6 ms·
It's clever, but it doesn't solve the problem. Because the problem isn't with strong preferences -- it's with extreme preferences. If there were 7 versions of
by crazygringo 8y ago
It's clever, but it doesn't solve the problem.
Because the problem isn't with strong preferences -- it's with extreme preferences.
If there were 7 versions of a bill (A,B,C,D,E,F,G) ranging from ultra-conservative (a "A") to ultra-liberal (a "G"), in a polarized community people could still be spending the minimum 1 point each on the A's or G's and none on B-F.
The problem with politics today isn't that people are single-issue voters (because they generally aren't -- it's not a problem that needs to be solved)... it's that the natural evolution of the two-party system has forced us into choices that are more polarized than ever before in the history of the US -- in a two-party election, we're often only given options A and G, or maybe B and F, but rarely C through E.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoAdditionally, it's got almost nothing to do with ideas anymore. It's about tribes. If you're in tribe A, your media tells you tribe B are literally devils. There's no understanding a devil, or compromise with one. If they say something that sounds reasonable? It's probably a trick. Hannity or Maddow will explain why tonight.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>Hannity or Maddow will explain why tonight... There is something very sad, yet true, about that statement.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoDownvoted pretty heavily, though. Guess it's a threatening message :)
- youdontknowtho 8y agoThere are literally millions of single issue voters who vote for conservatives because of abortion in the US. Literally millions of people.
- asark 8y agoYeah, NPR found plenty on their part of the national media's "how the hell did this happen?" tour right after the election. Lots of "well yeah he's awful and I wasn't happy to vote for him. But... court nominations and Roe v. Wade, so I kinda had to."
- jimhefferon 8y ago> the natural evolution of the two-party system The US has a long history, almost all of it with a two-party system. Only sometimes is there extremity. To my mind, 1860 is even more extreme than today. (My opinion is that an important common thread between then and today is a class of people with a great deal of money who are deliberately driving the political atmosphere. But in any event a claim that it is a natural outcome of a two-party system needs to account for the historical fact that the US experience is typically not extreme.)
- hannasanarion 8y ago1860 was also the first year of a brand new two-party system. The previous decade was unilateral Democrat rule while the Whigs died and Constitutionalists, Know-Nothings, and Republicans fought over the scraps. It was an unusual time.
- bilbo0s 8y agoYep. 1860 is more accurately characterized as the first year of the two party system. And the people only wanted another party because of the slavery issue. Literally, the only time we dealt with extremists, was when we first started the two party system. So it's disingenuous to say that 1860 was like today. It wasn't. At all. There is no new, powerful, upstart party that people can vote for to get away from the extremists today. There is no overriding issue that people can legitimately claim to be at once barbaric and deleterious to the republic. There is none of that. We just have two parties... who choose to be extreme for dubious reasons. So it hasn't been as polarized as it is today, ever really during the two party era. Today is way outside the norm. We haven't seen anything like this before. Of course, we've never had anything like our current leaders either. But that's a whole other issue. (A related issue though.)
- crazygringo 8y agoSlavery was a particularly and uniquely intractable problem where a "moderate" or "centrist" solution was particularly unappealing. There's extensive literature on what's been driving polarization, but it really is a new "era" for it and not a cyclical thing. Factors include: - More democratic/open primaries, which select extreme candidates - More statistically targeted media (including social media) to take advantage of extreme views (including social media) - Increasingly partisan news media made possible by more fragmented media (first cable, then the Internet) None of these show any signs of going away, and all three are phenomena that are fundamentally new in the past few decades.
- kitsy 8y agoI disagree. Many bills are written with compromises in place, so they appeal to enough voters. I would rank the American ACA bill as E on the A to G scale.
- onychomys 8y agoEven if that was true of the bill itself, it's certainly not true of how it was (and is) portrayed in the media. On the right wing channels, you hear that it's a G, or maybe a letter even further down the alphabet. On the left wing channels, you hear that it was so watered down that it was basically a B and that we have to do more etc etc etc.
- howard941 8y agoIt's striking even at this late a date to find the AEI proposal with mods crafted (or with pay offs as it was billed at the time) to appeal to the far right of the Democratic party rated as being practically at the edge of the far left.
