3 ms·
Scientists Know Better Than You--Even When They're Wrong
- DaniFong 19y agoI really disagree with the premise of the article. Famously, Feynman stated that “Science is the belief in the ignorance of the experts”. When his sweetheart Arlene Greenbaum became sick, he found himself shuttered away, studying her ailment with as much intensity as he could spare. Eventually he thought, based on the evidence, that it was most probably tuberculosis. But this was, at the time, a common disease. He reasoned that her doctors (of which there were many) would have known if it was. So he discounted his own diagnosis, and placed his faith in the opinion of the experts, who, if I recall correctly, believed it to be some sort of rare cancer. But it was tuberculosis. She died from it. Doing science isn't about applying some particular professional method. Fundamentally it's about using everything at your disposal to find out the truth of things. So called non-scientists can do that, if only they try. As an ethos, science, at least as it's seen by some, couldn't be more anti-expertise.
- dhbradshaw 19y ago>Fundamentally it's about using everything at your disposal to find out the truth of things. Nice statement. Also, great story. It's not just Feynman either. I've seen the same thing (family members getting the diagnosis before doctors because they care more and take the time to get it right) several times in my own family. As a graduate student I find myself continually astonished by the fact that narrow expertise comes quickly. That is, if you start out with a specific question it will not take too long before you understand it better than your adviser and then better than anyone you can find and finally better than anyone in the world, as far as you can discern. Basically, the world is so broad that if you specialize on a specific, well formed question (as Feynman did) you can probably become a world expert on that question if you put in the time and are actually looking to learn.
- kingkongrevenge 19y agoThe word "scientist" needs to be banned. There are physicists who have expertise in physics, much as there are plumbers who know a lot about plumbing. But there is no such special class of human beings called "scientists."
- kingkongrevenge 19y agoThe tone of the piece is kind of pathetic. It's people who crave more power and prestige bemoaning their status as technicians. Huge numbers of people believe all kinds of idiotic things in all sorts of unscientific domains, and this is not an interesting observation. This article only exists because between the lines they're talking about political power. This bit cracks me up. >Parents believe that even though doctors assure them that vaccines are safe, those doctors may be wrong. Therefore, the parents think they are entitled to throw their own judgment into the mix. The NERVE of parents to review the literature and conclude the autism threat may be greater than the vaccine protective benefits and make their own decision. It's not like billion dollar pharmaceutical products and associated government policies have ever hurt people before! The piece fails to even allude to the idea that scientific officialdom blew its credibility last century. A whole lot of stupid or evil policies and pronouncements that pushed people around were made under the banner of science. The laissez-faire people were almost always right.
- vixen99 19y agoHow annoying this is: 'But the collective expertise of thousands of researchers barely registers with global warming skeptics, creationist movie producers and distrustful parents. Why is scientific authority under fire from so many corners?' A neat trick, associating global warming scepticism with creationism! Why is it so difficult for people to understand that science proceeds via argument backed by data not by 'consensus' whatever that might be or estimations of scientists' expertise.