6 ms·
Remember that Larry was CEO twice: 1998-2001 and 2011-2015. During the first period Google was exceptionally innovative. During the second, Google attempted t
by nostrademons 8y ago
Remember that Larry was CEO twice: 1998-2001 and 2011-2015. During the first period Google was exceptionally innovative. During the second, Google attempted to be exceptionally innovative but largely fell flat on its face.
I'd blame size and market position more. Google was left as one of very few profitable giants standing when the dot-com crash hit, and yet they were young enough to not have the institutional inertia of Amazon, E-bay, and Yahoo. That left them exceptionally well positioned to capitalize on the Internet's deployment phase, where the technology got good enough and widespread enough to really build huge businesses off it. They managed to own the next platform (mobile) but were too large, slow, and entrenched to really understand the implications of it, and they're not even attempting to play in the cryptoverse.
- manigandham 8y ago> cryptoverse What exactly is this and what business is doing well in it?
- apl002 8y agoI am assuming he is referring to cryptocurrencies & blockchain tech. There are plenty of businesses doing well but that's irrelevant. Waiting for established businesses in a growing space before jumping in isn't very innovative.
- sanderjd 8y agoThis is an interesting point: is it innovative to jump into any new thing regardless of its actual potential? You could claim that yes, it is. I would argue that it actually isn't. The key to innovation is to be able to correctly evaluate where there are real opportunities for innovative technologies. It's possible "the cryptoverse" will eventually show that it has such potential, but it has stubbornly refused to do that for the near decade that I've been paying attention to it, despite metric gob-tons of money and hype being thrown at it. On the other hand, in the same time period (actually in a shorter time period!), machine learning driven technologies like voice and image recognition have gone from sci-fi to commonplace. I ask: which is more innovative?
- nostrademons 8y agoJumping into a new thing regardless of its potential is a necessary, not sufficient, component of innovation. If you wait until it's obvious to everyone that something's a good idea, you're not being innovative, you're just an opportunist. Similarly, if it turns out that it's not actually a good idea, you're not being innovative, you've just wasted a whole lot of time. Innovation happens at the intersection of contrarian & right. You have to be willing to stake your time, energy, and ego on an idea that many people believe is bad, impossible, or not worth it (otherwise it would've been done already), but you also have to be right in your judgment.
- patejam 8y agoI'm confused by all the assumptions in this thread, including 1. That Google didn't research crypto internally and purposely decide not to pursue it. 2. That crypto is worth staking Google's time, energy, and ego on. 3. That crypto involvement is a direct reason a company is or is not innovative.
- nostrademons 8y agoHard lesson learned from a couple of research projects within Google and then again from my first couple years as an entrepreneur: Internal research is useless. The only way to know whether a new idea will work is to try it: put some minimal form of it in front of people and see if they actually get use it. People are complex; sometimes they do things that all rational thought says they shouldn't (buying Bitcoin and investing in ICOs would both fit into that category, IMHO), and many times they don't do things that all rational analysis says they should (I participated in research projects while at Google for both micropayments for content and for labeling trustworthy sources on the results, both of which most people would agree are good goals but neither of which has ever worked, and I founded a startup afterwards to provide career guidance to undergrads, which every adult we talked to said "I love what you're doing, and totally wish that existed when I was a student" and every student said "I love that idea and would totally use it", and then promptly never looked at it again once we built it.) There's no guarantee that external research works either, but at least you've learned something applicable to the next idea.
- ulfw 8y agoWhich one is doing well? Which company has actually delivered something? And what is it?
- nostrademons 8y agoThe set of companies & foundations centered around blockchain, cryptocurrency, distributed ledgers, and related technologies. Coinbase, Binance, CoinMarketCap are doing great, Bitmain would be doing great except they made a terrible bet on Bitcoin Cash, a number of other organizations (VeChain, IOTA, Ripple, Stellar, Ethereum) are doing "we'll see", and still others (Bitfinex, Tether, Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin SV) are imploding dramatically.
- Aeolun 8y agoLooks like the only ones doing well are the traders.
- nostrademons 8y agoNah, it's the folks who sell shovels to the traders. Just like every other gold rush in history. Fortunes get created, but often not for the folks who think they're going to get rich.
- spookthesunset 8y agoThe whole space is a pile of scams the entire way down. As we are just now learning, tether, the "stablecoin" that makes up the backbone of the entire crypto economy was basically a fraud. The tech has had 10 years and so far it has produced absolutely nothing of value. In fact considering the damage it has done to the environment, it has been only contributing negative value to the planet.
- ForHackernews 8y agoI assume this refers to cyptocurrency-related businesses. ICOs ('initial coin offerings') collected around $5.6 billion and most of them never delivered any real product: https://www.coinwire.com/ey-report-finds-most-2017-icos-failed-to-deliver-a-product https://www.coinwire.com/ey-report-finds-most-2017-icos-fail... One could argue that getting enormous amounts of money without needing to produce any results for it is the very definition of "doing well".
- stanleydrew 8y agoI hope there aren't too many people who define "doing well" that way. Seems like it would lead to a total breakdown of the social fabric.
