7 ms·
Those who do genetic testing in the clinic know that, far more frequently than expected, family relations do not line up exactly as the genetic inheritance happ
by epistasis 8y ago
Those who do genetic testing in the clinic know that, far more frequently than expected, family relations do not line up exactly as the genetic inheritance happens. Clinicians go to great lengths to avoid damaging families with these revelations. I have a feeling that such ethics will not be brought to these situations by DHS.
- hello_friendos 8y agoI think damaging families is the point of this policy.
- Agustus 8y agoThe point of this policy is to identify real familial relations with those crossing the border. At the border there are instances of individuals using children to get special preference. The proposed idea will mitigate this issue.
- a_random_name 8y agoThis makes a lot of presumptuous about the intention of the adults here. Do you know that these are not something similar to adoptive parents?!
- mchristen 8y agoCan you define "real familial relations" purely by DNA? I don't think so, what about adoptions or surrogates? This just seems like a policy that can be used to discriminate against people who don't fit a chosen definition of "family".
- creaghpatr 8y agoOr it can be used to expedite the clearance of real families instead of subjecting everyone to the same questioning methods.
- thex10 8y ago> real families That's... still discriminating against people who don't fit a chosen definition of "family"
- mc32 8y agoBut then they won’t be claiming “this is my daughter/son”... They’re trying to filter against bogus claims.
- roywiggins 8y agoAnd people with adoptive children will say what, exactly?
- mc32 8y agoPresumably they can provide papers to the effect. Just as if I were to claim asylum in any other place. Also, I’m sure they have rates of these things and if it starts getting higher than the norm it could prompt more scrutiny.
- roywiggins 8y agoPeople fleeing for their lives may not have access to paperwork. In fact, the authorities denying people access to paperwork- such as birth records and legal status- is almost certainly evidence for approving an asylum claim in the first place.
- mc32 8y agoDo you think the instances “fleeing” is the bulk of the cases? Mostly it’s economic migrants. We know if they were fleeing they could just stay in Mexico or if not from The Americas, in a neighboring country. Also, in many of those countries there isn’t a tradition of adoption, so that would be pretty rare.
- klyrs 8y agoGood to know that adoptions aren't "real." So if a kid's parent dies and they're living with an aunt, that's not "real" and the government is free to tear the child's remaining family away and replace it with rape and imprisonment. Way to mitigate the issue. Damn the consequences.
- LoSboccacc 8y agoadoptions have a paper trail.
- sszz 8y agoNot a given, particularly for people fleeing countries in crisis, disarray, or violent turmoil. Or if a parent died during the migration, etc.
- LoSboccacc 8y ago> if a parent died during the migration so if a parent dies any rando in the caravan can claim the child and get all the attached benefits? gee, wonder if that kind of reward would have side effects on the safety of migrants with children.
- astazangasta 8y ago
- sszz 8y agoIt would mitigate this issue to an extent, but also introduces new challenges (for instance and as pointed to elsewhere: dealing with officially/unofficially adopted children). I'm not sure if there are published numbers on what fraction of adult asylum seekers are attempting to use children in this way, but the preoccupation with "solving" this particular issue demonstrates that either (a) that fraction is disturbingly high or (b) we'd like to make the process even more complicated for no particularly good reason. The trend of every policy along the border seems to suggest that (b) is more likely, which is upsetting.
- creaghpatr 8y agoIt's to prevent "Child Recycling" which is trafficking children across the border to claim asylum then trafficking them back to accompany a new group of migrants.
- gcb0 8y agoread the comment you replied to again. hint: it won't be effective at that.
- empath75 8y agoDo you think that actually happens.
- okcando 8y agoIt's been my experience that anything that can be conceived of does or will actually happen but I'd be surprised if this were a common occurrence. On the other hand, we are talking about desperate people frequently traveling under the guidance of notoriously callous border traffickers so what do I know...
- asveikau 8y agoI have no data, but I'd wager it's way more common to see any of the following: adoption, people raised by non-blood relatives, paternity not being what was thought -- all while being innocent, law abiding people.
- drak0n1c 8y ago> From October 2017 to February 2018, there was a 315 percent increase in the number of cases of adults with minors fraudulently posing as “family units” to gain entry.
- empath75 8y agoSo does that mean it was 5 cases and now it’s 21?
- dang 8y agoWould you mind reviewing the site guidelines and following them here? They include: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." We're trying to avoid flamewars on Hacker News, because they're predictable, therefore uninteresting, therefore off topic (see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). Plus they bring out meanness and dumbness in people and get worse as they go along.
- gcb0 8y agothis has nothing to do with being correct. there's a rush by law enforcement to create a DNA database. and if you did at a clinic or 23and me et al, be sure that your dna plus some metadata (if not from you, from your payment or from the lab, anything that goes around hippa is game) is already cataloged there. couple months ago a newspaper shown how cheap private investigators paid for this data to narrow down location of people they were paid to locate.
- drenvuk 8y agoSometimes I feel like I'm too paranoid but then these things keep happening that seemed like they would happen years ago which uselessly vindicates my position. Is there some critical threshold where they have enough DNA data to track everyone not in the database? Maybe any amount is helpful since it narrows a pool down. Why do people keep giving out their information so freely?
- rexpop 8y agoWe don't believe it could happen here.
- runlevel1 8y agoThe recent use of DNA-based ancestry sites' genealogical data to solve cold cases would suggest we're not far off. [1]: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2167554-serial-killer-suspect-identified-using-dna-family-tree-website/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2167554-serial-killer-s... [2]: https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/9kpnnz/linda-ann-okeefe-murder-suspect-arrest-dna https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/9kpnnz/linda-ann-okee... [3]: https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2019/02/19/maine-man-accused-killing-young-woman-alaska-years-ago/auNFXwgMAsXMmwGGzDLY4H/story.html https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2019/02/19/maine-man-accus...
- astura 8y agoFor white people, at least. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/10/golden-state-killer-genealogy/572545/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/10/golden-s... > Then the researchers built a model that predicted that a database needs to include only 2 percent of a population for 90 percent of the people to have a third-cousin match or closer in it. In other words, a database of just a few million people could be sufficient to track down nearly everyone in the United States....Another pattern jumped out in the MyHeritage data: People of primarily northern European ancestry were more likely to have matches than people of primarily sub-Saharan ancestry. This reflects the predominantly white customer base for MyHeritage and most other direct-to-consumer DNA tests. It also means that genetic-genealogy searches by law enforcement are, for now, more likely to succeed with people of European descent. These sorts of identifications actually require a lot of manual work by genetic genealogists tracing ancestry after a potential relative is found in a DNA database. For example, Barbara Rae-Venter lead a team of five people to identify the Golden State Killer. BTW, there's a handy Wikipedia page for a list of suspects identified using the GEDMatch database https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_suspected_perpetrators_of_crimes_identified_with_GEDmatch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_suspected_perpetrators...
- dehrmann 8y ago> I have a feeling that such ethics will not be brought to these situations by DHS. I'm picturing the president hosting a daytime talk show "who's the father" episode.
- thomasjudge 8y agoFTA: "The information collected in the DNA test will not be stored or shared, the ICE official said." Now, whether or not this is true...
- meheleventyone 8y agoNot to mention questions about how reliable this quick fix DNA testing is. False negatives will happen and destroy families in the process.
- calimac 8y agoBecause you have been manipulated by the fake news media. #LiberalismIsAMentalDisorder