12 ms·
Permafrost collapse is accelerating carbon release
- ForHackernews 8y agoThis is an emergency; it's well past time we started acting like it: https://rebellion.earth/ https://rebellion.earth/
- subsubsub 8y agoIt may well be an emergency, but inconveniencing [1][2] the very people you are attempting to persuade (the voting public) is not a strategy that is likely to work. In my opinion it will make them deaf to the underlying message (Although, I can provide no suggestions for strategies that might work!). [1] e.g. preventing them getting to work or flying to a holiday [2] Extinction Rebellion Protests: What happened? - https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-48051776 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-48051776
- c1sc0 8y agoRevolutions have worked in the past. Even non-violent ones. But those are rare.
- crispinb 8y agoThe ER founders chose nonviolent civil disobedience (which of necessity 'inconveniences' people) following decades of empirical research (eg. http://cup.columbia.edu/book/why-civil-resistance-works/9780231156820 http://cup.columbia.edu/book/why-civil-resistance-works/9780...) claiming to show that it's the most effective strategy for effecting fast & large-scale social change. I don't know the research well enough to assess it, but I'd trust it over lay guesswork (my own included!). The only further point I'd make is that less 'inconvenient' strategies (organising, lobbying, campaigning) have already failed. They've been tried relentlessly for 3 decades, and it's a done deal: they didn't work. Our civilisation is accelerating its path to global destruction (of which climate change is only one component). Emergency last-ditch strategies are all that's left.
- NeedMoreTea 8y ago> inconveniencing [1][2] the very people you are attempting to persuade (the voting public) is not a strategy that is likely to work Funny. Seems like it's working, remarkably quickly, to me: Michael Gove, the current Environment Minister, met with the protesters and accepted the need for urgent action, and other points. Far more than might be expected from the rather extremist position of today's Tory party. The opposition have acknowledged all their points, and pledged to make climate emergency policy. They are currently trying to force a vote on calling a climate emergency in the Commons. The organisers have turned up for interview on most of the UK's serious news outlets, including, I think, twice on the Today programme. Even those who've studiously avoided the topic are now talking about it. Oh, and public opinion of ER appears to have risen since the Easter protests. On that basis, I sincerely hope ER continue, and can step up their actions to more locations and companies too.
- roenxi 8y agoIf your first point of success is getting the Environment Minister to publicly commit to being pro-environment, you're working to a very low bar. It sounds like a problem that might be heading for a government committee rather than actual action. This thing you call a 'rather extremist position' is a traditional position industrial societies have held since the industrial revolution in the late 18th century. Exploiting the environment for the benefit of the people. This strategy has worked out quite well so far - cities are more far popular places to live than jungles and fields. Protesting can work - but there have been environmental protests for the last 20 years or so and have achieved much less than (1) big research spending on renewables and (2) using nuclear reactors. This is because apart from those two approaches, the environmentalists have proposed no solutions that don't involve committing the poor and middle class to reduced living standards. I'll spell it out even though I think it is self evident - we shouldn't put the environment ahead of the poor until we've exhausted every other option.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoIt's the current extreme right Tory party. One would normally expect their Environment Minister to pretend the protests and environment don't exist. Any admission is remarkable - but useless. For action we need a change of government. We've already had a select committee on climate that was unequivocal about what action and urgency was needed. > This thing you call a 'rather extremist position' is a traditional position industrial societies have held No, that really isn't true. The extremist position is continuing regardless in the face of overwhelming evidence. Not acting back in the 19th before there was any knowledge or evidence is not really comparable. It was Thatcher and Reagan that did so much to get the agreement for world phase out of CFCs in 1987. A more unlikely pair to promote such regulation I can't imagine. Thatcher was remarkably well informed in the earliest days of climate science. Also one of the first to call for global action on climate. So despite being of an anti-regulation mindset she was happy to promote and implement strong regulation to save our skins. From her speech to the UN in 1989: "What we are now doing to the world … is new in the experience of the Earth. It is mankind and his activities that are changing the environment of our planet in damaging and dangerous ways. The result is that change in future is likely to be more fundamental and more widespread than anything we have known hitherto. Change to the sea around us, change to the atmosphere above, leading in turn to change in the world's climate, which could alter the way we live in the most fundamental way of all. "The environmental challenge that confronts the whole world demands an equivalent response from the whole world. Every country will be affected and no one can opt out. Those countries who are industrialised must contribute more to help those who are not." She lost interest, or time, for the environment later in her premiership as it became ever more inept on most issues, caught up with in-party fighting (often EU related), and stupid ideas like poll tax. Yet her early and mid term record on climate and pollution is better than any since. > we shouldn't put the environment ahead of the poor until we've exhausted every other option. The poor will be more severely affected by climate changes than anyone.
