2 ms·
It’s easy to say in retrospect that this specific issue was a big problem and we wish someone had come forwards. It’s a lot harder for someone without the benef
by SpicyLemonZest 8y ago
It’s easy to say in retrospect that this specific issue was a big problem and we wish someone had come forwards. It’s a lot harder for someone without the benefit of hindsight to notice that it’ll definitely need to disaster, and that it over all the other minor deviations from the rules needs to be whistleblown on. (Before the hack, how much attention would you have paid to someone whistleblowing that some of Experian’s software dependencies are out of date?)
- oldjokes 8y agoNo it's really not. Designing a system that changes the pitch of the plane automatically while relying on a single sensor that is known to fail at a high rate while working proactively to hide this system from pilots is beyond negligent. It's beyond incompetent. It's just malicious greed. There is no hindsight argument in this case. This is an incredibly simple and easy to understand system, even for a layperson. The few people I know who have worked in real mechanical engineering systems are having meltdowns over how bad the design was.
- SpicyLemonZest 8y agoThe short-term alternative which Boeing has settled on, and which most people in the media seem fine with, is "a system that changes the pitch of the plane automatically while relying on sensors that are known to fail at a high rate". I don't buy that the average person (or the average reporter) could identify without guidance that the first system is terrible but the second system is okay.