4 ms·
"Because if there is a "run on the bank", someone will end up short. Either the first people out will get 100% of their money and last 26% will get zero, or eve
by perl4ever 8y ago
"Because if there is a "run on the bank", someone will end up short. Either the first people out will get 100% of their money and last 26% will get zero, or everyone will get 74% of their money."
I'm not clear on whether they have discovered fractional reserve banking or whether they are insolvent. There's a big difference. If they are insolvent, I'd tend to assume tethers not trading at a discount just means people are idiots. But if not, not.
- bb88 8y agoI think the difference is that in the end a Bank is backed and regulated by the US Government. Tether is not. So it is solvent or insolvent.
- perl4ever 8y agoI don't see why being regulated or not has anything to do with whether you are practicing fractional reserve banking. As I understand it, the concept is just that your assets are not all liquid, but rather some of them are long term loans. Which is not to say I think unregulated banking is the same as regulated banking.
- ShorsHammer 8y agoBank reserves have little to do with money creation: > Lord Adair Turner, formerly the UK's chief financial regulator, said "Banks do not, as too many textbooks still suggest, take deposits of existing money from savers and lend it out to borrowers: they create credit and money ex nihilo (out of nothing) – extending a loan to the borrower and simultaneously crediting the borrower’s money account > the German central bank explains that the money supply is not determined by the reserves of private banks, but by market factors and regulatory decisions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking#Criticisms_of_textbook_descriptions_of_the_monetary_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking#Cri...
- ShorsHammer 8y agoDo you think the US government could cover every single cent if all the depositors wanted their money out now? Not even physical cash, just a transfer to an overseas account. The money simply isn't there and the scales are enormous. US banks only can pay back 3-10% of cash deposits. The FDIC only has enough to cover a tiny proportion of bank liabilities. It seems very disingenuous for people in this thread to say "well if everyone cashed out tethers" and then handwave away the alternative of "well if everyone cashed out USD". These scenarios playing out would have Tether actually being able to pay a reasonable percentage of creditors.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoThe USA gov can just print the money to pay off the backed cash. Everyone gets their money. It may not be worth much if everyone actually demanded they could hold the dollar amount of their accounts in their hands in paper money - indeed, I imagine, you'd cause severe privations on the government funds in order to produce the money.
- perl4ever 8y ago"It may not be worth much if everyone actually demanded they could hold the dollar amount of their accounts in their hands in paper money" If literally nobody (hypothetically) is willing to own actual land, factories, and so on, then it's the tangible assets that are worthless, not the money. It would be the ultimate in deflation.
- ShorsHammer 8y agoI certainly agree it's possible, but at that stage you've gone down the Venezuelan path and I'd assume there are far smarter regulators in the States. The money wouldn't be given out, not even a fraction, it's a such a huge risk to stability that they'd cancel withdrawals and work from there. We saw this happen in Cyprus.
- stale2002 8y agoIt is literally impossible for the US to be "insolvent" when it comes to US dollars. They just print more money.
- nostrademons 8y agoYou could look at it as fractional reserve banking where one single borrower accounts for 26% of the assets. Tether is technically solvent (at least, assuming they aren't lying). However, they made a loan of $700M to Bitfinex. If Bitfinex pays back the loan on schedule and no more than 74% of Tether holders run for the exit, they're fine. However, that's a lot of counterparty risk, particularly considering it isn't clear whether Bitfinex is solvent, and that the big debtor (Bitfinex) and all the creditors (Tether holders) have correlated behavior. If Bitfinex becomes insolvent and defaults on the loan, Tether becomes insolvent. Bitfinex is more likely to become insolvent if Tether holders start withdrawing their money, which is the same event that would trigger a run on the bank and require that Tether call in its loan to Bitfinex. It actually looks a lot like the derivatives bomb in the financial industry from 2006-2008. You had some institutions that were insolvent because they made bad trades. You had other institutions that were technically solvent, but were standing next to insolvent ones, and would become insolvent if they had to write off the contracts they had with the insolvent ones. It's possible that all of your books would balance at the end - but do you want to be standing next to the bomb when it goes off?
- village-idiot 8y agoA fractional reserve bank is only fractionally liquid, the rest is invested in a variety of interest bearing loans. Obviously there’s always a risk of many loans not being repaid or sudden rushes for withdrawal, hence all the regulation and the FDIC. Tether is admitting that they only have enough cash and securities to cover 74% of the outstanding tether balance. This isn’t fractional reserve, this is just straight up insolvency. If your bank only has enough cash and mortgages to cover 74% of their deposits, then it’s time for the FDIC to step in.