- uxcolumbo 8y agoWouldn't you agree that the disruption caused was a 'good investment' for bringing up the climate crisis higher up the political agenda? Wales has declared a climate emergency and so has the First Minister of Scotland. Labour are going to launch a bid this Weds to do the same. “Blaming Extinction Rebellion for causing disruption is like blaming a fire alarm for waking you up in the middle of the night” XR's strategy seemed to work pretty well so far I would say.
- mempko 8y agoExtinction Rebellion chose non-violent civil disobedience after looking at lots of research around the subject of social change. They are being scientific about this and I think many people who are claiming it won't change minds haven't done the research as they did. This is a very very smart and focussed rebellion. They aren't just guessing their tactics will work, they base them on what actually did work. Listen to Roger Hallam talk about it here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8c2f_JmzoWU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8c2f_JmzoWU
- legostormtroopr 8y agoYeah - its about time someone started a focused group dedicated to climate change... > There will be a Puerto Rico contingency to the May Day Protests in NY that will create a specific performance relevant to the fight against debt and the 121 years of colonialism against Puerto Rico more generally. https://rebellion.earth/event/debt-is-a-hurricane-puerto-rico-contingency-may-day/ https://rebellion.earth/event/debt-is-a-hurricane-puerto-ric... Well, looks like another well intention green movement has been hijacked
- koheripbal 8y agoThe biggest problem with this rebellion is that it advocates disruption in the countries doing the MOST to combat climate change. I don't see any events planned in the biggest CO2 producers.
- ForHackernews 8y agoAre you Chinese? Start some events in China. Otherwise, I'd suggest you stop whining and start helping.
- Daishiman 8y agoFor those who haven't been watching this topic for the past few years: permafrost melt is the most probable factor for the possibility of a near-term extinction event.
- mistrial9 8y agofear and panic do not make a strategy; taking the issue seriously is, from a risk-management perspective.
- bdamm 8y agoNASA testified to the US Senate in 1988 that "higher temperatures can now be attributed to a long-expected global warming trend linked to pollution". [1] So, with more than 30 years of taking the issue seriously, what do you suppose we should do, from a risk-management perspective? [1] https://www.nytimes.com/1988/06/24/us/global-warming-has-begun-expert-tells-senate.html https://www.nytimes.com/1988/06/24/us/global-warming-has-beg...
