6 ms·
The difference with farmers and other occupations is that there's such a strong emotional bond. The land has been in the family for generations. Failure is si
by rmason 8y ago
The difference with farmers and other occupations is that there's such a strong emotional bond. The land has been in the family for generations. Failure is simply not an option. When the end comes some can't emotionally handle it.
A steelworker or a coal miner may feel sadness at fifty that they have to start over, but they always saw the mill or mine as a necessary evil. The best option they had to provide for their family.
I have a friend who told me the story of his great grandfather losing a piece of his farm in the depression. My friend said we waited eighty years but we've brought it back into the family where it has always belonged. He got into an auction with a neighbor and clearly overpaid but he was so joyful. Almost like he paid a ransom to get his own child back.
But the rest of us better be grateful that they do it. The hours suck, the risk is high and the pay is low. If there wasn't such a strong emotional bond we'd pay a lot more for our food just to get people to do it.
- floren 8y agoAh but this is HN. Do you know about the farm lobby? I hear it's big, and unlike the Silicon Valley lobbyists it's bad. Also Monsanto exists (well, they haven't been called Monsanto for some time, but whatever) so it's basically for the best if farmers kill themselves.
- rexpop 8y agoYour lazy comment is in bad faith.
- floren 8y agoThe top-rated comment on this article, describing how obviously farmers aren't really committing suicide because a survey was bad, that's in bad faith.
- dang 8y agoPerhaps, but please don't respond to bad comments with more bad comments. That only makes this place worse. The site guidelines point another way: Be kind. Don't be snarky. Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. Maybe you don't owe another commenter better, but you owe this community better. And if you know some truth that others don't know, you owe the truth better, too: to help people understand it instead of discrediting it and giving them a reason to dismiss it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mdorazio 8y ago> The hours suck, the risk is high and the pay is low. If there wasn't such a strong emotional bond we'd pay a lot more for our food just to get people to do it. Are you sure about that? Median farm household income is way higher than normal median household income [1] and farmers get a huge amount of subsidies at the state and federal level. [1] https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/farm-economy/farm-sector-income-finances/highlights-from-the-farm-income-forecast/ https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/farm-economy/farm-sector-inc...
- floren 8y ago> In recent years, slightly more than half of farm households have had negative farm income and therefore rely on off-farm income to support their well-being
- mdorazio 8y ago1) A huge number of farmers deliberately run their farms to try to show a net loss for tax reasons. 2) You're going to have to explain what off-farm jobs all these farmers have that provide them with 3-4x the median income in the places where they live, but somehow they have really rough lives because they own a farm.
- Spooky23 8y agoYou need to really know the stats to understand them. Big Midwest corn operations are like oil. They rake it in when prices are high and crash hard when they fall. Smaller family operations from 100-1000 acres are all dying or dead now. In the 1970s, a 50 acre dairy operation was a viable business. Today, forget it.
- mdorazio 8y agoThat would explain average income being high, but not median. It's also household income, not corporate.
- darpa_escapee 8y ago
- analog31 8y agoI have some friends who are small family farmers. God it's tough. I think part of the problem is an ingrained social expectation that success in farming stems from hard work. But work is no match for the efficiency of capital and the economy of scale. As a result, the small farms are being driven under. There's a huge social stigma attached to losing a farm -- you didn't work hard enough. My one friend pays more for his material inputs (seeds, fertilizer, etc.) and gets paid less for his crop, than the bigger farms. He's got about a hundred side hustles going. Like you say about the emotional bond, I know at least two people who live on roads named after their families.
- agumonkey 8y agoI still fantasize about an in-between solution where farmers could do normal work and enjoy just a bit more predictable output. Large scale seems to bring as many problems as benefits and it's quite soul-less. I'd give up a bit of my diet if I had to.
- christkv 8y agoCo-ops maybe I don’t understand why they are not more prevelant
- jdietrich 8y agoThis emotional attachment to the land creates a fundamental economic problem - inelasticity of supply. The uncomfortable reality is that the US is making too much food and has too many small farmers. Federal and state governments spend billions of dollars on farming subsidies, they create indirect subsidies through programmes like crop insurance, bioethanol mandates and food aid, but it still isn't enough to keep small farms profitable. Unless we introduce some kind of guaranteed minimum income for farmers, their long-term prosperity depends, sadly, on farm closures. We simply have more farmers and more small farms than the market can possibly sustain.
- coderintherye 8y agoPartially true, but partially not. If everyone grows the same crops then yes. However, there is quite a market for farmers to switch in to more esoteric crops that fetch a premium. However, this requires exposure to new markets, risk, and learning new things. Case in point is hemp, which I grow, and is quite a profitable crop. Eventually, it won't be, but for right now it's something that a lot of farmers could be switching in to and making better money.
- cageface 8y agoWhat are the commercial uses for the hemp you grow? I notice hemp seeds are becoming a lot more popular as a natural protein & healthy fat source.
