4 ms·
They give up their autonomy in moderation - Github will now have the power to say "you are not allowed to contribute to Apache projects". This will lead to a)
by im3w1l 8y ago
They give up their autonomy in moderation - Github will now have the power to say "you are not allowed to contribute to Apache projects". This will lead to
a) Github will have leverage over the project.
b) They make themselves vulnerable to the outrage du jour. If an outrage mob forms against someone in the Apache Project, Github may kick them off their platform - they are known to have done so in the past. Apache will then have to decide what to do. The path of least resistance will be to just let them go.
People who anticipate such a course of events will have to live in constant fear of all their effort coming to waste and their community being pulled from them by an outsider. And people who anticipate such fear may never join in the first place.
- wDcBKgt66V8WDs 8y agoTo all you who think this idea is unfounded or dramatic, remember that this is the entire point of FOSS. Whether this idea holds water is irrelevant, it's aligned to FOSS and it's strange that they don't appear to care or have valued other things over it.
- RhodesianHunter 8y agoIt's likely that they care, but consider the provable improvement in contributions to open source and thus a demonstrable benefit to the community to be worth more than a theoretical possible eventuality that most would consider unlikely at best.
- cndx 8y agoAll projects that I have closely observed that went to GitHub for FOMO have NOT gotten more contributions afterwards. Among the real reasons are: 1) Every OSS project has its bureaucrats who contribute a modest amount of code but want to have an immodest amount of power. For these bureaucrats GitHub is like heaven: They appear productive, have power to silence discussions etc. 2) They work for someone or know someone who is associated with GitHub or in the Microsoft embracing strike force. 3) Legitimate reason: They want to show their employers a metric how much they contribute. I'm pretty cynical about the current state of OSS. Major idealistic contributions are a thing of the past. It is all about attaching oneself to a project, get hired somewhere and then stop contributions.
- ultim8k 8y agoHmm based on this, the .org tld and the server providers can have control over the project too. Right? If so, we should use an open source distributed protocol.
- progval 8y agoFor what it's worth, the conditions for termination from the Public Interest Registry (.org's registry) are slightly better than Github. PIR has a five-items list of possible reasons: https://pir.org/policies/org-idn-policies/takedown-policy/ https://pir.org/policies/org-idn-policies/takedown-policy/ while "GitHub reserves the right to refuse service to anyone for any reason at any time."
- int_19h 8y ago"Deems necessary, in its discretion ... to protect the integrity and stability of the registry" sounds extremely vague, though.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y ago> Hmm based on this, the .org tld and the server providers can have control over the project too. Right? No, pretty obviously not. For the domain, this has already been answered. For the servers, it's trivial to move your setup to a different hoster with no visible effects to the outside. > If so, we should use an open source distributed protocol. Like ... git and email? Yeah, we should.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoGit and email isn't sufficient, surely you need a repository as well, a listserver in your implementation I guess?
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y ago
- skybrian 8y agoEven if it were true, this isn't the "entire point", or at least not to everyone. You're talking about communities that have diverse interests, and only a subset of those people are into avoiding all dependency on commercial software in the FSF or Debian sense. "FOSS" includes Windows developers, Mac developers, iOS developers, Java developers, people working for bigtech corporations, and some bigtech firms themselves. (Some parts of these firms some of the time, anyway.)
- jraph 8y agoit seems you confused commercial with non free software. Java may be a commercial product, but it is also free software and the FSF and Debian are happy with that. They do not reject commercial software quite the contrary. That said, your point still stands.
- gstein67 8y agoThat is simply not true. Please take your conspiracy theories elsewhere. Apache maintains clones of all our GitHub org's repositories. GitHub has no leverage over our repositories. We have a fallback mechanism for contributors to push to our server, if they deny GitHub T&Cs. Apache has the support of GitHub and Microsoft, from the CEOs of both, and through the organizations. -- Greg Stein
- im3w1l 8y agoI don't think it's a conspiracy theory, these things happen all the time. I'm very glad to hear of the fallback mechanism.