the logic behind why strikebreakers privately benefit from defecting. That's kinda the point of giving them such a bad name (scabs). Edit: Scab->strikebreaker
- SkyBelow 8y agoCalling them scabs is an attempt to dehumanize them. It is quite funny that the pro union individuals are so easily swayed into attacking their fellow workers which only give unions a worse image.