3 ms·
I'm curious why you'd say something so completely wrong so authoritatively. Please do share your motivations and thoughts if you would. The countless deaths by
by rjf72 7y ago
I'm curious why you'd say something so completely wrong so authoritatively. Please do share your motivations and thoughts if you would. The countless deaths by scurvy are some of the most well documented there are. Especially during the age of sail death by scurvy was a regular and inevitable part of attrition. The convenient thing here is that these deaths would occur at sea, or recently at sea, and are heavily documented through captains'/physicians'/etc logs. Literally just about any captain's log from this era and an international voyage will reference large numbers of deaths from scurvy. It was a normal part of attrition.
As literally every single source you might find will affirm this, I'm at a loss for what to cite. Here [1] is a source that seems well written and informative, including some of the countless first person accounts as well. You can also look up the voyages of any famous trader/explorer/voyager you might be aware of. For instance Vasco de Gama, Magellan, Columbus, etc - you'll find horrid tales of rampant scurvy when you actually look into their voyages.
[1] - https://www.sciencehistory.org/distillations/magazine/the-age-of-scurvy https://www.sciencehistory.org/distillations/magazine/the-ag...
- nradov 7y agoPopulations were much smaller then, and only a small fraction of the population went on sailing voyages long enough to suffer from scurvy. So your estimate of millions of deaths from scurvy is implausible on the face of it.
- rjf72 7y agoOf course I agree with you. I was initially quite surprised to discover how many deaths it caused. It's a world we can't even imagine when good chunks of your crew dying was just a regular part of a job. But of course intuition should never replace facts. Maybe next time a more productive idea would be to ask for a source? I'm certain you're far from the only person who found the fact surprising!