5 ms·
Would you be willing to share vague details of your roadmap? Specifically; How many barrels of ready to burn gasoline are you outputting per day in 6 months? 1
by mrguyorama 8y ago
Would you be willing to share vague details of your roadmap?
Specifically; How many barrels of ready to burn gasoline are you outputting per day in 6 months? 1 year? 3 years?
The fact that the general fuel is going to be sold and re-burned means this is at best carbon neutral, so from a cynical environmentalist point of view, what's the point? This can't help anyone unless you pump the synth-gas into the ground and sequester it, but that isn't VC-backed viable.
If you are using some sort of membrane to pull out distillates without heat, why wouldn't you just sell that to existing petro-chemical companies for their distillation processes? What non-thermal-energy related benefits come with this membrane?
The poster gave important information in another thread: 60kWh per gallon of gas, aiming for ~5 cents per kWh, ~$3.00 per gallon into distribution channels. That makes it instantly cheaper than petrol in, at minimum, the UK
- tofof 8y ago...the general fuel is going to be sold and re-burned means this is at best carbon neutral, so from a cynical environmentalist point of view, what's the point? This can't help anyone unless you pump the synth-gas into the ground and sequester it... The status quo today is that we are removing carbon from the ground and putting it into the air. This replaces those fuels that currently come out of the ground. It's still a big win, even if it's technically only carbon neutral. Even electric vehicles aren't carbon neutral, because they're mostly charged by coal power. Also: you suggest the synth-gas should be pumped into the ground. What would be the point of converting the carbon dioxide to alcohol to gasoline and spending electricity to do it? At a minimum you could just pump at the alcohol stage.
- solarkraft 8y agoAn EV makes several times the motion from the same energy input. > Even electric vehicles aren't carbon neutral, because they're mostly charged by coal power.Even electric vehicles aren't carbon neutral, because they're mostly charged by coal power. Is thus an invalid/irrelevant argument. I can get excited about jet fuel however, since battery powered planes are considerably less practical than their traditional counter parts with the current technology.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Robotbeat 8y agoThis is a completely accurate comment. Why is it downvoted? I assume the company is operating in the US. In the US only 27% of electricity is from coal and falling. https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.php?t=epmt_1_01 https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph... And in California (where nearly half of the US's electric vehicles reside--with EVs achieving a nearly 8% market share last year among light vehicles), it's MUCH less than that. There's only a single, tiny 63MW coal co-generation plant in the state, so coal power is less than 1% of California electricity. > Even electric vehicles aren't carbon neutral, because they're mostly charged by coal power. Additionally, it's absurd to compare two consumers of electricity, both of which are flexible with respect to time of consumption, and just arbitrarily say one is mostly coal power (which is false) and the other isn't. We definitely need carbon neutral or even carbon negative industrial processes. I kind of question the logic of going for fuels versus more valuable non-fuel feedstocks, however. A maybe 50% efficient conversion of electricity to alcohols with a typical 20% energy conversion of fuels to mechanical power gives you about an order of magnitude less efficiency than battery-electric. And if you ARE insistent on making carbon neutral fuels: Makes more sense to focus on things that are super hard to electrify, like long-haul aircraft and transoceanic shipping and maybe heating fuels for the far north (where air source heat pumps lose their effectiveness in January). But I'm glad an electrochemical process is being developed, here. Electrolysis and related processes are much preferable, IMHO, than the more common thermal processes.
- jonnycomputer 8y agoIf this process were to only make transoceanic shipping carbon neutral it would be well worth it.
- erobbins 8y agoExcept fuel oil used in shipping is like $1 per gallon or something similarly low.
- mrguyorama 8y ago>What would be the point of converting the carbon dioxide to alcohol to gasoline and spending electricity to do it? At a minimum you could just pump at the alcohol stage. Sounds like a great idea! My general point is that zero carbon energy sources like wind and solar are at least mildly zero sum, and creating brand new load on them would likely just result in capacity moving over to other producers like natural gas and coal. I guess I don't understand why YC is throwing money at this because I'm not confident there's profitability on the horizon, unless they nail down mind bogglingly large scale of production of aviation fuel, Meanwhile, if San Fran is looking to dump money on (IMO) nebulous and green projects, give me money and I'll plant 100k trees
- throwaway5752 8y agoNot sure how in the last 10 years after the last gas shock that people have forgotten the petroleum is a finite resource that we are going through rapidly. If you read E&P announcements and various P2/P3 reserve estimates of existing resources and measure those against daily global consumption it is pretty alarming. Presuming stable petroleum input prices may not be a reasonable assumption.
- rmcginnis 8y agoWe'll need a lot more wind and solar, so Prometheus will drive the expansion of these. We'll start out taking intermittent power that's low cost (wind at midnight, for example), but will soon have resources built for us to expand. This will be good for displacing other fossil fuel use (other than transportation), as we will be increasing the availability of renewable power, and also solving the problem of being able to use the excess (we can be seen as a kind of grid storage).