- 8y ago
- skybrian 8y agoI understand how it happens, but it's unhealthy to tie your self-worth to a business that much. Just because people do it doesn't mean it's right. What is anyone doing to help them get out of it? Is there anything out there for recovering farmers?
- nitrogen 8y agoWhat is self-worth worth if it's not attached to anything though?
- autogn0me 8y agoI would imagine he is referring to attaching your self-worth to external objects. External objects can change and if you lose such an anchor that you have made a pillar of identity - one can become destabilized. Some personalities/mind can't "pull up" (out of it) and frequently suffer the Porkins fate (death, suicide, depression, etc).
- Simon_says 8y agoIt’s called self-esteem and when over abundant it’s awful.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mreome 8y agoA family farm is a bit more than a business though. It's someones career, skill set, home, upbringing, lifestyle and local culture. It's all encompassing in a way that differs from most other businesses and careers. How do you recover from the failure of something so central to your life and so central to who you are?
- wutbrodo 8y ago> The hours suck, the risk is high and the pay is low. If there wasn't such a strong emotional bond we'd pay a lot more for our food just to get people to do it. I'm not sure this is the case. It seems like we'd just move even further towards large agribusiness and automation and away from the mythos of the yeoman farmer. Agriculture is far from a free market, and this nostalgia is one of the reasons why (along with more concrete, rational reasons like national security). The idea that a reduction in labor supply would cause prices to rise isn't as much of a given in a market like this, especially after the market shifts to adjust. I find it very hard to believe that the type of family farmer-owner you describe is a necessary pillar of our food production system.
- JackFr 8y ago> But the rest of us better be grateful that they do it. Why? Why is working in agriculture more praiseworthy than in a service job?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoAt a fundamental level, because we all need to eat. My wife and I can cut each others' hair (though we may be less than pleased with the results), but I can't grow enough food for us.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y agoWe all need to eat. But we don't all need to eat food produced by small farms. We all need to wear clothes, but we don't all need hand-stitched wool coats. We all need shelter, but we don't all need bespoke architecture and locally sourced organic timber framing. I think I understand the sentiment, but I don't agree with it. I am not grateful to small farmers, at least, not especially. I suppose I'm glad that everyone is playing their part, but I feel this way about anyone contributing to our society. They sell nothing that I cannot get just as good and cheaper from large and industrial farms. I work on something that I would argue many people "need" in their life. But I don't expect anyone to be grateful to me. Of course they shouldn't. I'm doing my work for my own benefit, mostly. I think very little about the end users whose lives are made slightly easier by my work. I am certainly not doing my work out of a sense of altruism toward their well-being. I suspect that most farmers are the same. The production is too far removed from the consumption. This is not therapy, massage, teaching, or housekeeping. This is business. To the extent small farmers do think of me, I hope they realize that I would rather pay a dollar less for the same eggs, even if it means they don't get to keep working their ideal job. It's a little sad, but I have bills, and childcare, and rent to pay. Those things are no less important than the expenses of a farmer.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoI primarily meant farmers in general, not small farmers (though that may have been an error, given the context). But you might want to re-think your position, because you can also be on the receiving end. That big egg grower? He may feed the chickens exotic chemicals if it means they lay more frequently, in order to produce your one-dollar-cheaper eggs. Those same chemicals may reach any females in your household, either through the eggs or the groundwater, and may do interesting things to their monthly cycles. And so on with other chemicals and other kinds of farmers. It might be worth a buck to support smaller farmers, presuming that they see their customers as human beings who can't be fed that stuff.
- justin66 8y ago> The difference with farmers and other occupations is that there's such a strong emotional bond. The land has been in the family for generations. Failure is simply not an option. When the end comes some can't emotionally handle it. I wonder if there is anything more emotionally negative about losing a farm than losing any other multigenerational family business.
- mohn 8y agoFarms tend to be lived on. When a farm is lost, it's not just the family business going, but the longtime family home and maybe recreation area. I'd think it's more emotionally negative than the closure of the family mine, steel mill, or other such businesses where (typically) you don't have generations of children growing up on-site, playing around, and developing fond childhood memories. It's not just the dangerous workplaces that will have a reduced family connection when compared to a farm. Generations of kids probably won't spend as much time in the family medical clinic, law office, bank, design firm, etc. as they would on the family farm. Maybe this is closer to the emotional negativity of losing a farm: after clientele dwindles, the multigenerational family restaurant with an upstairs flat has to be sold off. The family must move away, and now the space is an Applebee's.
- justin66 8y agoPeople lose their homes during times of financial turmoil all the time, and it's not a happy thing for anyone. It's possible this is all different for farmers, but the simplest explanation is that these farmer-specific explanations are all speculation based on the mythology surrounding farming. The thing about farmers' suicide rates being uniquely bad has been debunked a bit, although the numbers are undeniably quite bad. It just seems to me a lot of unnecessary speculative baggage is being added onto the whole thing for some reason.