4 ms·
Some of the big tech companies already have a solution to this problem (good performers might not be good managers): They make it possible to make good money a
by lordnacho 8y ago
Some of the big tech companies already have a solution to this problem (good performers might not be good managers):
They make it possible to make good money as an individual contributor without climbing the management ladder.
- abakker 8y agoThat is almost word for word mentioned in the article: >For example, technical organisations, like Microsoft and IBM have long used split career ladders, allowing their engineers to advance as individual contributors or managers. These practices recognize workers for succeeding in one area without transferring them to another. I think there is an interesting component here, though. There are no C-level individual contributors, really. At the head of an organization, is a manager/leader. The skill of management really is rewarded/recognized in organizations more readily. I think that makes sense, since the coordination of individual contributors is the most difficult problem to solve. OTOH, I'd say casually that most of the best leaders are those that were also excellent individual contributors. To really be the top of the management ladder, I think the empathy of personal experience is the more important than most managers give it credit for.
- ip26 8y agoThere are no C-level individual contributors, really. At the head of an organization, is a manager/leader. Even the top level technical track folks who are nominally IC's wind up doing some leadership. This makes sense; there's fundamentally a limit on how much you can accomplish all by yourself. Somewhere along the road, your visions will require the work of more people than only yourself. You can be a technical leader without being a manager, so it's not all bad.
- shostack 8y agoCan you be an effective C-level as an IC? Or by definition of the role does that preclude it?
- nilkn 8y agoI can confirm that, at least in my career so far, the management and technical tracks have never been completely equivalent -- even when great effort was spent trying to make them so. Very high-level IC roles are possible that are roughly equivalent to VP or SVP management roles. However, these are often extremely few in number compared to high-level management roles. They often come with a title like Technical Fellow or just Fellow. In a large company, there might be 100 VPs for every 1 Fellow. A mid-level manager is also often afforded more organizational perks than a mid-level IC. For instance, while private offices in general are in short supply across the entire industry, a mid-level manager is much likelier to have one than any IC is regardless of title.
- the_watcher 8y agoThe problem: while there is absolutely a need for very senior level ICs, there is simply less of one than there is for managers, so despite parallel career tracks existing, advancement often substantially more available via a management track.
- bitL 8y agoBut the ratio is like 10-100:1 for individual contributor vs manager, so the competition for a few spots on the IC ladder is much tougher than on the management ladder. That's why so many FANG employees are frustrated without any progress inside as they compete against some of the best engineers, but management is more leaky as assessing quality is not so clearly measurable/comparable.
- stcredzero 8y agoThere are different types of leadership, which get confused or conflated when talking about promotions and organizations. There are people who lead by being exemplars. Such people might contribute greatly to the organization, yet have minimal management skills. Then again, this also applies to different kinds of management. There are many different kinds and styles of management, which are differently suited to different situations. My wife and I often talk about her managing the "A students" versus the "B students" versus the "C and D students." Note that this is relative. If an organization is pushing into new and difficult terrain, some completely independent A students might become more like B students in the new context. Some "C and D students" might start to thrive in a far messier context. Think of the change of context between training camp, versus combat deployment in Band of Brothers and Hacksaw Ridge. In both of those shows/movies, the people who thrived and contributed the most in one context were very different than in the other context.
- hinkley 8y agoI've had to be careful even in a lead position to make sure the other team members have plenty of breathing room to work on things that are useful and that they enjoy. Being a project contributor and a source of authority work at cross purposes. It's not impossible but it's a drag on your faculties to maintain it. As a details person that answer is easy for me: I touch the parts that I don't ever want to break in production, the parts that mid level people tend to shy away from anyway. But not everyone has my temperament and being overly optimistic can result in treading on toes....