13 ms·
Most relevant details, from the last link [1]: > It took her photo, comparing her picture to a preloaded photo databased of all the passengers with tickets on
by crazygringo 8y ago
Most relevant details, from the last link [1]:
> It took her photo, comparing her picture to a preloaded photo databased of all the passengers with tickets on this flight, and then she got a check mark, indicating she was cleared to board. The whole process took about five to six seconds.
> The Aruba experiment is expected to last somewhere between 45 and 90 days.
> "We're basically capturing that picture at the boarding gate, providing it to U.S. Customs and Border Protection. They're identifying the traveler," Farrell said. "It's actually the U.S. government that's implementing the biometric matching system that does all the hard analysis and crunching of the data."
> A biometric exit system to track non-U.S. citizens using their faces or fingerprints has long been a congressional mandate, particularly after 9/11, to improve border security and identify people who've overstayed their visas.
> Crockford says people don't know how CBP might share that data with local police. CBP insists it'll discard photos taken of citizens, and only keep a database of non-citizens.
> Customs and Border Protection has been piloting similar biometric tests at airports in Atlanta, New York and the D.C. area. And, according to a customs official, the goal is to deploy facial recognition tech widely by early next year.
I guess it must be comparing with their passport photo? (Or visa photo, for foreigners?) It doesn't seem much different from the way you're already required to show your physical passport and they check your photo manually. It's also always been pretty normal to have your photo taken by countries when passing through passport control. So I don't really see what the problem would be here?
[1] https://www.wbur.org/bostonomix/2017/06/21/jetblue-facial-recognition-pilot https://www.wbur.org/bostonomix/2017/06/21/jetblue-facial-re...
- chatmasta 8y agoIs it really that useful to identify someone who has overstayed their visa when they are leaving the country? Sure, you then know not to let them in next time. But it seems like a lot of effort when there are so many people overstaying their visa and not leaving out of the airports. That said, even as a libertarian, privacy-conscious person, I'm not sure I have a problem with exit controls like this. It's important to know who is crossing the border, in both directions. But why do they even need the photo? Presumably the name is already on the ticket... surely they can detect overstays from names + address alone, not just photos?
- mfatica 8y agoDidn't read the article, did it specify international flights? It makes sense if they're doing this for intranational flights too
- village-idiot 8y agoAlso, you need photo ID to fly and pass customs.
- dillonmckay 8y agoYou don’t need photo ID to fly. TSA will ask you questions from your credit report and allow you to board. *US citizens flying within the states.
- gumby 8y agoYou are correct; sad that most people don't know this.
- reallydude 8y agoI'm not sure that's true everywhere, but not for long many places (eg California, Washington). Casual article on it: https://www.king5.com/article/news/local/how-to-get-on-a-plane-when-real-id-is-enforced-in-october-2020/281-573114349 https://www.king5.com/article/news/local/how-to-get-on-a-pla...
- gumby 8y agoThe real id rules only address what documents count as id, no the cases of no id
- asdff 8y agoWhy should they? The only time it would be relevant is if you forgot your ID, and if you want to rent a car or hotel at your destination that might be a problem there as well. Knowing the TSA, I bet this adds at least an hour to the trip as you are begrudgingly walked to some back room and sit there for 20 minutes while someone is pulling up your file.
- ssss11 8y ago>It's also always been pretty normal to have your photo taken by countries when passing through passport control. No not always, only recently. > I don't really see what the problem would be here? You’re kidding right? There’s multiple privacy problems. Sounds like you either benefit from mass surveillance or have been conditioned to it.
- sushisource 8y agoI think being conditioned to it is inevitable to some degree. I think the only reasonable choice is to focus on punishment for misuse, not prevention. This reeks to me of another situation where we're trying to put the cat back in the bag, and that has basically never worked (except maybe nuclear disarmament, and even then... barely, and largely because the capital costs are so extreme). Surveillance tech is cheap and widely available and will only continue to move in that direction. Attempting to make sure no one has a photo of you without your consent seems hilariously impossible to me. Focus on the outcomes instead.
- mentat 8y agoMake it symmetric, use it to watch the watchers, then we might be talking about something socially viable. Without that, it's about control.
- shkkmo 8y agoThere is a fundamental trade-off between transparency and privacy, but also a very real risk that we will end up with neither.
- lapinot 8y agoPrivacy is not hiding, it's about controlling visibility. Most of the data we wish would be treated differently are not strictly private, we just don't assume they would be easily accessible (specifically by a private company). We are currently transparent to big actors but cannot see through the window ourselves.
- yellowapple 8y ago> CBP insists it'll discard photos taken of citizens, and only keep a database of non-citizens. So only non-citizens would be able to "use" the face-as-boarding-pass "feature"?
- sombremesa 8y agoAnd you probably still need to have a boarding pass to get past TSA.
- codedokode 8y agoI am not sure if passport photo is good enough for this. The mimimum requirement for face recognition is about 50 pixels between the eyes, and for reliable recognition it probably should be more. So the photo must come from somewhere else. For example, it could be taken when she passed the gates previous time.
- gorbypark 8y agoI'm not sure what the resolution is (I tried it out a few years back), but you can actually pull your digital passport photo out of your passport using NFC. There's an Android app for it.
- joe_the_user 8y agoNot to mention some portion of photos would have to be out-of-date or otherwise unusable. My guess is the app probably just approved anyone or nearly anyone. It's unlikely someone without a boarding pass would try to get on and it's likely that anyone with a boarding pass who got disapproved would be pissed. Or who knows, maybe homeland security did a mechanical Turk and had someone at the other end looking at faces and checking off names.
- jpalomaki 8y agoIn Europe there’s automated passport control gates with face recognition in several airports. These are based on the photo stored on passport. Not sure how automatic these are - would be of course possible to have a human there looking at the photos. According to quick search there’s no specific resolution requirement for the image in biometric passport, but size should be min 12kB to have recognizable image. https://readid.com/blog/face-images-in-ePassports https://readid.com/blog/face-images-in-ePassports
- things 8y agoThere is a human looking at the photos. When you take the Eurostar you can see them sitting in a booth after the gates. If you look into the booth as you pass, you'll see a grid of photos on screen. I'm assuming they're overseeing it all rather than checking everything manually. I noticed that these gates were quite slow ID'ing me the first couple of times I went through them but now I hardly have the time to see my face flash on the screen before the gates open. Maybe there's a human check on initial passes. Either that or their code has gotten way better or they store data that helps matching after a few uses.
- tikhonj 8y agoI have a Green Card and I get my photo taken each time I enter the country. I assume the same process exists for non-citizens, and that CPB is using these photos for this process.
- Milner08 8y agoEveryone on an ESTA has their photo taken when they enter the US (at least first time you enter on an ESTA. I don't always have it taken on subsequent visits). I would assume that is enough for them to match you.
- drb91 8y ago> It doesn't seem much different from the way you're already required to show your physical passport and they check your photo manually. Well, now they can check your identity anywhere with a camera removing all agency. Yay!