- roenxi 8y agoThis is an interesting debating point in itself. The problem isn't extreme preferences - the extremist wing of any political party tends to be motivated, visible and small. The problem is that the extreme wing wields a lot of power through their persistent and single minded effort. Quadratic voting weights power away from my-way-or-highway voters towards voters who are willing to consider more than one option. Without thinking too deeply, it would make it easy to tease apart large and awkward alliances. Even if it didn't formally fracture the major parties, it would de-facto moderate politics by increasing the risk of holding extreme positions. Basically any other form of voting is an improvement over the US FPTP system; FPTP's only advantage is that it is very obvious how it works. Nothing to sneeze at, but not mathematically satisfying.
- erentz 8y ago> The problem with politics today isn't that people are single-issue voters... The problem is the people have no representation, what people want does not impact the likelihood of passage of a law.[1] People on the left in right have a lot more in common with each other than everyone likes to make out. But even where they agree still nothing happens. I think this “polarization” line is a convenient distraction from this reality. [1] https://bulletin.represent.us/american-government-isnt-democracy/ https://bulletin.represent.us/american-government-isnt-democ...
- morley 8y agoI think you're pointing out a different shade of the same problem. People _do_ technically have representation in the form of their Congresspeople and Senators. But those elected officials have to polarize their viewpoints and thus their votes because when they vote out of party, the vocal members of their parties excoriate them as traitors. So the people in the middle feel like their representatives aren't representing them.
- coldtea 8y ago>People _do_ technically have representation in the form of their Congresspeople and Senators. Do those people really care and work for their voters? Or for their own career (including post-political career at some company they've done favors), lobbies, party, etc?
- steve76 8y agoGetting elected, that's their job. They are either campaigning or raising money. I think the biggest problem with this is it would be used selectively and always move to one direction, and nothing will be mutual. Someone's going to choose what elections are used with tokens, and it will only go into that direction. Don't use politics, or the law. It's there to cap the violence. Stay away, do things on your own. When you go to these big places, DC, Wall St., Silicon Valley, it really is other people taking over.
- kazagistar 8y ago
- larrydag 8y agoI agree. For this "tribal" reason of picking a party I've been more inclined to have term limits on Congress.
- hannasanarion 8y agoTerm limits in congress aren't really a good thing though. We have term limits for President because the President is uniquely powerful, they can almost unilaterally bend the aparatus of government to their will. If allowed to rule for too long, a president can easily become a dictator. The same is not true of a congressperson who weilds 1/535th of the power of a branch. Besides, if the people want to put someone in office, shouldn't they be allowed to? Isn't that Democracy 101?
- cjslep 8y agoCareer congresspersons are beholden to those that secure their reelection. That's the current steady state system we have now. Term limits forces that dynamic to no longer apply to the final term, which frees congresspeople from this dynamic for at least one term. It also forces clearer the revolving door between the private sector and politics as then the no-longer congressperson gets hired into a company.
- hannasanarion 8y ago>Career congresspersons are beholden to those that secure their reelection Yeah, those people are called "voters". That's how it's supposed to work. We want congresspeople to feel beholden to them. > It also forces clearer the revolving door between the private sector and politics as then the no-longer congressperson gets hired into a company. Isn't this just motivation for more cronyism? You're basically arguing that the last term of any congressperson should be spent working for a company instead of the people.
- cjslep 8y ago> Yeah, those people are called "voters". That's how it's supposed to work. We want congresspeople to feel beholden to them. No it's not. It's to the people with money which let's them get to the voters. Because otherwise that money is going to an alternate candidate that plays ball. Have you ever wondered where the blue-collar Democrats of the 1970's went, for example? Businesses and those with money instead financing better campaigns in return for business representation, won. It's why both Democrats and Republicans have generally represented corporate interests since Reagan. > Isn't this just motivation for more cronyism? No, it's motivation for making the existing cronyism even more transparent. Or, incentivizing those who did their terms to return to the communities they helped represent and move on with their non-political life.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoEspecially since the Federal level of government has increased in both power and attention over last century where winner takes all. If States regained the political and power emphasis, more politics would be local and generally conducted among people with more similar views....and if you dont like it, chances are that another State caters to your viewpoint.
- overthemoon 8y agoPolarization isn't in itself a problem unless you believe the truth is somewhere near the center, which is itself an ideological position. On top of that, our choices have always been the options from C to E. Sanders is the farthest left serious candidate for president we've had in decades, and he's not very far left relative to many center-left European parties. Trump has farther right tendencies but policy-wise he's more or less in lock step with the center of the GOP. I would love to hear an explanation for why I'm wrong. We've rarely had a president or even candidates on either extreme.
