6 ms·
While I think this is a good (maybe necessary) move for the drivers in the short term, I think it's inevitably going to be perverted by the PR departments from
by falcolas 8y ago
While I think this is a good (maybe necessary) move for the drivers in the short term, I think it's inevitably going to be perverted by the PR departments from the companies involved into a "See?! Unions are bad! Look at all the inconvenience they're causing our poor, hapless customers!" The corporate lobbiests are likely to then take that rhetoric and push for regulations to prevent such groups of "contract" employees from being able to strike in the future.
Of course, if the drivers feel exploited enough to form a union in the first place, who are we to say they're wrong? They already know going in that it's likely to be a black mark against them, yet they're doing it anyways. I personally don't live in or visit NY, and don't hire out Uber or Lyft vehicles; so all I really can do is wish them the best, and hope that it turns out in their favor.
- esotericn 8y ago> Look at all the inconvenience they're causing our poor, hapless customers Does anyone actually fall for this other than those who are paid to? I have no expectation that a low paid worker will exist at any time for me. As far as I'm concerned the fact the local supermarket, uber, takeaway, etc keep running is magic. It's thoroughly in the realm of a 'bonus', it's something I don't expect to be able to rely on (even if historically I've always been able to).
- TeMPOraL 8y agoYou are the exception. Normal people freak out and become helpless (often showing as anger) if some systems they assume to work suddenly stop. Everything from plumbing to supermarkets to taxis. And in my experience, there isn't enough space for nuance in the public consciousness for most people to not blame the actual service workers.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> "See?! Unions are bad! Look at all the inconvenience they're causing our poor, hapless customers!" The corporate lobbiests are likely to then take that rhetoric and push for regulations to prevent such groups of "contract" employees from being able to strike in the future. They don't actually need any of that. All they have to do is to keep using basically the same pricing algorithm they already do. If a bunch of drivers go on strike then any of the remaining ones automatically get paid more because the supply is lower (surge pricing). The higher pay attracts new drivers, or gets the ones who only drive during surge pricing to come out and work full shifts as long as the good money is there. This is basically the same result for the company as conceding to the drivers' demands, except that it ends as soon as the striking drivers give up and reenter the labor pool. The only way to get consistently higher wages is to maintain the higher fares and correspondingly the lower demand for drivers. In other words, some of the drivers have to stop working. Striking is just feigning solidarity as you hope it's somebody else who gets booted out of the job so you can earn more. The only way drivers are going to get paid more is for enough of them to permanently stop accepting lower fares. But the trade off never actually goes away -- do you want higher fares or more hours? It can't be both unless some people stop driving, and if not enough other people quit the person who quits has to be you.
- shkkmo 8y ago> The only way to get consistently higher wages is to maintain the higher fares and correspondingly the lower demand for drivers. The drivers in NYC are striking for greater job security, not higher wages. The drivers not in NYC are striking for the guaranteed minimum wage that the drivers in NYC are guaranteed by law.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The drivers in NYC are striking for greater job security, not higher wages. And what happens when the company only has enough customers to provide that to 400 drivers when there are 500 drivers on strike? > The drivers not in NYC are striking for the guaranteed minimum wage that the drivers in NYC are guaranteed by law. Which they can already have by just not accepting fares lower than that.
- ameister14 8y ago>And what happens when the company only has enough customers to provide that to 400 drivers when there are 500 drivers on strike? They downsize or pass the cost to the consumer, just like always. Doesn't mean it's a bad thing to do.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoBut that's the whole point -- it means they need some people to stop working. If the workers are willing to make that trade off then they don't need the company's assent, they can just have the appropriate number of people quit. The lower supply guarantees more work for the remainder. The problem is everybody thinks they're going to be the one who gets "more work" and not the one who gets the axe.
- ameister14 8y agoYes, individuals aren't good at this. It's one of the reasons why collective bargaining works better than individual. That said, no, the company will not increase wages and add job security to the same extent with an external artificial decrease in driver supply. They'll do it in order to attract more workers and approach an equilibrium where wages and drivers meet, but if you artificially manipulate it without spelling these out it doesn't actually reach the same level.
- randyrand 8y agoNone of that is necessary to know unions/monopolies are bad (for some definition of bad). Their impact is well understood. Economics textbooks usually have at least one chapter devoted to monopolies - which unions fall under. Whether monopolies are bad or not is somewhat subjective, but the impact of them is not. Most basically, monopolies lead to price increases.