3 ms·
> No. They can't as long as cheap energy storage on mass scales doesn't exist. It does, Tesla's grid-scale Powerwall made 25% of its cost in profits in 6 month
by mschuster91 8y ago
> No. They can't as long as cheap energy storage on mass scales doesn't exist.
It does, Tesla's grid-scale Powerwall made 25% of its cost in profits in 6 months (per https://insideevs.com/news/340702/tesla-powerpack-in-australia-generated-17-million-in-revenue-in-6-months/ https://insideevs.com/news/340702/tesla-powerpack-in-austral...).
Aside from using Powerwalls, us Europeans have extensive experience with using hydro pump storage.
- jjoonathan 8y agoSo why did Germany go with gas and coal?
- Tomte 8y agoGermany has always had a lot of coal. It's not like Germany just started building a lot of coal plants, to replace the closed nuclear plants.
- mschuster91 8y agoOur coal infrastructure is on the way to be phased out, it won't be around for long-term any more - the Kohlekommission proposed 2035-2038 for the final shutdown, with 12.5 GW of 42.6 GW capacity going offline until 2022 (per https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2019-01/kohlekommission-kohleausstieg-bundesregierung-plan-kraftwerke-braunkohle https://www.zeit.de/wirtschaft/2019-01/kohlekommission-kohle...). What's left will be gas and renewables.
- bboygravity 8y agoIt is planned to be phased out. Just like nuclear. That means that within 15 years Germany will have to replace roughly 70 % of its constant energy sources (nuclear and coals) by the only scalable constant energy source left: gas. Thereby becoming completely reliant on gas from Russia. Creating a massive geopolicital risk that didn't exist previously. http://instituteforenergyresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Germany-Electricity-Generation.png http://instituteforenergyresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/201... I'll believe it when I see it. Also. What problem exactly is that supposed to solve? I thought the whole energiewende stunt was about decreasing CO2 emissions. I'm not seeing this.
- imtringued 8y ago>by the only scalable constant energy source left: gas. What makes you think coal and nuclear are scalable? Gas has been the only option from the start and simply switching from coal to gas already results in a 50-60% CO2 reduction.
- realityking 8y ago> Thereby becoming completely reliant on gas from Russia. While currently most imports are from Russia,there‘s an effort to start building LNG terminals to be able to import from the US. https://www.reuters.com/article/germany-lng/update-1-germany-set-to-have-at-least-2-lng-terminals-minister-idUSL5N2072W1 https://www.reuters.com/article/germany-lng/update-1-germany... Part of this is appeasement to the US but it is a good backup to have.
- Tuna-Fish 8y agoThe Tesla grid scale system made that money by stabilizing the grid, essentially providing storage for time periods below 15 minutes. It in no way provides the kind of storage that is needed to use solar or wind power as baseline production.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThey also chose Australia on purpose, because the energy market there is pretty messed up and the result is high energy prices, i.e. higher profits than the same system would see somewhere else. For battery storage to be cost effective in general it has to be quite a bit cheaper than it currently is. The cost has been declining, but people who expect exponential curves to continue forever are generally disappointed. It may or may not hit a stable floor before the cost is low enough to actually replace baseload power generation. What it is likely to be good for is to get over the load hump between dusk and bedtime for solar -- but that requires a lot less storage than being able to carry the whole night. Especially in winter (when the nights are longer), and especially if we expect people to switch from carbon-based to electric heat. The issue is we need to be building things to replace carbon right now. Even if batteries become cost effective in a decade or more, that's too late. And there is no guarantee of even that.
- chelical 8y agoTo be fair, nuclear power plants can also take a decade or more to build.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> To be fair, nuclear power plants can also take a decade or more to build. That's kind of the point. Better to have it and not need it than need it and not have it. And even if batteries become cost effective in a decade or more, that's when people start installing them at scale. It's not as if you could replace the entire grid with them overnight either.
- 8y ago