- mrguyorama 8y agoWouldn't you have to really be paying above market rates to "drive" the expansion of renewables? Any thoughts about essentially building/running your own renewable power facilities?
- 8y ago
- tlb 8y agoCalifornia electricity is only 1% coal. 52% is natural gas and 40% is carbon-free. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_California https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_California. Most growth is in renewables.
- mamon 8y agoThe world is bigger than just California, and I thought that SV startups target "world dominance" by default :)
- tlb 8y agoMost advanced economies are phasing out coal. Worldwide it's less than 30% of power generation. Also, fuel is fairly transportable. You can produce the fuel wherever renewable electricity is most available, and sell it worldwide. The economics are comparable to aluminum, where a large fraction of the world's supply is produced adjacent to geothermal power stations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Iceland#Aluminium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Iceland#Aluminium
- ericd 8y agoWell, every barrel of their stuff that is burned is one that wasn't sucked from the ground and put into the carbon cycle. So as long as it doesn't depress the price of gas much and cause consumption to increase, I'd take a bit of a less cynical view towards it.
- baddox 8y ago> The fact that the general fuel is going to be sold and re-burned means this is at best carbon neutral, so from a cynical environmentalist point of view, what's the point? It's meant to replace a carbon-emitting process (burning gasoline made from fossil fuels) with a carbon-neutral process. The replacement process is not carbon-neutral.
- rmcginnis 8y agoIf we replace fossil gasoline with renewable gasoline, that reduces CO2 emissions. Our gasoline will be zero carbon, and may actually be certified as slightly negative, as we will not be emitting CO2 from drilling and refining as fossil fuels do. If we replace all liquid fuels now made from oil with fuels made from air mining of CO2, it could reduce emissions by approx. 10 gigatons per year. That is huge. The membrane will definitely replace distillation in a number of industries, but the most exiting thing to do with it is to replace fossil transportation fuel with renewable fuel.
- mrguyorama 8y ago>If we replace fossil gasoline with renewable gasoline, that reduces CO2 emissions Nitpick: It will leave carbon emissions unchanged, but may reduce the amount added to the carbon cycle. What kind of production quantity are you looking at? Small batch aviation fuel for a niche "green" airline? Every semi truck on the road in America? The neighbor kid's go-kart? You give an "efficiency" of 60ish %, but I don't know how to interpret that. How many megajoules (or kilowatts) are required to produce a gallon of 86 rated gasoline?
- rmcginnis 8y agoWe are going for the whole gasoline, jet fuel, and diesel market. The 100% efficient energy content of gasoline is approx. 34 kWh/ gallon. At 60% efficiency in converting renewable electricity to chemical energy, that would be approx. 57 kWh/gal.
- njarboe 8y agoSeems like France would love to have this technology to replace imported fuels, and the political problems that go with them, with fully-local nuclear-powered hydrocarbon production.
- jacobush 8y agoPlease think twice about diesel - NOX is a killer. On the other hand, I expect particle emissions to be much lower with your fuel.
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoThe main thing that's turned me positive on "e-fuels" is that there's such a huge amount of petroleum that's used today in applications where we basically have no other options. Think stuff like big jets, or container ships. If you sit down and crunch the numbers for any non-carbon energy carrier, you either end up sinking the ship or with a fuel tank twice the size of the cargo.
- berbec 8y agoPlastics! Zero-carbon plastics would be great. Pull CO2 from the air, mix with water and wind/solar elec and product bags, phones etc!
- icebraining 8y agoThe thought is kind of horrifying, but you could even make it a closed process - send your old phone to the factory, where it's burned to produce the plastics for your new phone.
- mrguyorama 8y agoThat would open up a pretty good avenue for "recycling" then, and could possibly reduce waste plastic in the environment
- codethief 8y agoAs I learned today in another thread [1], the only problem would be that plastic is usually doped with additional elements that I assume we would somehow have to deal with when burning it. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19845427 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19845427
- stordoff 8y agoWhy is this horrifying? Is there some part of this I'm missing here?
- qmanjamz 8y ago> what's the point? This is an utterly asinine question. The point is that most current fuel is not carbon neutral so this is an improvement over the status quo.
- e3b0c 8y agoIt can be seen as an energy storage technology for renewables.
- mikorym 8y agoPersonally: Carbon negative aims are admirable, but idealistic. Carbon neutrality is in many cases much more feasible and makes a massive impact in an industry that is currently overwhelmingly carbon positive. By argument of historical trends to future trends replacing a carbon positive market with carbon neutrality at the end of the day is removing carbon from the air that would otherwise have ended up there.
- ncallaway 8y ago> is at best carbon neutral, so from a cynical environmentalist point of view, what's the point? This doesn't make sense to me? Wouldn't even the most cynical environmentalist agree that carbon neutral is much preferable to carbon positive?