4 ms·
I'm genuinely interested in understanding what you have to say. It's difficult to understand though, since the only difference in our situations seems to be tha
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I'm genuinely interested in understanding what you have to say. It's difficult to understand though, since the only difference in our situations seems to be that you want to use plastic bags and I don't.
I have a diagnosis of atypical cystic fibrosis. I'm going to take a wild guess and assume you do not. Germ control is a really, really big thing in my life.
It is very possible that we are all missing something integral to your overall argument
If you will read my comments more closely, you might realize that I'm usually not making an argument. It's other people who turn it into an argument.
My first comment was merely an observation, not an argument. The fact that most people here are framing it as an argument to be won is precisely the problem.
It is possible to talk to someone with no goal of proving a particular point. It's called conversation. When done right, it can add information to the system that improves decision making.
But that can't happen as long as the entire fucking world sees a different experience and different point of view as a threat to their precious status quo that must be shot down before it has any hope of taking root.
- mikekchar 8y ago> But that can't happen as long as the entire fucking world sees a different experience and different point of view as a threat to their precious status quo that must be shot down before it has any hope of taking root. And now I invite you to try to understand my feelings. If you want it not to be "the whole fucking world" to shoot someone down simply because they have a different experience and different point of view, it's really got to start somewhere. You might keep in mind that my initial interaction in the conversation was an offer to try to understand your point of view.
- seer 8y agoA genuine question - can’t you buy a stack of plastic bags and just bring some of them with you? When they introduced the ban on plastic bags in my country, it was more a ban on supermarkets selling them alongside your normal purchase, but you still can buy a stack of a few hundred in speciality shops, and just use that. And if you forget to bring your own you can always buy the pristine reusable ones at a small cost. At least here thats how a lot of people protested the ban for a few years - just brought they’re own plastic bags. Maybe they are banned outright? No way to “smuggle in” a stack or something?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoOne of the issues is that most disabled people are also poor. Their disability simultaneously imposes extra expenses and tends to limit earning capacity. Most of the replies here are genuinely not interested in understanding the reasons this stuff is a hot button topic in disabled circles. I'm basically being grilled on the assumption that: A. I'm too stupid to have thought of any obvious solutions being proposed here and this don't have actual legitimate reasons for my preferences. B. I owe the entire world justification for my preferences. C. I speak for and represent the entire disabled community on all topics, even ones I'm only passingly familiar with because they don't happen to be big issues for me in specific. Bags aren't banned where I currently live. They are banned in California. I was living there at the time that they were banned. I was also homeless at the time. People are equally aggressively dismissive of comments I make about the bag ban being a burden on the poorest of the poor. Poor people, disabled people and women seem to all be equally dismissed. And then folks just can't seem to understand the rage some folks in those populations feel about various things. Which is like wow. Seriously?
- 9HZZRfNlpR 8y agoBut plastic bags in bulk are very very cheap. For American living standards it's not even worth a discussion. I'm very sorry you have to live with that horrible disease but the solution is very simple.
- Dylan16807 8y agoLet's back up a bit. Earlier, you made a post where the whole end chunk was about how going without plastic bags assumes the use of a car. Then someone disagreed, with detailed examples about how it's not dependent on a car. You interpreted this as condescension and not trying to understand you. What the hell? They were disagreeing with a part of your argument that wasn't about you at all, since you don't have a car. They weren't dismissing you because of anything you are. Also, being able to name a way a policy hurts some particular poor or disabled person doesn't mean it's overall bad for that group. For example: Plastic bags can hurt some poor people that can't easily use alternatives. But when bags aren't free then groceries themselves will be slightly cheaper. This will benefit a different subset of poor people. Sometimes other people want to add nuance, too. Disagreement with part of what you say is not dismissing you.