- throwayEngineer 8y agoI don't see the truth in the center. The federal government has been corrupt my entire life. I don't see any reason to give them additional money or power. If anything, I find national liberals wrong, and state liberals more correct. I wouldn't mind paying for things my area uses, I have some oversight. Nationally trillions of dollars gets lost.
- overthemoon 8y agoSure, I guess my point is just this--it's tempting to see oneself above the ideological fray, when solutions like this come from priors just like any others. This technocratic third way approach tries to bury its political identity in the appearance of objectivity. I'm not even necessarily criticizing its content, though I happen to disagree, I'm just saying that when trying to come up with a balanced system, this approach necessarily favors the center, which, like I said, is an ideological position.
- Allower 8y agoits not a two party problem, its a problem of intelligence, literally the american congress (and most of the uneleceted public servants) are literally ignoramuses who are incapable of thinking about more than 2 options.
- weberc2 8y ago> it's that the natural evolution of the two-party system has forced us into choices that are more polarized than ever before in the history of the US I don't think this is supported by the evidence. Polarization in the US hasn't been unidirectional (there are many long periods during which the US became less polarized) and the recent massive spike is, well, a recent spike--it's not a natural evolution at all. Something happened in the last twenty years or so that increased our polarization. I recall several good sources, but I'll have to dig around for them...
- mschuster91 8y ago> Something happened in the last twenty years or so that increased our polarization. I'd expand the timeframe to 30 years and say the biggest contributors to this are the rise of neoliberal politics combined with globalization leaving a lot of working class people "behind" while corporations made ever more and more profits, combined with the rise of the Internet where the most outrageous content gets the most clicks/likes/eyeball-time with next to no institutions to provide as "quality filter". Stuff like antivaxxers, flat earthers, "great exchange of the white people" and other conspiracy bollocks was relegated to physical mailings of fringe groups naturally limiting its distribution, nowadays the reach capability is in the millions for everyone. In addition, countless fuck-ups (aided by propaganda) demolished trust into journalism and experts in general, which led to the erosion of fact-based viewpoints as the base for democratic discourse.
- weberc2 8y ago> great exchange of the white people What is this referring to?
- magnusmundus 8y agoThe actual term is "great replacement", and it's a conspiracy theory regarding an alleged systematic replacement of native Europeans (i.e. "whites"). The Christchurch shooter was a big fan, apparently.
- 8y ago
- chrislloyd 8y agoFrom https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2755844 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2755844 > g Likert has never done; engages a higher level of thoughtfulness; attenuates extremism to expose deeper insight; and predicts behavior better than Likert at high levels preference intensity. Basically extreme views and polarization are poorly weighted in large populations and this can be _exposed_ by QV.
- ptah 8y agoi agree. i sometimes think that a two party system is worse than one party as it is ultimately a waste of resources for very little difference
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jackpirate 8y agoin a two-party election, we're often only given options A and G, or maybe B and F, but rarely C through E. This is the exact opposite of what economic theory predicts and my (admittedly biased) personal observations. Consider for example Hoetelling's Law, which states that competitors naturally tend to become as similar as possible in order to extract as much value from the competition as possible: https://www.uh.edu/engines/epi2692.htm https://www.uh.edu/engines/epi2692.htm The advantage of systems other than the two party system is precisely that they allow more diverse view points to be represented.
- smallnamespace 8y agoThat only applies when there isn't a direct payoff from being against the other side ... which is exactly what the primary process selects for.
- TuringTest 8y agoActually, I can see how this process actually solves the problem of extreme preferences, and does it in favor of those minorities who have the most to gain. Suppose I belong to minority group X (say people with a rare disease, LGBT, immigrants...) whose life will literally change by approving or rejecting a bill. On the other side, a similarly sized group Y strongly opposes the first group out of first principles from their ideology (reducing taxes, sanctity of heterosexual marriage, keeping the country "pure"). Usually this group will have strong opinions against several of those social issues, but none of them will really affect their lives directly. So, their votes will be divided among several issues. Therefore, the votes of a small group will decide the outcome in their benefit on those issues that strongly affect them, unless: 1) an equal opposing group has the same extreme incentives (and in that case, the opinion of the overall population will decide), or 2) the opposing group is much larger than the small group. I'd say that, in both cases, it is reasonable to think that the system is working as it should.