- rjf72 8y agoThere's one big issue inhibiting any sort of productive change on this issue. "A senior U.N. environmental official says entire nations could be wiped off the face of the Earth by rising sea levels if the global warming trend is not reversed by the year 2030. Coastal flooding and crop failures would create an exodus of ″eco- refugees,′ ′ threatening political chaos, said Noel Brown, director of the New York office of the U.N. Environment Program, or UNEP. He said governments have a 10-year window of opportunity to solve the greenhouse effect before it goes beyond human control. ... The most conservative scientific estimate that the Earth’s temperature will rise 1 to 7 degrees in the next 30 years, said Brown." All of that is accurately quoted with one exception. That article was published in 1989, the 'point of no return' was 2000, not 2030. And incidentally this year makes 30 years since that article was published. In spite of the "the most conservative estimate" showing an expected temperature rise of 1 to 7 degrees in these 30 years, we've seen the temperature increase by 0.62 degrees since 1989. [2] And global CO2 emissions have spiked far higher and faster than anybody could have imagined due in large part to China's ultra-rapid industrialization. Imagine you could go back in time 30 years ago armed with all the knowledge of today, and had the power to do whatever you could to try to enact action on climate change. What would you do? I think the most logical thing to do would be to put out pinpoint accurate predictions. When you do this you'd establish a substantial degree of reliability in the field. And then when the predictions start looking increasingly dire, you'd have decades of accuracy to justify action. And I think we can start this today. We need to focus on accuracy above any and everything else. When you want to enact global change you first need to establish yourself as a reliable authority. Then what we can do is look back and emphasize how accurate our predictions have been. But without reliability, we cannot expect predictions to actually drive any change that would be in any way inconvenient. [1] - https://apnews.com/bd45c372caf118ec99964ea547880cd0 https://apnews.com/bd45c372caf118ec99964ea547880cd0 [2] - https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/global-temperature/ https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/global-temperature/
- FeepingCreature 8y agoTo the meat: > We estimate that abrupt permafrost thawing in lowland lakes and wetlands, together with that in upland hills, could release between 60 billion and 100 billion tonnes of carbon by 2300.
- lixtra 8y agoIs this unique to human caused climate change or does it happen each time earth heats up?
- aaronbrethorst 8y agoThat doesn't feel particularly relevant to the possibility of destruction of our species. Regardless of whether or not this has happened before, it is unprecedented in human history.
- lixtra 8y agoIt is super relevant if it happened before because, even if no human witnessed it, there could be proxy data that shows how this unfolds. It could explain past sudden changes in climate change (and accompanying mass extinctions) that are not yet well understood for example.
- flukus 8y agoMost sudden changes were long enough ago that continents were in a different configuration at different latitudes, so it's not very prescriptive. It's almost definitely played some role but past climate change has almost always been the result of a number of factors coalescing, we have to estimate it's effects on our specific conditions.
- jamesblonde 8y agoThis is pure speculation. Configuration of continents has no affect on a warming ocean releasing large amounts of methane trapped as methane ice (methane clathrates). You then set some arbitrary condition on us understanding the current configuration of continents and how that would interact with the release of methane clathrates based on warming. Sorry this is denialism mascarading as evidence-based requirements. The analysis must be risk based - without requiring absolute certainty. Currently, scientific consensus is there is a risk of large releases of methane from melting Arctic sea ice.
- shard972 8y agoBut what about the plastic coffee cups?
- baruchthescribe 8y ago"This much is clear: the Arctic is warming fast,..." No it isn't. Arctic sea ice extent is normal and cyclical as can be seen from the Danish meteorological institute's data here: http://ocean.dmi.dk/arctic/icecover.uk.php http://ocean.dmi.dk/arctic/icecover.uk.php
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoHow does your statement follow from the graph you link? It clearly shows the years 2015-present are more than 2 standard deviations below the average from 1981-2000.
- baruchthescribe 8y agoArctic sea ice is also long-term cyclical and has no relationship to carbon dioxide. It's currently the same thickness as it was 60 years ago.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThis is complete, unmitigated bullshit, and anyone with a pulse, the ability to do a couple searches, and an 8th grade reasoning ability not completed blinded by "global warming is a librul conspiracy!!!" could figure this out. Just stop.
- cr1895 8y agoTo bolster your point: http://psc.apl.uw.edu/research/projects/arctic-sea-ice-volume-anomaly/ http://psc.apl.uw.edu/research/projects/arctic-sea-ice-volum...
- cageface 8y agoThe oil industry’s FUD has done its job here. I don’t completely understand how they managed to turn this into a partisan left/right issue but hats off to them for understanding how to play the system so well. Lately I wonder if there are other intelligent species on other worlds that managed to deal with this problem like adults or if technological change always outpaces social and political maturity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bayareanative 8y agoThe recommendation for arboreal permafrost is to remove all the trees because grassland tundra hard freezes easier than forests, and this is necessary to maintain soil stability in the summer months. And to do so, reintroducing large megafauna herds that destroy trees are necessary, potentially with a mammoth/elephant hybrid; or with logging. Interestingly, large managed herds of grazing animals is a solution to grassland health for avoiding and reversing desertification.
