3 ms·
First off, great article. But, like so many other articles about security vulnerabilities, there seems to be a general attitude among most people (including ma
by peter_d_sherman 8y ago
First off, great article.
But, like so many other articles about security vulnerabilities, there seems to be a general attitude among most people (including many IT shops) that "it's an isolated incident", and "the experts will fix it...".
"It's an isolated incident", and "The experts will fix it...".
They said the same thing about Spectre, Meltdown, Rowhammer attacks, what have you.
"It's an isolated incident", and "The experts will fix it...".
Well, if you read HN long enough, you'd know that there's too much of this on too regular a basis to continue to espouse those views.
I'm going to go for broke here.
I'm going to put on my conspiracy "what if" tin-foil hat, and ask two questions.
The first is related to Virus-Checking and Security Software -- like Norton, McAfee, etc. how do we know that any of it doesn't contain remote code execution (aka major security) vulnerabilities?
You see, if I were the bad guys, that's where I'd put it.
Also, let's say you have Nation States. Could you see one of these guys "persuading, for the good of their country" one or more of their same-nationality corporations to put such vulnerabilities into their "Security" software?
In other words, maybe you have a Chinese producer of anti-virus/security software, and maybe it has little "surprises" for non-Chinese Citizens.
Maybe you have an American producer of anti-virus/security software, and it too has little "surprises" for non-American Citizens.
You see? Nation A thinks that it's permissible and OK for it to compromise Nation B's "Security" software. And Nation B thinks the same thing, but in reverse.
Even if Nation States are removed from the equation, you still have the Virus Checker/Security software company themselves. How do you know that random employees at that company haven't tainted that software in some way?
In other words, "Who guards the guardians?"
Which is my second question.
It's an ancient philosophical question.
"Who guards the guardians?"
We The People - do not seem to be doing such a good job these days...
All I know is that you might be seeing a whole lot more "isolated incidents" that "the experts will have to fix" in the future, unless We The People - step up to the plate...
- ilaksh 8y agoWell I think it's very possible that backdoors are set up by governments like you say. But I also think that even if they don't, it also seems very possible that vulnerabilities are quite common as mistakes. Just due to the realities of security. In my opinion security is much more difficult than people realize. For example in this case there seems to be a majority opinion something along the lines of "What an idiot! _I_ would never make that mistake!". It's much easier to say that in hindsight than it is to really execute secure code that no one can defeat. The response might be "well, no one broke into any of _my_ systems so far" and I would say .. how do you know they didn't? And also, maybe no one bothered to try to exploit you because you are not a high value target. Or they are just busy and will get to trying to penetrate you next week. I think this is due to the complexity of software and IT rather than general negligence.
- jondubois 8y agoYes I don't think that the government needs to plant vulnerabilities to get backdoors into people's machines. Finding vulnerabilities is not that difficult. The more moving parts you have and the more complex the code is, the more likely it is that there are vulnerabilities in the software.