4 ms·
I don't see the problem. Extended detention and repeated interrogation is normal around the world. Visit Rikers island and look at how long people are held th
by sandworm101 8y ago
I don't see the problem. Extended detention and repeated interrogation is normal around the world. Visit Rikers island and look at how long people are held there prior to trial (years). The focus on confessions isn't a Japanese thing. Look at how many americans/canadians/brits/auzzis agree plea deals, a form of confession. Repeated questioning isn't torture. In the USA it is true that police have to stop asking questions once you demand a lawyer, but that isn't true in Canada. The mounties can, and do, question suspects for hours. Brits who do not want to speak still have to sit through the ritual of "no comment' interviews which can last hours. Are we only talking about these Japanese cases because they involve rich people?
- gambiting 8y ago>>I don't see the problem. Extended detention and repeated interrogation is normal around the world. Just because something is normalised doesn't mean it's ok, I think we can both agree on that?
- draw_down 8y agoMaybe it's just me, but when a widespread injustice is only being discussed in the context of it happening to a rich and/or powerful person, that's a pretty strong hint we're not talking about the actual injustice.
- thereare5lights 8y agoThen why do posts that talk about our (the US's) problems such as Rikers always get flagged on HN whereas posts about other countries get through? Seems like empty rhetoric to me.
- draw_down 8y ago> Are we only talking about these Japanese cases because they involve rich people? That would be my understanding, yes.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoSaying you don't see a problem is absolutely disgusting. The Rikers cases are miscarriages of justice and the two famous cases led to changes in the law to prevent some future horrors.
- socksindrawers 8y agoIf anything, I'm happy that there's a country willing to prosecute people for white collar crimes. Just look at how America is all-too-willing to let mass murderers like the Sackler family get away with profiting off of addiction. Do these sound like words of someone trying to do anything other than profit off of death? “The prescription blizzard will be so deep, dense, and white.” Meanwhile you see blue collar Americans charged with federal riot and conspiracy charges for exercising their legally protected free speech rights at a protest that they had acquired a permit for (Rise Above Movement).
- colejohnson66 8y agoRioting, even with a permit to protest, is illegal
- socksindrawers 8y agoThey didn't riot, they were attacked and defended themselves. Look at any video from the event.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fzeroracer 8y agoYou're saying the people that participated in the Unite the Right rally, who conspired to commit violence and escalate an already violent event and who were members of what is essentially a terrorist group were just defending themselves? No, they weren't attacked. They were the aggressors. They have a history of being aggressors. They openly admit to being violent and aggressive.
- socksindrawers 8y agoYes, that's what I'm saying. The people with the permit to demonstrate were attacked and defended themselves, and are being railroaded by the justice system. It's not illegal to be proud of defending your right to free speech with self defense. Meanwhile the people who show up with weapons and masks, and with no permit and incite the violence don't even get arrested. It even happened a few days ago at a Trump rally. A reporter got harassed and attacked, and nothing will happen to the perpetrators - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j693_xvdGTI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j693_xvdGTI
- ConcernedCoder 8y agoMy unpopular opinion: Questioning someone longer than they want to provide answers, when that same person is unable to leave the interview is a form of torture -- change my mind.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoUnder that reasoning I don't see how any form of detainment could not be considered torture as well, including pretty much all public education. One must accept that the real world is not made of lines that provide convenient barriers between concepts, in other words, there are degrees of torture, and some will be much more acceptable than others.
- pas 8y agoThe efficacy of learning for sitting in classes is very low. Especially for those who don't want to be there. So, yes, it's a quite pointless form of torture. (Kids who loathe school need therapy, not "just" school.)
- rmah 8y agoYour request is, at its heart, a question about the definition of the word "torture". The pedestrian definition of "torture" as per the Merriam-Webster dictionary is: 1: the infliction of intense pain (as from burning, crushing, or wounding) to punish, coerce, or afford sadistic pleasure 2: a) something that causes agony or pain; b) anguish of body or mind 3: distortion or overrefinement of a meaning or an argument I guess definition 2b in the context of "mind" fits best with your proposition. Which then leads to the definition of "anguish". Alternatively, we can examine the legal definition, which will vary by jurisdiction, but for completeness, I will link to the UN definition at https://www.apt.ch/en/what-is-torture/ https://www.apt.ch/en/what-is-torture/. In brief: "Torture means any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession" Here, you'd have to ask if prolonged unwanted questioning causes "severe [mental] pain or suffering". And finally, perhaps you mean torture in the figurative sense. Either way, if simply questioning someone "longer than they want" is "torture" then pretty much all of us have, at some point tortured someone. At that point, the word "torture" becomes synonymous with "discomfort" or "to annoy" and would, IMO, lose all utility from a legal point of view. In the final analysis, what this boils down to is that the world does not exist to serve your desires. Unpleasant things can and will happen to you. Even being asked questions you don't want to answer in situations where you cannot leave. While an individual may never have experienced anything more unpleasant than that, and thus it feels horrible to them, the fact is that there are far far FAR more unpleasant experiences that millions of others have faced. Society does not owe the sheltered more than the less sheltered.
- ekianjo 8y ago> I don't see the problem. Extended detention and repeated interrogation is normal around the world. You could say the following as well: I don't see the problem. Dictatorship is normal around the world. Since when is something normal just because it's widespread? There is no reason to keep someone in jail unless there is a strong suspicion they are a threat to others, or a risk of flight.
- dalore 8y agoYou can't leave until you confess or payup isn't a problem? With no access to family OR legal representation throughout the process?
- SkyBelow 8y ago> Look at how many americans/canadians/brits/auzzis agree plea deals, a form of confession. There are also done under threat. "Plea guilty to X and take 6 months in prison, or we will charge you with Y which carries 10 years in prison. If you choose the second option we will give you an overworked public defender who loses 90% of the time." In effect, it is punishing people for insisting on their right to a jury trial.
- SkyBelow 8y ago*There -> They're My self disappointment is immeasurable.