11 ms·
> Because private-equity firms appear frequently as villains in the press, many people assume that they cater mostly to the superrich, earning high returns on i
by paganel 8y ago
> Because private-equity firms appear frequently as villains in the press, many people assume that they cater mostly to the superrich, earning high returns on investments for billionaire clients. They do. But by far the most important piece of their business — 48 percent, according to the data-analytics firm Preqin — is investing capital for American pension funds.
This doesn't get mentioned often enough when talking about the "1-percenters" and the wealth gap in Western countries, i.e. that most of the capital behind all of the current economic and social system is directly or indirectly held by part of the general populace itself.
The issue is of course that the other part of the populace (generally speaking people under 35 who cannot put money towards their retirement funds or who can only get temp jobs) are not part of this financial arrangement and, as it so happens, are also some of the worst affected by the current economic set-up (those temp jobs I was mentioning are not as great as the normal full-time jobs held by people whose pension funds are managed by the companies investing in Cerberus).
Afaik almost no politician has focused on this social and economical contradiction, if I may call it this way, some of them are putting whole of the blame on the 1-percenters, some of them are choosing to ignore it all together, but almost no-one has actually looked at the real numbers. And the real numbers tell the story of a society divided in two, a part that will manage to enjoy its pension and the other part that has no clue how will pay for its old age.
- stvswn 8y agoI think your point ignores that there's a mandatory federal pension system w/ a minimum benefit that people who don't save in private pension plans or who may only have temp jobs do contribute to, and will draw from in old age. It's true that it's not fully funded, sure, but if it didn't exist it would be the obvious policy solution to the problem you're describing.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoI’ve been shocked to the extent politicians haven’t focused on the lost tax revenue from the gig economy. I’m certain it’s caused a drop in tax revenue from what would normally constitute middle class tax payers.
- dba7dba 8y agoPoliticians are not shocked by anything except when they lose in elections... Edit: In fact, what they say/act that they are shocked about is often a projection they put up to make sure they get reelected.
- shaki-dora 8y agoOh c’mon... This is just empty, nihilistic cynicism. It actually contributes to the problem, because people just stop trying when, completely independent of their actions, they are continually derided as stupid/corrupt/egotistic/lying/etc.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoWhat lost tax revenue do you mean? Self-employed/temp/gig workers still pay the same taxes as full time employees.
- honopu 8y agoNot necessarily. https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/self-employment-taxes/tax-reform-changes-for-self-employed-businesses/L4OoLLhqR https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/self-employment-taxes/t... See 20% deduction on self employment income.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoThat's a good point, and it may net out to be an advantage for a gig employee. But is is a complicated calculation. Throw in the higher payroll tax rate for gig employees, and tax deductible healthcare expenditures by companies on employees and it is unclear there is any advantage in overall taxes paid.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoGig independent contractors pay the same payroll tax as employee/employer pairs.
- aksss 8y agoHaving been gainfully employed in corporate IT since I was 19 - and doing max contribution to my 401k every year since - I'm not "in touch" with the predicament of today's kids. Are they alright? Record employment numbers today. Wage growth up. We still have a talent shortage. Being (now) a business owner, my biggest complaint on the talent front isn't a lack of education in candidates, it's a lack of customer focus and inner curiosity (to be aggressively learning in one's spare time and on the job).
- ip26 8y agoRight, you maxed your 401k, your IRA, your HSA, and all it took was a little financial prudence, diligence, and a job paying 60k or more straight out of high school. Anybody could do it.
- systemkei 8y ago>employed in corporate IT since I was 19 unlikely you'll ever collect from that 401k friend!
- WillPostForFood 8y agoIt is a huge disservice to take a cheap shot at 401ks. There is almost no case where someone who has the opportunity to contribute shouldn't do so.
- dractori 8y agoThe top 1% own 40% of the wealth and have realized 95% of the increase in wealth over the past decade: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_Unite... "More recently, in 2017, an Oxfam study found that eight rich people, six of them Americans, own as much combined wealth as half the human race."
- ahupp 8y agoBoth of these things can be true: that the top 1% own a large fraction of wealth, and that an even larger fraction is owned by the pensions and retirement plans of the non-wealthy. Wealth comparisons are tricky, e.g they'll show that Americans are some of the poorest people in the world because there's a large fraction with debt (e.g homes, credit cards, student loans). While technically true, that doesn't really match our intuitions for what wealth means.
- UweSchmidt 8y agoWell then our intuition is wrong. If your finances throughout your life are not in order, if you have high debt, regardless if it's because of medical bills, student loans or too big a car and house, you are in a weak position. What good does a nice car do if you worry about bills and if you try to avoid to look at the balance in your banking app? You don't always know how rich some folks are, but for the most part it's easy to see if someone is living above their means, if you get a little anxienty on those people's behalf, then good!