- freeflight 8y agoReminds me of what Sergey Zimov has been trying to do in Siberia with his "Pleistocene park" [0], which afaik ties into attempts to bring back the woolly mammoth to act as the megafauna [1] [0] https://www.lonelyplanet.com/news/2017/03/23/ice-age-ecosystem-siberia/ https://www.lonelyplanet.com/news/2017/03/23/ice-age-ecosyst... [1] https://gizmodo.com/scientists-could-soon-resurrect-the-woolly-mammoth-but-1833953899 https://gizmodo.com/scientists-could-soon-resurrect-the-wool...
- mceoin 8y agoAllan Savory talks about the use of intensive grazing as a method for combatting desertification in Africa [0]. Herd fertilize while eating grasses that would otherwise fall into senescence and create pockets of erosion. [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vpTHi7O66pI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vpTHi7O66pI
- pas 8y agoAlas their experiment concluded without significant difference between the treatment and non-treatment zones. Basically the guy (and holistic grazing) is a quack(ery). :/ https://www.truthordrought.com/holistic-grazing-myths https://www.truthordrought.com/holistic-grazing-myths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holistic_management_(agriculture)#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holistic_management_(agricultu...
- flukus 8y agoThanks for that, I believed this. I've got to stop trusting TED talks.
- ThomPete 8y agoAgain a speculative article. “Might” is the important word in that article and Might” is not the word you use in scientifically demonstrated claims. This debate have become so ideological that all reason has left the room a long time ago. Show me scientifically demonstrated consequences not just speculated consequences we cant deal with, then ill rally behind you until then i am quite confident in my non-alarmist position.
- freeflight 8y agoYou are asking for absolutes in science, which is something that does not exist because science is not dogma, thus open to corrections, which is inherently opposed to making absolute statements. That's why scientific statements use probabilities and words like "might", it has nothing to do with "not demonstrated" but everything with admitting that humans are fallible beings and there's always a margin of error.
- ThomPete 8y agoI am asking for a demonstrated fact not speculation. I know what the difference is in science. It's not a scientific statement it's interpretation of ths science something very very different. There are plenty of areas where I can point to specific facts which can be demonstrated to be true. So I am not asking for anything insane here. Just that we stop pretending speculated is the same as demonstrated. As an example. Let's assume that human CO2 emissions have some effect on the climate. Try and find the specific percentage that humans are demonstrated to be affecting climate. Not just speculated but demonstrated. I would even allow for a 10% margin.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoA practical plan for limiting carbon emissions: 1. Carbon tax 2. Import tariff at the border equivalent to the carbon tax on carbon used in production, plus an admin fee. But only on products from countries without their own carbon tax or equivalent. 1. This can be adopted unilaterally, but would probably work best if adopted by a group of nations at the beginning. 2. Does not require the near impossible task of requiring world wide agreement at the beginning. The hope is that it will encourage everybody to join the club eventually 3. Structuring as a tax rather than quotas mostly eliminates the fairness problem between developed / developing
- pas 8y agoThe important thing is, that to make the tax a pure carbon-negative incentive, that the revenue from the tax should be simply paid back to the taxpayers (of course divided into equal parts).
- uclscount 8y agoGet your daily dose of climate hysteria!
- gdubs 8y agoMelting permafrost is the thing that terrifies me. For a long time now scientists have been warning of the potential bomb lurking there. But, my understanding is it hasn’t factored heavily in the IPCC reports because feedback loops have historically been difficult to quantify. Anecdotally, the trend seems to be that when it comes to Climate Change, things rarely break in our favor and those “worst case scenarios” seem to be coming up frequently. I’m a pragmatist, I remain optimistic (foolishly, perhaps), but I think it’s fair to say that society isn’t sufficiently grappling with the potential catastrophe on the horizon. In particular I don’t think enough attention is given to the possibility of climate dynamics at some point rapidly flipping to some new normal.