- mrb 8y agoCryptocurrencies. For example Coinbase is doing well—raised $300M on a $8B valuation: http://fortune.com/2018/10/30/coinbase-series-e-funding/ http://fortune.com/2018/10/30/coinbase-series-e-funding/
- UncleMeat 8y agoGoogle's market cap is 850B. The existence of some very successful companies in crypto does not mean that Google made a mistake by not jumping on that train.
- plorkyeran 8y agoRaising a bunch of money at a high valuation isn't enough to make a company "very successful" either.
- mrb 8y agoCoinbase grew from zero to an $8B valuation in just over 6 years. If that isn't "very successful", what is? ;)
- plorkyeran 8y agoGetting to the point where you don't have to sell off parts of your company to get the cash to sustain your growth. Coinbase is certainly on a nice trajectory, but assuming your goal is to build a real business you haven't succeeded yet if you're still talking about your funding rounds rather than how much money you made last year.
- nostrademons 8y agoThey made a billion dollars in revenue in 2017 and about $520M in 2018, in the midst of a massive bear market. For a company whose primary product is software and doesn't need to worry about cost-of-goods-sold the way that sharing economy companies do. Supposedly they made $450M in profit. They're doing way better than Uber and Lyft are, which continue to lose money even after going public.
- pcwalton 8y agoGoogle also grew to dominate the browser market during 2011-2015.
- nostrademons 8y agoThrough Chrome, which was started internally in 2006 and launched externally in 2008. Though that also was one of those projects where Larry sponsored a couple of talented engineers behind Eric's back and they put out something awesome.
- CydeWeys 8y agoBehind Eric's back? A company that has tens of thousands of employees and you think the co-founder would have to hide a small initial implementation of a project he believed in?
- Judgmentality 8y agoThere's no way Google had tens of thousands of employees in 2006. Although it was probably large enough (between 5,000 and 10,000) that your point still stands.
- lkhAL 8y agoAbsolutely. If it isn't hidden, the developers will have to deal with management, credit taking, metrics, attempts to squash the project, jealousy from other employees, unreasonable pressure (surely a browser can be written in 3 months ...) and being treated as a cost center. All this would happen even if backed by Larry. It is a miracle that new projects happen at all in companies, though Google of course actually bought many successful projects.
- trophycase 8y agoYes it is quite amazing how they have almost complete browser dominance and video content creation/hosting dominance as well as search dominance but are unable to come up with even a simple in browser tipping system to hedge against the downfall of their almost entirely ad based revenue.
- pishpash 8y agoCorporations are not meant to disrupt themselves. It just doesn't happen.
- robotresearcher 8y agoNetflix did.
- compiler-guy 8y agoApple disrupted itself at least twice. macOS are the Apple II series iPhone clobbered the iPod.
- NikkiA 8y agoBoth of those are examples of parallel product groups that eventually migrated one set to the other. The Apple II product line lasted until 1992, by which point the Mac product line had become affordable to the people at which the apple 2 line had been marketed. The iPod continued as the iPod classic and iPod touch products until 2015, nearly 10 years after the iPhone was released.
- omarchowdhury 8y agoYou're assuming that an "in browser tipping system" is a viable hedge to the also assumed downfall of their ad based revenue.
- trophycase 8y agoWell Patreon is proving to be somewhat successful, I don't see why something similar, or donation/tipping shouldn't be easy to incorporate.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- davidcbc 8y ago> they're not even attempting to play in the cryptoverse. They aren't even attempting to play in snake oil or astrology either
- KeenFox 8y agoCrypto is 99% woo, but the 1% is interesting. The interesting stuff isn't world-stompingly amazing, so it gets less press. I like the idea of someday being able to take pennies worth of payments from places where transaction fees alone at traditional payment processors represent a huge % of income. Bitcoin won't be the one to do it, but some of the coins that depend on something other than proof of work might. At least I hope it's not Bitcoin. The power use is obscene.
- golergka 8y agoI'd say it's 80% woo, 1% of what you call interesting and 19% is solving real user problems with breaking the law. Mostly transactions that you can't depend on banks for - like buying drugs.
- themacguffinman 8y agoI think being able to make small transactions with low fees is a human economic problem, not a technical one. How would crypto do anything better or differently, other than the idea of "let's spend power on proof of work instead of trust" which you seem to dislike?
- lugg 8y agoPenny payments will never* be viable. * Never say never. Basically I don't think it could possibly be viable because it would require the total cost of transaction to be less than pennies. That includes the shopkeepers time to manage the automated store, the electricity used in the transaction, and a bunch of other non zero components. Hell even transactions with real pennies today are almost a net loss. We eradicated 5c coins in NZ because they cost something like 6c to make. And to be clear I understand you mean micropayments in general and maybe it is something possible im just not yet convinced the electricity costs will allow it unless it's subsidized in an unsustainable way.
- cc439 8y ago>they're not even attempting to play in the cryptoverse. Which is a good thing considering how much of the population's life is already intertwined with and recorded by Google. I can't imagine anything more dystopian than a Google issued currency.