- bluGill 8y agoIf you die deep in dept you managed to cheat at life: your cost of living was higher than input. If you die rich you got cheated: you put more effort into life than you got out of it.
- zentiggr 8y agoAnd there is the failure of so much modern thinking, laid out in black and white: your financial picture is your measure of success. God I hate greed and the profit motive more than anything else in this whole wacky place. I would love to die in average suburban comfort if it meant the billions I'd made had all gone to deserving causes and not to any flagrant lifestyle of my own.
- WorldMaker 8y ago> This doesn't get mentioned often enough when talking about the "1-percenters" and the wealth gap in Western countries, i.e. that most of the capital behind all of the current economic and social system is directly or indirectly held by part of the general populace itself. I think the keyword there is indirectly. It's still easy to blame the 1-percenters for the proportional lion's share of the blame when the majority of the general populace's influence/control over their investments is intentionally gatekeeped and/or obfuscated by "professional finance" people, many of whom are 1-percenters or wish-they-were. In the case of legitimate pensions that is top-to-bottom controlled by finance people with almost zero control from the average pension. In the case of the modern faux-pension, the 401k, while most individuals could take direct control of how they invest those funds, and that's supposedly a feature, very few actually do/will, because the game is rigged (401k providers have a lot of vested interests in promoting their investment products where they make the most fees) and also a full time job that the 401k "owner" doesn't need on top of their existing job that pays into the 401k in the first place (again, giving the 401k providers the benefit of defaulting people their investment products with the most fees). Even further, the push to "personal responsibility" to the individual in a 401k system also removes a lot of power of the general populace to collectively bargain as investment holders. Under the regime of traditional pension systems a lot of hedge funds were checked by pension managers when employee/pensioner interest was kept in mind (especially in the cases where pensions were managed by Unions rather than employers or outsourced to professional finance firms; there's a good history of hedge funds versus Unions on the books some of which used to stop leverage buyouts). > And the real numbers tell the story of a society divided in two, a part that will manage to enjoy its pension and the other part that has no clue how will pay for its old age. Even when federally mandated pensions existed there was always an interesting line between pension-earning work and the rest. It's not an entirely new worry, it's just continuing to get a lot worse. Even worse is how much the breakdown of the earned pension system to the "privatized" 401k system is creating a weird muddy ground in between the extremes of people that sort of have retirement investments, but no longer have collective bargaining power, often have more middlemen eating their share of the pie, and everything is much more of a gamble.
- sokoloff 8y ago> the 401k...is also a full time job that the 401k "owner" doesn't need on top of their existing job that pays into the 401k in the first place Really? I can't imagine how to spend 20 hours per year on 401(k) related topics, let alone 40 hours per week on it. If you're under 40, buy a broad-based stock fund and forget about it. (Probably true if you're under 50.) Use the 40K hours you save by not having this extra "full time job" however you like.
- UweSchmidt 8y agoSo those pensions - representing a large chunk of everyone's lifetime earnings - are in the same order of magnitude as what the "1%" invest? That's pretty much how the "1-percenters" are defined: "this tiny number of people own as much as everyone else combined". If these pensions are used to create harm to the general populace, how does this not aggravate the whole situation? Do you really think politicians have not focussed on the insane economic and social developments because they somehow failed to obtain those "real numbers"? Oops, we had no idea that people are crushed by student loans and lack of retirement arrangements?
- Swizec 8y ago> a part that will manage to enjoy its pension and the other part that has no clue how will pay for its old age. Quoth Bladerunner: Every civilization was built off the back of a disposable workforce
- zemptime 8y agow/r/t "almost no politician has focused on this contradiction," I've heard Andrew Yang talk about it tangentially through the (probably a/b tested) talking point of "job loss to automation." Then when I looked more, I realized, he _wrote explicit policy on his website_. :O https://www.yang2020.com/what-is-ubi/ https://www.yang2020.com/what-is-ubi/ , hop into the question that's: > Why does Andrew Yang want to implement Universal Basic Income (UBI) in America? This might be a stretch. It's where my mind went, and I think it's interesting, so I hope this comment is in good taste!
- fjsolwmv 8y agoYou have to squint pretty hard to call Andrew Yang a politician and not a person on a vanity/activism project.
- rhizome 8y ago>most of the capital behind all of the current economic and social system is directly or indirectly held by part of the general populace itself. As the system is designed, it doesn't matter so much who's money it is, it's who controls it and collects fees from steering it.